This paper compared the yield of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and mononucleosomal DNA (100-300 bp) among saliva specimens collected in three different tube types (Oragene OG-600, Norgen cfDNA 5cc and conical tubes) and stored for up to 168 h at room temperature before extraction using three different kits (DNA Genotek prepIT, DNeasy Blood & Tissue and QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kits). The authors also investigated the effect of freezing saliva on dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA yields and saliva storage at room temperature on the levels of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), dsDNA, total genomic DNA, microbial DNA and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Finally, the authors compared human papillomavirus (HPV) detection in matched saliva and plasma of three patients with HPV-positive oropharyngeal carcinoma.
Isolation of salivary cell-free DNA for cancer detection.
Brooks PJ, Malkin EZ, De Michino S, Bratman SV
Purpose
Conclusion
The highest yield of dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA were obtained from saliva collected in Oragene OG-600 tubes; the authors found that use of Oragene tubes attenuated most of the effects of storing saliva at room temperature. While the greatest yield of dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA was obtained with the DNA Genotek prepIT Kit, the mean fragment size of mononucleosomal DNA was larger and the effects of saliva storage were much greater than when extraction was with the QIAamp Kit. Consequently, the authors identified the pairing of collection in Oragene tubes and extraction with the QIAamp Kit as being the optimal choice. dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA yields and mononucleosomal DNA fragment lengths were unaffected by storage of saliva for 2 weeks at -80°C and thawing compared to DNA that was extracted from fresh saliva. Levels of ssDNA, dsDNA, total genomic DNA and spiked-in HPV16 DNA were unaffected by storage of saliva in Oragene tubes at room temperature for 168 h, but increased levels of microbial DNA and mtDNA were observed in specimens stored for ≥48 h. HPV DNA was detected in the saliva of all three patients with HPV-positive oropharyngeal carcinoma but was detected in the matching plasma of only two patients.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the yield of dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA (100-300 bp) among saliva specimens collected in three different tube types (Oragene OG-600, Norgen cfDNA 5cc and conical tubes) and stored for up to 168 h at room temperature before extraction using three different kits (DNA Genotek prepIT, DNeasy Blood & Tissue and QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kits). The authors also investigated the effect of freezing saliva on dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA yields and saliva storage at room temperature on the levels of ssDNA, dsDNA, total genomic DNA, microbial DNA and mtDNA. Finally, the authors compared HPV detection in matched saliva and plasma of three patients with HPV-positive oropharyngeal carcinoma. Unless otherwise specified, saliva was collected from 1-4 healthy volunteers into Oragene OG-600, Norgen cfDNA 5cc, and conical tubes. Saliva specimens were collected at the same time of day at least 30 min after eating or drinking. Saliva was centrifuged at 300 x g for 20 min followed by 10,000 x g for 20 min, and DNA was extracted using the QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit. Double-stranded (ds) and single-stranded (ss) DNA were quantified using Qubit assays. DNA fragment size distribution was analyzed using a bioanalyzer. DNA <300 bp and >300 bp were isolated using AMPure XP magnetic beads. Nuclear DNA was quantified by real-time PCR amplification of LINE-1. Mitochondrial, microbial and HPV DNA were quantified by droplet digital PCR amplification of NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase chain 1 (MTND1), the microbial 16s rRNA gene, and HPV16 E6 and E7, respectively. Potential effects of collection container were investigated by collecting saliva from a single volunteer into Oragene OG-600, Norgen cfDNA 5cc, and 15 mL DNAse/RNAse-free conical tubes and storing the specimens at room temperature for 0, 2, 12, 24, 48, 72, or 168 hours. To investigate the effects of DNA extraction method, the saliva was collected from four volunteers and specimens were stored in Oragene tubes for 0, 2, 24, 48 and 168 h at room temperature before DNA extraction with the DNA Genotek prepIT, DNeasy Blood & Tissue and the QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kits. To investigate the effects of freezing, saliva from three volunteers was collected in Oragene tubes and DNA was extracted immediately or after 2 weeks at -80°C using the QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit. To investigate the effect of delayed processing on the types of DNA present in saliva, saliva was collected from three healthy volunteers and DNA was extracted immediately and after 2, 24, 48 and 168 h at room temperature. To investigate the effects of storage on detection of HPV16 DNA, saliva from three healthy volunteers was spiked with HPV16 DNA and stored for up to 168 h at room temperature. To compare HPV16 fragment size in plasma and saliva, blood and saliva specimens from three patients with HPV-positive oropharyngeal carcinoma were collected in Streck Cell-Free DNA BCT and Oragene tubes, respectively.
Summary of Findings
A higher yield of dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA (100-300 bp) were obtained from saliva collected in Oragene OG-600 or Norgen cfDNA 5cc tubes than conical tubes and from Oragene OG-600 tubes than Norgen cfDNA 5cc tubes, respectively. dsDNA levels declined drastically when saliva was stored at room temperature in Norgen or conical tubes, with loss of almost all DNA after 48 h. In contrast, only small declines in dsDNA (5.7%/day) and mononucleosomal DNA were found when saliva was stored in Oragene OG-600 tubes. In saliva specimens from all four patients, the greatest yield of dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA was obtained with the DNAGenotek prepIT Kit. The mean fragment size of mononucleosomal DNA was smallest than when extracted with QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit (169±4 bp versus 207±4 bp with DNA Genotek and 201±4 bp with DNeasy). When saliva was stored for 168 h at room temperature prior to extraction, the amount of dsDNA isolated was non-significantly lower, regardless of extraction kit, compared to saliva specimens that were analyzed immediately; considerable loss of mononucleosomal DNA was observed following extraction with DNA Genotek (-92.6±3.0%) or DNeasy kit (-93.6±2.9%, P=0.003), but not QIAamp (-21.9± 8.6%, P=0.0005). dsDNA and mononucleosomal DNA yields and mononucleosomal DNA fragment lengths were unaffected by storage of saliva for 2 weeks at -80°C and thawing compared to DNA extracted from fresh saliva. Levels of ssDNA, dsDNA, and total genomic DNA were unaffected by storage of saliva in Oragene tubes at room temperature for 168 h, but increases in microbial DNA and mtDNA were observed in specimens from all three volunteers when saliva was stored for ≥48 h. Spiked-in HPV16 DNA copy number was unaffected by storage of saliva in Oragene tubes at room temperature for 168 h. HPV DNA was detected in the saliva of all three patients with HPV-positive oropharyngeal carcinoma, but was detected in the matching plasma of only two patients. The majority of detectable HPV DNA fragments were smaller than 300 bp in two of the three saliva specimens (99.4 and 86.6%, respectively), while HPV DNA fragments <300 bp only represented 24% of the DNA in the third specimen.
Biospecimens
FluidSalivaFluidPlasmaPreservation Types
FrozenOther PreservativeNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
NormalNeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
DNAReal-time qPCRDNADigital PCRDNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerDNAFluorometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Biospecimen location PlasmaSalivaBiospecimen Acquisition Type of collection container/solution 15 mL DNAse/RNAse-free conical tubesNorgen cfDNA 5cc tubesOragene OG-600 tubesStorage Freeze/thaw cycling 0 cycles1 cycleStorage Time at room temperature 0 h168 h2 h24 h48 hAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method DNA Genotek prepIT KitDNeasy kitQIAamp KitDigital PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid HPV16 E6 and E7Microbial (16s rRNA)Mitochondrial (MTND1)