This paper compared differences attributable to RNA extraction method and inclusion of a deparaffinization step on RNA yield, integrity and amplificability. RNA was extracted from cores of a formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimen of myometrium and a fundic mucosa specimen using four different kits with and without a deparaffinization step.
Comparing RNA extraction protocols from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded microcore samples.
Golias M, Krupova Z, Defrenaix P, Heymann MF, Heymann D
Purpose
Conclusion
RNA was obtained from both FFPE specimens using all five kits. RNA yields and integrity (DV200) were higher from the fundic mucosa than the myometrium specimen. The lowest RNA yields were obtained using the Nucleospin Total RNA FFPE Kit and the highest using the PureLink Kit with deparaffinized specimens. While deparaffinized specimens generally led to higher yields and DV200 values for the myometrium specimen, effects were less clear for the fundic mucosa specimen. RNA integrity (DV200) was lowest when extraction was with the RNeasy Kit followed by the truXTRAC Kit. RNA obtained from myometrium specimen using the RNeasy Kit was more degraded when the deparaffinization step was ommitted, but deparaffinization did not affect DV200 when extraction was with the other kits evaluated. Calculation of RNA integrity numbers was possible for all RNA extraction methods/kits except the RNeasy Kit. While cycle threshold (CT) values did not differ among RNA extraction kits for fundic mucosa, RNA extracted using the NucleoSpin Kit or RNeasy Kit from deparaffinized or non-deparaffinized myometrium generally yielded higher CT values than extraction using the truXTRAC Kit, but significance depended on the amplicon analyzed.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared differences attributable to RNA extraction method and inclusion of a deparaffinization step on RNA yield, integrity and amplificability. RNA was extracted from cores of a formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimen of myometrium and a fundic mucosa specimen using four different kits with and without a deparaffinization step. A FFPE block containing normal uterus and one containing stomach were obtained from the Institut de Cancérologie de l’Ouest (ICO) tissue library. Microcores (200 μm) of the fundic mucosa of the stomach and myometrium were obtained using Alpha Metrix Manual Tissue Arrayer. RNA was extracted from case-matched deparaffinized and non-deparaffinized FFPE cores using the Nucleospin Total RNA FFPE XS, Quick-RNA FFPE MiniPrep, PureLink FFPE Total RNA isolation, RNeasy FFPE, and truxTRAC FFPE RNA microtube Column Purification Kits, with inclusion of a 4 h proteinase K digestion and DNase 1 treatment. RNA was quantified with a fluorometer and RNA integrity was assessed using the RNA 6000 Pico Kit. Levels of GAPDH, POLR2A and PGK1 were quantified by real-time PCR of 47 bp and 85 bp fragments, respectively.
Summary of Findings
RNA was obtained from both FFPE specimens using all five kits. RNA yields and integrity (DV200) were higher from the fundic mucosa than the myometrium specimen. The lowest RNA yields were obtained using the Nucleospin Total RNA FFPE Kit and the highest using the PureLink Kit with deparaffinized specimens. While deparaffinized specimens generally led to higher yields and DV200 values for the myometrium specimen, effects were less clear for the fundic mucosa specimen. RNA integrity (DV200) was lowest when extraction was with the RNeasy Kit followed by the truXTRAC Kit. RNA obtained from myometrium specimen using the RNeasy Kit was more degraded when the deparaffinization step was ommitted, but deparaffinization did not affect DV200 when extraction was with the other kits evaluated. Calculation of RNA integrity numbers was possible for all RNA extraction methods/kits except the RNeasy Kit. While cycle threshold (CT) values did not differ among RNA extraction kits for fundic mucosa, RNA extracted using the NucleoSpin Kit or RNeasy Kit from deparaffinized or non-deparaffinized myometrium generally yielded higher CT values than extraction using the truXTRAC Kit, but significance depended on the amplicon analyzed.
Biospecimens
TissueStomachTissueUterusPreservation Types
FormalinDiagnoses
NormalPlatforms
RNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNAFluorometryRNAReal-time qRT-PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Biospecimen location Fundic MucosaMyometriumAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Nucleospin total RNA FFPE XS KitPureLink FFPE Total RNA Isolation KitQuick-RNA FFPE MiniPrep KitRNeasy FFPE KITtruxTRAC FFPE RNA microtube Column Purification KitAnalyte Extraction and Purification Deparaffinization DeparaffinizedNon-deparaffinized