Skip to main content

Performance comparison of fecal preservative and stock solutions for gut microbiome storage at room temperature.

Park C, Yun KE, Chu JM, Lee JY, Hong CP, Nam YD, Jeong J, Han K, Ahn YJ

Publication: J Microbiol (2020) • Vol 58 • Page 703-710PMID: 32583287View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the microbiome of fecal specimens stored at room temperature for up to 65 days in NBgene-Gut tubes, OMNIgene-Gut tubes, 70% ethanol, or RNAlater with those of specimens from the same three volunteers that were frozen immediately.

Conclusion

The number of distinct features, Chao1 index, Shannon’s index, and Simpson’s index in specimens preserved in NBgene-Gut tubes, OMNIgene-Gut tubes, 70% ethanol, or RNAlater were each comparable to those in frozen specimens, regardless of storage time at room temperature. Principal component analysis (PCA) based on Bray-Curtis distances or unweighted uniFrac distance clustered specimens by volunteer source, not preservative or storage duration.  No significant effects of storage duration on the microbial profile were observed. Differences in the microbial profile among the preservatives at the phyla, family, and genus level were observed, but significance depended on volunteer source and preservative Generally, differences in the microbial profile between frozen and preserved/stored specimens were more likely to be significant when specimens were stored in RNAlater or 70% ethanol, and microbial profiles were more similar to frozen specimens when feces were stored in NBgene-Gut tubes or OMNIgene-Gut tubes.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared the microbiome of fecal specimens stored at room temperature for up to 65 days in NBgene-Gut tubes, OMNIgene-Gut tubes, 70% ethanol, or RNAlater with specimens from the same three volunteers that were frozen immediately. Fecal specimens were collected from three healthy Korean adults (two men and one woman; 20-40 years of age) and mixed for homogeneity. Triplicate specimens of 30 g were frozen at -80°C while from the remainder of the specimen 1 g was placed in each of the following: a NBgene-Gut tube, an OMNIgene-Gut tube, a tube containing 70% ethanol, or a tube containing RNAlater. Tubes were stored at room temperature for 2, 15, 30, 45, and 65 days before freezing at -80°C. DNA was extracted using a modified protocol and  the QIAamp DNA stool MiniKit and evaluated using PicoGreen (yield) and Nanodrop (purity). Sequencing libraries were prepared according to the Illumina 16S Metagenomic Sequencing Library protocol and sequenced on a MiSeq instrument. Microbial 16S rRNA sequencing data was analyzed using QIIME 2.

Summary of Findings

The number of distinct features, Chao1 index, Shannon’s index, and Simpson’s index in specimens preserved in NBgene-Gut tubes, OMNIgene-Gut tubes, 70% ethanol, or RNAlater were each comparable to those in frozen specimens, regardless of storage time at room temperature. PCA based on Bray-Curtis distances or unweighted uniFrac distance clustered specimens by volunteer source, not preservative or storage duration; however, the Bray-Curtis distances increased non-significantly with storage while still maintaining the clustering by volunteer. Compared to matched frozen specimens, the relative abundance of Bacteroides was lower in specimens from one volunteer and higher in specimens from the other two volunteers when preserved in 70% ethanol (P<0.05) and higher in specimens from one of the three volunteers when preserved with OMNIgene-Gut (P<0.05) or RNAlater (P<0.05). Compared to matched frozen specimens, the relative abundance of Firmicutes was higher in specimens from one volunteer when preserved in 70% ethanol (P<0.05) and lower in specimens from another volunteer when preserved in OMNIgene-Gut (P<0.05) or RNAlater (P<0.01). The relative abundance of Proteobacteria was higher in OMNIgene-Gut(P<0.001) or RNAlater (P<0.05) preserved specimens than in matched frozen specimens from a single volunteer. The relative abundance of at least one of the thirteen microorganism families investigated was affected by each of the preservatives, with specimens preserved in 70% ethanol or RNAlater among the most affected. In specimens from two volunteers, relative Taxa abundance was most affected when specimens were preserved in 70% ethanol or RNAlater and were least affected when preserved in NBgene-Gut or OMNIgene-Gut, but the abundance of more taxa were affected in specimens from the third volunteer, regardless of preservation. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering based on the relative abundance of the 25 genera clustered specimens by volunteer source. Among specimens from one volunteer, the genera profile differed significantly in specimens preserved in 70% ethanol and frozen specimens, but the differences were not significant among specimens from the other two patients.  

  • Biospecimens

    FluidFeces
  • Preservation Types

    FrozenEthanolOther PreservativeRNAlater
  • Diagnoses

    Normal
  • Platforms

    DNANext generation sequencing
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Ethanol
    Frozen
    NBgene
    OMNIgene GUT
    RNAlater
    StorageTime at room temperature
    0 days
    15 days
    2 days
    30 days
    45 days
    65 days