This paper compared cell-free DNA (cfDNA) yields, size profiles, and methylation profiles of case matched urine specimens that were stored for 0, 6 or 72 h either unpreserved or preserved with PAXgene Urine Technology or Streck Urine Preserve.
A comprehensive urine workflow enables robust methylation and fragmentation analysis of cell-free DNA.
Mauger F, Oussada N, Horgues C, Eberhard A, Oman L, Gou M, Lumière K, Mancarella-Langer D, Voss T, McGinn S, Abuja PM, Heitzer E, Deleuze JF
Purpose
Conclusion
The cfDNA concentration was higher when extracted from PAXgene- or Streck-preserved urine than unpreserved urine (3.21±3.97 ng/µL and 2.55±2.78 ng/µL, respectively, versus 0.39±0.83 ng/µL; P<0.0001, both). PAXgene- and Streck-preserved urine specimens had significantly higher concentrations of cfDNA than unpreserved urine at all storage timepoints evaluated (adjusted P<0.01, all). The mean fragment size of DNA from PAXgene- and Streck-preserved urine was longer than that from unstabilized urine (161 bp and 163 bp, respectively, versus 89 bp; P<0.0001, both) and the differences were significant at all storage timepoints evaluated. The cfDNA from the stabilized urine had nucleosomal peaks that were not observed in unstabilized urine. Sufficient DNA for sequencing was available from 29 of 57 of the unstabilized urine specimens; libraries were successfully prepared from 24 of the unpreserved urine specimens. In contrast, all but one Streck specimen and all PAXgene specimens yielded sufficient DNA for sequencing and were successfully sequenced. Library insert sizes, similar to fragment sizes, were longer for stabilized than unstabilized specimens; however, all urine specimens displayed the characteristic 10 bp periodicity. The mapping efficiency, read depth, autosomal coverage and sex chromosome coverage were lower and the duplication rate was higher when unstabilized urine was used instead of the PAXgene or Streck stabilized specimens. The CpG methylation rate was also lower for unstabilized specimens than PAXgene (3.72% versus 60.45%, P=5.8x10-9) or Streck stabilized specimens (3.72% versus 60.81%, 4.98x10-9). Eleven unstabilized urine specimens, including 6 that were stored for 72 h, had a CpG read depth <10 and were excluded from further analysis. CpG methylation rates for the X chromosome were lower in unstabilized urine than stabilized urine, and while they were unaffected by storage of stabilized urine, they decreased in unstabilized urine with longer storage durations. Hierarchical clustering grouped urine specimens by patient source, with the exception of two unstabilized specimens. In principal component analysis (PCA), the first two components accounting for 25.2% of the methylation variance separated stabilized from unstabilized specimens, with stabilized specimens also clustering by patient source. Further analysis of only stabilized specimens clustered all specimens by patient source except for one (a Streck 72 h specimen). There were no sites that were differentially methylated when PAXgene and Streck specimens were compared, but 2,430 and 1,792 sites were significantly differentially methylated when unstabilized urine and PAXgene and Streck urine were compared, respectively. Importantly, many of the sex-based differences in methylation, including those in autosomal genes, were consistently shared across stabilization methods and storage timepoints. Tissue deconvolution analysis of the methylation data showed that white blood cells and spleen were the predominant tissues of origin. Models based on the PAXgene data were the most accurate at gender prediction.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared cell-free DNA (cfDNA) yields, size profiles, and methylation profiles of case-matched urine specimens that were stored for 0, 6 or 72 h either unpreserved or preserved with PAXgene Urine Technology or Streck Urine Preserve. Urine was collected from 20 healthy volunteers (10 men and 10 women, aged 23-34 years) and aliquots were stabilized with PAXgene Urine Technology, Streck Urine Preserve or left unstabilized within 15 min of collection. Urine was stored at room temperature for 0, 6 and 72 h before centrifugation of unstabilized and PAXgene stabilized urine at 1900 g for 15 min followed by 1900 g for 10 min and centrifugation of Streck stabilized urine at 2,680 g for 10 minutes. DNA was extracted from urine using the QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit and stored at -20°C. DNA was quantified with the Qubit 1X dsDNA HS Kit and fragment size was evaluated using the Femto Pulse Instrument. DNA was concentrated using the MinElute 96 UF PCR Purification Kit before sequencing library preparation with the NEBNext Enzymatic Methyl-seqKit and sequencing on a NovaNext 6000 instrument. Data was analyzed using R and Bioconductor.
Summary of Findings
The cfDNA concentration was higher when extracted from PAXgene- or Streck-preserved urine than unpreserved urine (3.21±3.97 ng/µL and 2.55±2.78 ng/µL, respectively, versus 0.39±0.83 ng/µL; P<0.0001, both). PAXgene- and Streck-preserved urine specimens had significantly higher concentrations of cfDNA than unpreserved urine at all storage timepoints evaluated (adjusted P<0.01, all). The mean fragment size of DNA from PAXgene- and Streck-preserved urine was longer than that from unstabilized urine (161 bp and 163 bp, respectively, versus 89 bp; P<0.0001, both) and the differences were significant at all storage timepoints evaluated. The cfDNA from the stabilized urine had nucleosomal peaks that were not observed in unstabilized urine. Sufficient DNA for sequencing was available from 29 of 57 of the unstabilized urine specimens; libraries were successfully prepared from 24 of the unpreserved urine specimens. In contrast, all but one Streck specimen and all PAXgene specimens yielded sufficient DNA for sequencing and were successfully sequenced. Library insert sizes, similar to fragment sizes, were longer for stabilized than unstabilized specimens; however, all urine specimens displayed the characteristic 10 bp periodicity. The mapping efficiency, read depth, autosomal coverage and sex chromosome coverage were lower and the duplication rate was higher when unstabilized urine was used instead of the PAXgene or Streck stabilized specimens. The CpG methylation rate was also lower for unstabilized specimens than PAXgene (3.72% versus 60.45%, P=5.8x10-9) or Streck stabilized specimens (3.72% versus 60.81%, 4.98x10-9). Eleven unstabilized urine specimens, including 6 that were stored for 72 h, had a CpG read depth <10 and were excluded from further analysis. CpG methylation rates for the X chromosome were lower in unstabilized urine than stabilized urine, and while they were unaffected by storage of stabilized urine, they decreased in unstabilized urine with longer storage durations. Hierarchical clustering grouped urine specimens by patient source, with the exception of two unstabilized specimens. In principal component analysis (PCA), the first two components accounting for 25.2% of the methylation variance separated stabilized from unstabilized specimens, with stabilized specimens also clustering by patient source. Further analysis of only stabilized specimens clustered all specimens by patient source except for one (a Streck 72 h specimen). There were no sites that were differentially methylated when PAXgene and Streck specimens were compared, but 2,430 and 1,792 sites were significantly differentially methylated when unstabilized urine and PAXgene and Streck urine were compared, respectively. Importantly, many of the sex-based differences in methylation, including those in autosomal genes, were consistently shared across stabilization methods and storage timepoints. Tissue deconvolution analysis of the methylation data showed that white blood cells and spleen were the predominant tissues of origin. Models based on the PAXgene data were the most accurate at gender prediction.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
PAXgeneStreck/BCTNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
NormalPlatforms
DNANext generation sequencingDNABisulfite conversion assayDNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerDNAFluorometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation None (fresh)PAXgeneStreck cfDNA urine presevativeUrine preservative tubeStorage Storage duration 0 h6 h72 h