This paper compared the yield, purity, amplifiability, and sizing accuracy of DNA extracted after blood or blood peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were stored at room temperature, 4°C, or -80°C for 24 h or 8 days; comparisons for the same endpoints were drawn after 0, 5 and 10 freeze thaw cycles of blood or PBMC, after storage of saliva and buccal swabs at room temperature for 8 days and 8 months, and after storage of extracted DNA from PBMC, blood, saliva and buccal swabs at room temperature, 4°C and -30°C for 0 and 12 days.
Preanalytical DNA assessment for downstream applications: How to optimize the management of human biospecimens to support molecular diagnosis-An experimental study.
Mordenti M, Capicchioni V, Corsini S, Locatelli M, Abelli E, Banchelli F, Boarini M, Sangiorgi L
Purpose
Conclusion
The authors report that each of the tested storage temperatures/durations allowed for isolation of DNA of suitable quantity, quality, and reproducibility for molecular analysis, but PBMCs were more sensitive to storage than whole blood, saliva, or buccal swabs. Among whole blood specimens, the highest DNA yields were obtained from whole blood that was stored at room temperature or 4°C (versus-80°C) for 24 h (versus 8 days) that did not experience freeze-thaw cycling (versus 5 cycles). Amplifiability of extracted DNA was highest in blood stored for 8 days (versus 24 h) at room temperature (versus -80°C and 4°C), although storage duration and condition did not affect DNA purity. Among PBMC, the highest DNA yields were obtained when PBMCs were stored at 4°C (versus room temperature or -80°C), and among samples that did not experience freeze-thaw cycling (versus 5 or 10 times); like whole blood, DNA amplifiability was highest when PBMCs were stored for 8 days (versus 24 h) at room temperature (versus -80°C and 4°C). The percentage of DNA specimens with an absorbance at a ratio of 260/280 nm that was classified as good (between 1.8 and 2.0) was higher in PBMCs that were not freeze-thaw cycled compared to those that were cycled 5 or 10 times. Among saliva and buccal specimens, the highest DNA yields and amplifiability were obtained following specimen storage at room temperature for 8 months versus 8 days. While the purity of DNA isolated from buccal swabs was not affected by storage, the percentage of DNA specimens with an absorbance at a ratio of 260/280 nm that was classified as good (1.8 - 2.0) was higher when saliva was stored at room temperature for 8 months versus 8 days. DNA yield decreased when it was extracted from blood, PBMCs, saliva, or buccal swabs experience that were stored at -30°C versus room temperature or DNA isolated from blood, PBMCs, or saliva that were stored at 4°C versus room temperature. Similarly, DNA amplifiability was higher when DNA was extracted from blood, saliva, and buccal swabs stored at room temperature versus -30°C and when extracted from buccal swabs stored at room temperature versus 4°C. The accuracy of DNA amplification sizing was not affected by storage of blood, PBMC, saliva or buccal swabs specimens or the extracted DNA.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the yield, purity, amplifiability, and sizing accuracy of DNA extracted from blood and PBMCs that were stored at room temperature, 4°C and -80°C for 24 h and 8 days and subjected to 0, 5, and 10 freeze-thaw cycles; saliva and buccal swabs that were stored at room temperature for 8 days and 8 months; and storage of DNA samples at room temperature, 4°C and -30°C for 0 and 12 days that were isolated from PBMC, blood, saliva and buccal swabs specimens. Peripheral blood (45 specimens), saliva (15 specimens), buccal swabs (15 specimens), and/or PBMC (22 specimens) specimens were collected from a total of 82 participants (5-70 years of age, no diagnosis was specified). Peripheral blood was collected in EDTA tubes and PBMCs were isolated from an aliquot using a Ficoll gradient. Saliva was collected using the OG-500 Kit and buccal swabs specimens were collected using the OG-575 Kit. Whole blood and PBMC aliquots were stored at room temperature, 4°C, and -80°C for 24 h and 8 days, and freeze-thaw cycled 0, 5, and 10 times (from room temperature to -80°C) over the course of 8 days prior to DNA extraction. Saliva and buccal swabs were stored at room temperature for 8 days and 8 months before DNA extraction. DNA was extracted from blood using the Genfind v2 DNA Purification System on a Span-8 Laboratory Automation Workstation, from PBMCs using the ReliaPrep Blood gDNA Miniprep System, and from saliva/buccal swabs using the prepIT L2P Oragene-DNA/Saliva Kit. Extracted DNA was stored at room temperature, 4°C, and -30°C for 0 and 12 days before analysis. DNA yield and purity were assessed by spectrophotometer; DNA integrity was analyzed by gel electrophoresis; and, amplifiability was quantified by real-time PCR amplification of a 195 bp fragment of β-actin. Amplification sizing accuracy was evaluated by amplification of 688, 366, and 182 bp fragments of β-actin and analysis of the products by electrophoresis and bioanalyzer.
