Skip to main content

Reducing bias in microbiome research: Comparing methods from sample collection to sequencing.

Kool J, Tymchenko L, Shetty SA, Fuentes S

Publication: Front Microbiol (2023) • Vol 14 • Page 1094800PMID: 37065158View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the microbiome of case-matched fecal specimens that were immediately frozen with those that were stored for 3-5 days at room temperature either without preservation, in Zymo tubes (containing DNA/RNA shield), or in OMNIgene GUT tubes (containing stabilization buffer) by next-generation sequencing (NGS). Potential effects of lysis method, DNA extraction method, DNA input amount, the number of PCR cycles, DNA extraction in one versus multiple instrument runs, and using one set of barcodes or multiple sets on the fecal microbiome were also examined. 
 

Conclusion

Although the Shannon index, Observed taxa, and Simpson’s indices were not affected by the use of stabilization solutions during fecal storage, nor did they differ between collection cohorts, clustering based on principal coordinate analysis (PcoA) was driven by cohort and to a lesser extent use of OMNIgene GUT tubes. Consequently, additional comparisons were limited to matched specimens within individual cohorts. Differences in the relative abundance of phyla and taxa were observed between frozen specimens and case-matched specimens that were stored for 3-5 days without buffer, in Zymo, or in OMNIgene GUT tubes. 

For fecal specimens that were frozen without buffer, DNA yields (total and bacterial) were higher using both kits when lysis was with beads rather than proteinase K buffer, but there was no clear difference between the two extraction kits. In contrast, for fecal specimens frozen in Zymo buffer,  DNA yields (total and bacterial) were higher when DNA was extracted using the Maxwell RSC Fecal Microbiome DNA Kit than the Maxwell RSC Blood DNA Kit, but no clear effect of lysis method was observed. Shannon index, Observed taxa, and Simpson’s indices were unaffected by DNA extraction kit or lysis method, but PcoA based on the Bray–Curtis distance showed an effect of lysis method. Differences at the phyla level were noted between lysis methods for each extraction kit, but not between extraction kits for specimens lysed using either method. Using mock community samples (commercially available combinations of bacterial strains) the correlation with the known composition was the strongest when mechanical disruption was combined with the Maxwell RSC Fecal Microbiome DNA Kit. DNA input and the number of PCR cycles did not affect the Shannon index, Observed taxa, Simpson’s indices, or Bray–Curtis distances, but a higher number of PCR cycles resulted in the detection of microbial reads in negative controls. Divergence in Bray-Curtis distances were smaller when the same bar-codes were used than when different barcodes were used and when extraction occurred in one run versus different runs, but the differences were only significant when a mix of five specimens was used, not mock communities.
 

Studies (2)

Purpose

This study compared the microbiome of case-matched fecal specimens that were immediately frozen with those that were stored for 3-5 days at room temperature either without preservation, in Zymo tubes (containing DNA/RNA shield), or in OMNIgene GUT tubes (containing stabilization buffer) by next-generation sequencing (NGS). Fecal specimens from 12 healthy volunteers were aliquoted and matched specimens were frozen immediately at -80°C or stored at room temperature for 3–5 days without buffer or in Zymo tubes before freezing. Fecal specimens from 64 participants in the PIENTER study (diagnosis not specified) were aliquoted and matched specimens were frozen immediately at -80°C or collected in OMNIgene GUT tubes and stored at room temperature for 3–5 days before freezing. DNA was extracted by lysis (unclear if it was mechanical or enzymatic) followed by purification using the Maxwell RSC Fecal Kit. DNA was quantified by fluorometer and by real-time PCR amplification of the 16S rRNA gene. Libraries were constructed by V4 amplicon PCR and sequenced on a MISeq Instrument.
 

Summary of Findings

Although Shannon index, Observed taxa, and Simpson’s indices were not affected by the use of stabilization solutions during fecal storage (OMNIgene or Zymo), nor did they differ between collection cohorts clustering based on PcoA was driven by cohort (R2=0.026; P=0.001) and to a lesser extent use of OMNIgene GUT tubes (R2=0.020; P=0.002). Consequently, additional comparisons were limited to matched specimens within individual cohorts. Compared to specimens frozen immediately, those that were stored for 3-5 days at room temperature without buffer had fewer firmicutes (P=0.000488) and  more proteobacteria (P=0.000488) and verrucomicribiota (P=0.0143), and specimens stored for 3-5 days at room temperature in Zymo tubes had more bacteroidota (P=0.000488) and proteobacteria (P=0.00342) and fewer actinobacteriota (P=0.000488). Compared to specimens frozen immediately, those stored for 3-5 days at room temperature in OMNIgene GUT tubes had fewer firmicutes (P=0.0025) and actinobacteriota (P=7.87e-5) and more bacteroidota (P=2.32e-9), and proteobacteria (P= 2.91e-6). At the taxa level, there were differences between frozen specimens and specimens stored for 3-5 days without preservation or in Zymo or OMNIgene GUT tubes, but the differences were specific to the tube type. More taxa were differently expressed between frozen specimens and matched specimens stored at room temperature in OMNIgene GUT tubes than between matched frozen specimens and those stored at room temperature without buffer or in Zymo tubes. 

  • Biospecimens

    FluidFeces
  • Preservation Types

    FrozenOther Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    Normal
    Not specified
  • Platforms

    DNANext generation sequencing
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Frozen
    OMNIgene GUT
    Zymo DNA/RNA Shield
    StorageTime at room temperature
    0 days
    3-5 days