This paper investigated the effects of storage on the DNA yield, integrity and next-generation sequencing (NGS) profile of case-matched CytoRich Red-fixed cytology and formalin-fixed, paraffin- embedded (FFPE) endometrioid carcinoma resection specimens by comparing results before and after storage for 15-45 months and between specimen types. Cytology specimens were stored at 4°C, but the FFPE storage conditions were not specified.
Endometrial Liquid-Based Cytology Specimens Preserve High Genome Quality for Molecular Classification After Long-Term Storage.
Akahane T, Kitazono I, Tanimoto A, Higashi Y, Kobayashi H, Yokoyama S
Purpose
Conclusion
In a preliminary study that compared CellPrep, ThinPrep, SurePath, and CytoRich Red fixed HEC-251 cells (an endometrial carcinoma cell line) stored for 1 week, 6 months and 12 months, DNA suitable for NGS was obtained from all specimens, and there were no effects of storage or fixative type on tumor mutation burden (TMB) or microsatellite instability (MSI) scores. DNA concentration was lower and the DNA quality score (DNA QC, difference in cycle threshold, CT, value for the 200 bp amplicon versus the 100 bp amplicon) was higher (indicating increased degradation) in FFPE endometrial carcinoma specimens stored for 15 to 45 months (storage conditions not specified) than in case-matched specimens that were not stored (P=0.0105 and P<0.001, respectively); however, the DNA QC remained below the 0.04 threshold for NGS in all FFPE specimens even after storage. The DNA yield from cytology specimens was also lower after storage (P=0.0061), but the DNA QC score of DNA isolated from cytology specimens was unaffected by 4°C storage and remained below the 0.04 threshold, indicating that all specimens were suitable for NGS. After storage, the C>T transition frequency increased in FFPE specimens (P<0.0001), but not in cytology specimens. The TMB and MSI scores before and after storage were modestly correlated in FFPE specimens (R2=0.61 and R2=0.51) and very strongly correlated in cytology specimens (R2=0.93 and R2=0.92, respectively), but variability in MSI scores was much higher in FFPE specimens than cytology specimens. While storage did not affect the classification of ultrahigh TMB specimens, the MSI classification of three FFPE specimens changed after storage (two mismatch repair deficient (MMRd) MSI high to low and one DNA polymerase epsilon mutation ( POLEmut ) MSI-low to high). Importantly, the detected gene mutations were similar between case-matched FFPE and cytology specimens.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of storage on the DNA yield, integrity and NGS profile of case-matched CytoRich Red-fixed cytology and FFPE endometrioid carcinoma resection specimens by comparing results before and after storage for 15-45 months and between specimen types. Twelve endometrial cytology specimens were collected using a Endocyte sampler, fixed in CytoRich Red and processed using a BD SurePath liquid-based Pap Test System and stored at 4°C. Case-matched surgically resected endometrium (1-4 specimens/patient) specimens were fixed with neutral buffered 15% formalin for 24 h, paraffin-embedded, and sections were immunohistochemically and H&E stained. DNA was extracted from three to six 10 µm FFPE sections (additional details not provided) and quantified using the Qubit dsDNA BR assay Kit and quality was evaluated using the QIAseq DNA QuantiMIZE Kit. The difference in CT value between the 200 bp amplicon and the 100 bp amplicon (DNA QC) was calculated; DNA QC values <0.04 were considered suitable for NGS. Gene mutations were identified using the QIAseq Gynecological Cancer Panel version 2 and a MiSeq instrument using case-matched peripheral blood specimens as a reference. The TMB was characterized as low (< 42), high (≥ 42), or ultrahigh (≥ 72) and the MSI was considered low (< 13) or high (> 13).
Summary of Findings
In a preliminary study that compared CellPrep, ThinPrep, SurePath, and CytoRich Red fixed HEC-251 cells (an endometrial carcinoma cell line) stored for 1 week, 6 months and 12 months, DNA suitable for NGS was obtained from all specimens, and there were no effects of storage or fixative type on tumor mutation burden (TMB) or microsatellite instability (MSI) scores. DNA concentration was lower and the DNA quality score (DNA QC, difference in cycle threshold, CT, value for the 200 bp amplicon versus the 100 bp amplicon) was higher (indicating increased degradation) in FFPE endometrial carcinoma specimens stored for 15 to 45 months (storage conditions not specified) than in case-matched specimens that were not stored (P=0.0105 and P<0.001, respectively); however, the DNA QC remained below the 0.04 threshold for NGS in all FFPE specimens even after storage. The DNA yield from cytology specimens was also lower after storage (P=0.0061), but the DNA QC score of DNA isolated from cytology specimens was unaffected by 4°C storage and remained below the 0.04 threshold, indicating that all specimens were suitable for NGS. After storage, the C>T transition frequency increased in FFPE specimens (P<0.0001), but not in cytology specimens. The TMB and MSI scores before and after storage were modestly correlated in FFPE specimens (R2=0.61 and R2=0.51) and very strongly correlated in cytology specimens (R2=0.93 and R2=0.92, respectively), but variability in MSI scores was much higher in FFPE specimens than cytology specimens. While storage did not affect the classification of ultrahigh TMB specimens, the MSI classification of three FFPE specimens changed after storage (two mismatch repair deficient (MMRd) MSI high to low and one DNA polymerase epsilon mutation (POLEmut) MSI-low to high). Importantly, the detected gene mutations were similar between case-matched FFPE and cytology specimens.
Biospecimens
CellEndometriumTissueUterusPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
DNAReal-time qPCRDNAFluorometryDNANext generation sequencingPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Method of cell acquisition Cytology specimenBiospecimen Acquisition Method of tissue acquisition Surgical resectionBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Cytorich red preservative fluidFormalin (buffered)Storage Storage duration 0 months15-45 months