This paper compared the quantified levels of four endogenous microRNAs (miRNA, miR) and one spike-in miRNA using real-time PCR and ddPCR in matched K2EDTA and K3EDTA plasma of healthy patients and those with endocrine disorders.
Challenges in circulating miRNA analysis in adrenocortical tumors.
Vékony B, Nyirő G, Butz H, Szeredás BK, Tóth V, Ferdinandy P, Patócs A, Igaz P
Purpose
Conclusion
Using either K2EDTA or K3EDTA plasma, real-time PCR cycle threshold (CT) values were correlated with ddPCR copy numbers for cel-miR-39-3p (K2EDTA: R2=0.871982, P=8.72e-11 and K3EDTA: R2=0.433754, P=0.0016, respectively), miR-16-5p (R2=0.96138, P=8.55e-15 and R2=0.96138, P=1.22e-11, respectively), miR-21-5p (R2=0.877594, P=7.08e-12 and R2=0.900411, P=3.05e-13, respectively) and miR-210-3p (R2=0.37271, P=0.0042 and R2=0.917572, P=5.02e-11, respectively), but no correlation was observed for miR-483-5p. Interestingly, while real-time PCR CT values that were normalized to cel-miR-39p were correlated with the ddPCR copy numbers for each of the four miRNAs when K2EDTA plasma was used (R2=0.2786-0.3691, P<0.05, all), the correlation between normalized real-time PCR CT value and ddPCR copy number was limited to miR-210-3p when K3EDTA plasma was used (R2=0.2359, P=0.0299). Bland-Altman plots revealed that, generally, real-time PCR measured higher levels than ddPCR at the lower end of the quantification range, but ddPCR measured higher levels than real-time PCR at the higher end of the range. Further, the bias associated with the quantification method was generally lower in K2EDTA than K3EDTA plasma and when CT values were normalized to cel-mir-39-3p. There was much more variability in raw CT values and copy numbers in K3EDTA plasma than K2EDTA plasma. Additionally, K3EDTA plasma had higher cel-miR-39-sp normalized (but not raw) levels of miR-16-5p (P=0.008219), and miR-210-3p (P=0.009439), higher raw CT (but not normalized) values for miR-483-5p (P=0.02965) and lower cel-miR-39-3p normalized (but not raw) levels of miR-21-5p (P=0.006142) than K2EDTA plasma. Interestingly, ddPCR levels of each of the five miRNAs were found to be comparable between K2EDTA and K3EDTA plasma.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the quantified levels of four endogenous microRNAs (miRNA, miR) and one spike-in miRNA using real-time PCR and ddPCR in matched K2EDTA and K3EDTA plasma. Blood was collected from 13 healthy volunteers and seven patients with endocrine disorders (diagnosis included primary aldosteronism, idiopathic hypoparathyroidism, nonfunctional pituitary adenoma, and hypothyroidism) into matched K2EDTA Vacutainer and K3EDTA Vacuette tubes. Blood was immediately placed on ice, and plasma was obtained by centrifugation at 1,861 g for 10 min at 4°C. miRNA was isolated from plasma using the miRNeasy Serum/Plasma Kit with the inclusion of cel-miR-39 as a spike-in. Extracted miRNA and plasma were stored at -80°C. RNA was quantified by spectrophotometer. Levels of cel-mir-39-3p, miR-16-5p, miR-21-5p, miR-210-3p and miR-483-5p were quantified using TaqMan real-time PCR assays and by ddPCR using the same TaqMan probes.
Summary of Findings
Using either K2EDTA or K3EDTA plasma, real-time PCR cycle threshold (CT) values were correlated with ddPCR copy numbers for cel-miR-39-3p (K2EDTA: R2=0.871982, P=8.72e-11 and K3EDTA: R2=0.433754, P=0.0016, respectively), miR-16-5p (R2=0.96138, P=8.55e-15 and R2=0.96138, P=1.22e-11, respectively), miR-21-5p (R2=0.877594, P=7.08e-12 and R2=0.900411, P=3.05e-13, respectively) and miR-210-3p (R2=0.37271, P=0.0042 and R2=0.917572, P=5.02e-11, respectively), but no correlation was observed for miR-483-5p. Interestingly, while real-time PCR CT values that were normalized to cel-miR-39p were correlated with the ddPCR copy numbers for each of the four miRNAs when K2EDTA plasma was used (R2=0.2786-0.3691, P<0.05, all), the correlation between normalized real-time PCR CT value and ddPCR copy number was limited to miR-210-3p when K3EDTA plasma was used (R2=0.2359, P=0.0299). Bland-Altman plots revealed that, generally, real-time PCR measured higher levels than ddPCR at the lower end of the quantification range, but ddPCR measured higher levels than real-time PCR at the higher end of the range. Further, the bias associated with the quantification method was generally lower in K2EDTA than K3EDTA plasma and when CT values were normalized to cel-mir-39-3p. There was much more variability in raw CT values and copy numbers in K3EDTA plasma than K2EDTA plasma. Additionally, K3EDTA plasma had higher cel-miR-39-sp normalized (but not raw) levels of miR-16-5p (P=0.008219), and miR-210-3p (P=0.009439), higher raw CT (but not normalized) values for miR-483-5p (P=0.02965) and lower cel-miR-39-3p normalized (but not raw) levels of miR-21-5p (P=0.006142) than K2EDTA plasma. Interestingly, ddPCR levels of each of the five miRNAs were found to be comparable between K2EDTA and K3EDTA plasma.
Biospecimens
FluidPlasmaFluidBloodPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NormalOther diagnosesPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRRNADigital PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Anticoagulant Multiple forms evaluatedPotassium EDTAReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Data handling Normalized to cel-miR-39-3pRaw CTReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Technology platform TaqMan real-time PCRddPCR