This paper compared the DNA fragment size, amplifiability, next-generation sequencing metrics (read counts, coverage uniformity, A>G and C>T transition mutation rates, fragment length and variant allele frequencies (VAF)) between formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) and frozen tumor specimens. The effects of tumor type (hepatocellular carcinoma versus endometrial carcinoma), duration of FFPE block storage (collected 2018-2024) and inclusion of a PreCR repair step for DNA from FFPE specimens were also investigated.
A nanoscale quality control framework for assessing FFPE DNA integrity in cancer research.
Huang Z., Si Y, Zhang Y, Huang Z, Song P, Wang Y, Wang Y., Fan C, Xiu X
Purpose
Conclusion
Compared to frozen specimens, FFPE specimens had shorter DNA (<340 nm or 1000 bp versus >340 nm or 1000 bp), higher cycle threshold (CT) values that indicates less amplifiable DNA, and no discrete bands observable by SDS-PAGE. Further, the percentage of amplifiable DNA for FFPE specimens decreased with amplicon length, resulting in positive values for the difference between the cycle CT value for the 260 bp amplicon and the 50 bp amplicon (ΔCT L/S), which confirmed increased fragmentation. The ΔCT L/S was significantly higher in FFPE specimens collected pre-2023 than in frozen specimens. DNA fragmentation (decreased DNA length and higher ΔCT L/S) increased with the duration of FFPE block storage, with no significant differences observed in ΔCT L/S between frozen specimens and FFPE specimens collected in 2024. FFPE hepatocellular carcinoma specimens collected in 2024 had a higher ΔCT than FFPE endometrial carcinoma specimens (MD=1.218, P=0.015) collected in 2024, which the authors state indicates that FFPE processing effects are specific to tumor type. When analysis of ΔCT values was limited to a single specimen type, results matched the degradation as observed by electrophoresis.
FFPE specimens had lower mean read counts and read count uniformity than frozen specimens and fewer A>G and C>T mutations. Read count uniformity was higher for FFPE specimens collected in 2024 than those from 2018/2019. PreCR treatment increased read count for loci with negligible or undetectable reads but decreased read count percentage for loci that had high read counts when untreated. PreCR treatment also reduced the prevalence of A>G and C>T mutations in FFPE specimens, but both mutations were still more prevalent than in frozen specimens. Compared to FFPE specimens collected in 2024, those collected in 2018 had shorter average fragment length in WES libraries (225 versus 215 bp), more mutations at a variant allele frequency (VAF) of 35.8-56%, and fewer mutations at a VAF of <35.8%. Further, read density in low-depth regions (50-150 reads) with a GC content between 0.4-0.6 was higher for the 2018 FFPE specimen than the 2024 FFPE specimen, which the authors state may be due to preferential sequencing of more degraded DNA fragments in the 2018 specimens. In contrast, read density in higher depth regions (150-400 reads) was higher for the 2024 FFPE specimen than the 2018 FFPE specimen, which the authors state is reflective of the reduced amplification efficiency of 2018 specimens.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the DNA fragment size, amplifiability, next-generation sequencing metrics (read counts, coverage uniformity, A>G and C>T transition mutation rates, fragment length and variant allele frequencies (VAF)) between formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) and frozen tumor specimens. The effects of tumor type (hepatocellular carcinoma versus endometrial carcinoma), duration of FFPE block storage (collected 2018-2024) and inclusion of a PreCR repair step for DNA from FFPE specimens were also investigated. This study used 33 FFPE blocks containing endometrial carcinoma, 11 FFPE blocks containing hepatocellular carcinoma and 4 paired frozen endometrial carcinoma specimens collected between 2018 and 2024 (details of processing and storage not specified). DNA was extracted using the QIAamp DNA FFPE Tissue Kit and aliquots are repaired using the New England Biolabs PreCR Repair Mix. DNA was quantified fluorometrically and adjusted to 20 ng/µL. DNA was evaluated by electrophoresis and real-time PCR amplification of 50 and 260 bp amplicons. An additional 26 SNPs were investigated in DNA from 5 frozen and 8 FFPE specimens by multiplex PCR amplification of 100–180 bp amplicons and targeted sequencing. For whole exome sequencing (WES), DNA from one FFPE specimen collected in 2018 and one collected in 2024 was sheared, end-repaired, A-tailed and then captured using biotin-labelled probes and streptavidin-coated beads and amplified (further details not provided). Libraries were then sequenced using the Illumina platform.