Summary of Findings
The highest DNA yields from whole blood specimens were obtained following specimen storage at room temperature as opposed to 4°C for 24 h (P=0.004) or 8 days (P<0.001) or -80°C for 8 days (P<0.001). From PBMC specimens, higher yields were obtained from specimens stored at 4°C as opposed to room temperature for 24 h (P=0.002) or 8 days (P<0.001); however, the DNA yields were higher when PBMC specimens were stored at room temperature as opposed to -80°C for 8 days (P<0.001). While DNA yields were comparable from blood that was not frozen or freeze-thaw cycled 10 times, DNA yields were lower from blood that was freeze-thaw cycled 5 times than blood that was not frozen (P<0.0001) and from PBMCs that were freeze-thaw cycled 5 or 10 versus compared to PBMCs that were not frozen (P<0.001). DNA yields from saliva and buccal swabs were lower when specimens were stored at room temperature for 8 months compared to those stored for 8 days (P<0.001, both). DNA yields were lower when DNA isolated from blood, PBMCs, saliva or buccal swabs was stored at -30°C relative to DNA stored at room temperature (P=0.035, P<0.001, P<0.001 and P<0.001, respectively). Similarly, DNA yields were also lower when DNA isolated from blood, PBMCs, or saliva was stored at 4°C relative to DNA stored at room temperature (P=0.002, P<0.001, and P<0.001, respectively). DNA purity was largely unaffected by storage temperature or duration; however, the percentage of DNA specimens with an absorbance at 260/280 nm ratio that fell between 1.8 and 2 was higher among saliva specimens that were stored at room temperature for 8 months compared to 8 days (P=0.006) and was higher in DNA from PBMCs that were not frozen compared to those that were freeze-thaw cycled 5 or 10 times (P=0.046 and P=0.014, respectively).
DNA amplifiability was higher following storage of blood or PBMCs for 8 days at room temperature when compared to those stored at -80°C (P<0.001, both) or 4°C (P=0.008 and P<0.001, respectively), or when blood or PBMC specimens were stored for 8 days compared to those stored for 24 h at room temperature (P<0.001, both), or when blood was stored at 4°C for 8 days compared to blood stored for 24 h (P=0.002); DNA amplifiability was unaffected by freeze-thaw cycling of blood or PBMC specimens. Similarly, amplifiability decreased when saliva and buccal swabs specimens were stored for 8 months at room temperature compared to those stored for 8 days (P<0.001). Amplifiability was when extracted DNA from blood, saliva and buccal swabs was stored at room temperature compared to DNA samples that were stored at -30°C (P=0.018, P=0.002, and P=0.002, respectively). Amplifiability was also higher when DNA isolated from buccal swabs was stored at room temperature compared to DNA samples stored at 4°C (P=0.012). The accuracy of amplification sizing was unaffected by storage of blood, PBMCs, saliva or buccal swabs or storage of the isolated DNA. The authors conclude that each of the tested storage temperatures/durations allow for isolation of DNA of suitable quantity, quality and reproducibility for molecular analysis, although PBMCs are more sensitive to storage than whole blood, saliva or buccal swabs.
Biospecimens
CellBuccalCellWhite CellsFluidBloodFluidSalivaPreservation Types
None (Fresh)FrozenOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
DNASpectrophotometryDNAElectrophoresisDNAReal-time qPCRDNAPCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Biospecimen location BloodBuccal swabsPBMCSalivaStorage Freeze/thaw cycling 0 cycles10 cycles5 cyclesStorage Storage conditions As blood, PBMC, buccal swabs or salivaAs extracted DNAStorage Storage duration 24 h versus 8 days8 days versus 8 monthsStorage Storage temperature Room temperature versus 4°C and -30°CRoom temperature versus 4°C and -80°C