Summary of Findings
Compared to frozen specimens, FFPE specimens had shorter DNA (<340 nm or 1000 bp versus >340 nm or 1000 bp) and higher cycle threshold (CT) values, indicating less amplification. Further, CT values increased with amplicon length for FFPE specimens, confirming increased fragmentation. SDS-PAGE gels revealed that FFPE DNA did not form discrete bands and was generally much smaller (included fragments <100 bp) while frozen DNA had discrete bands >1000 bp. The authors report DNA fragmentation (decreased DNA length and higher CT values) increased with FFPE block storage duration. The FFPE specimen had only 23.3% of the amplifiable DNA of frozen specimens based on the 50 bp amplicon, which was reduced to 0.3% when based on the 260 bp amplicon. As expected, the CT value for the long (260 bp) amplicon was lower than that for the short amplicon (50 bp) for reference or frozen DNA (ΔCT L/S of -0.07 to -2.0), but CT values for the long amplicon were higher than those for the short amplicon for FFPE specimens (ΔCT L/S of 3.9-5.5), indicating substantial DNA fragmentation in FFPE specimens. While the ΔCT L/S were significantly higher in FFPE specimens collected in 2023, 2019 and 2018 than in frozen specimens (mean difference, MD=3.05, P=0.025; MD=4.82, P<0.001; and MD=6.48, P<0.001, respectively), no such difference was observed for FFPE specimens collected in 2024 (MD=1.59, P=0.459). Further, ΔCT L/S were significantly higher in FFPE specimens collected in 2018 than in 2023 or 2024 (MD=3.43, P<0.001 and MD=4.89, P<0.001, respectively). FFPE hepatocellular carcinoma specimens collected in 2024 had a higher ΔCT L/S than FFPE endometrial carcinoma specimens collected the same year (MD=-1.218, P=0.015), which led the authors to conclude that FFPE processing effects are specific to tumor type. When analysis of ΔCT values was limited to a single specimen type, results matched the degradation as observed by electrophoresis.
Mean read counts and read count uniformity (coefficient of variance, CV and Gini index) were higher for frozen than FFPE specimens (8,155 versus 172, P<0.05; and CV of 1.46 and a Gini index of 0.65 versus CV of 1.53 and a Gini index of 0.69). Read count uniformity was higher for FFPE specimens collected in 2024 than those collected in 2018/2019 (CV of 1.165 versus 1.535, P<0.05 and Gini index of 0.569 versus 0.691, P<0.05). PreCR treatment increased read count for loci with negligible or undetectable reads but decreased read count percentage for loci with high read counts when untreated. PreCR treatment also reduced the prevalence of A>G and C>T mutations in FFPE specimens from 18.02% to 16.81% and from 14.68% to 14.40%, respectively, but both mutations were still more prevalent in FFPE than frozen specimens (14.88% and 13.85%, respectively). The prevalence of G>A mutations was similar across specimen types (FFPE, frozen and repaired FFPE, 14.08-14.94%). The average fragment length in WES libraries was shorter from the 2018 FFPE specimen than from the 2024 FFPE specimen (215 versus 225 bp). More mutations at a variant allele frequency (VAF) of 35.8-56% were found in the FFPE specimen collected in 2018 than the FFPE specimen collected in 2024, although the 2024 specimen had more mutations at a VAF of <35.8%. The read density in low-depth regions (50-150 reads) with a GC content between 0.4-0.6 was higher for the FFPE specimen collected in 2018 than the 2024 specimen; the authors state that this may be due to preferential sequencing of more degraded DNA fragments in the 2018specimen. In contrast, the read density in higher-depth regions (150-400 reads) was higher for the 2024 FFPE specimen than the 2018 FFPE specimen; the authors concluded that this is reflective of the reduced amplification efficiency of 2018 FFPE specimens.
Biospecimens
TissueUterusTissueLiverPreservation Types
FrozenFormalinDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
DNANext generation sequencingDNAReal-time qPCRDNASpectrophotometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition Endometrial carcinomaHepatocellular carcinomaBiospecimen Acquisition Biospecimen location Endometrial carcinomaHepatocellular carcinomaBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)FrozenStorage Storage duration Collected between 2018-2024Next generation sequencing Specific Template modification PreCR repairedUnrepaired