Skip to main content

Supply chain disruptions due to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic lead to an unusual preanalytical error in measuring hemoglobin concentration in a large medical center.

Law SM, Hardy R, Anderson D, Small L, Hurley J, Beggs L, Campbell Y, Olsen M, Mancini-Flegel T, Valentine A, Borowitz MJ, Francischetti IMB

Publication: EJHaem (2022)PMID: 36718355View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this paper was to systematically identify the cause of a high level of variability observed between repeat hemoglobin measurements in specimens collected from the same patient within 24 h.  After an initial investigation revealed variability was not due to patient factors (bleeding/transfusion or medication), the authors looked for analytical errors and variations in the blood collection procedure.

Conclusion

During April 2022, the number of potential errors reported to the Hematology Core Lab increased from an average of 2 to 18. All 18 reports indicated variability in hemoglobin levels among specimens collected from the same patient over a short period of time (multiple blood specimens collected over the course of 9 days with some <24 h apart).  Initial analysis eliminated bleeding, transfusion, increased hemolysis, and medications as potential sources of the variability; and analytical errors were excluded by repeat analysis using a different analyzer, a different analytical method, and analysis at a different laboratory. Upon further investigation, the timing of the increase in variability occurred with a change in from using a Vacutainers Luer-Lok Access Device to a Vacutainer Female Luer Adapter blood transfer device when transferring blood from an IV catheter to a K2EDTA vacutainer. This switch necessitated collecting blood from the IV catheter into a syringe and then transferring a small portion into the K2EDTA tube. It was then determined that sedimentation during this additional step resulted in an unequal distribution of red blood cells unless a mixing step was employed. Variability in hemoglobin measurements was largely eliminated once collection into syringes were no longer used to transfer blood specimens from the IV catheter to a K2EDTA vacutainer tube.

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to systematically identify the cause of a high level of variability observed between repeat hemoglobin measurements in specimens collected from the same patient within 24 h. After initial investigation revealed variability was not due to patient factors (bleeding/transfusion or medication) the authors looked for analytical errors and changes in the blood collection procedure. This retrospective study investigated the source of errors in repeat blood specimens collected by central venous catheters from 18 patients.  Each patient had a central venous catheter for the administration of chemotherapy agents but no diagnosis was specified.  Variability in hemoglobin was demonstrated using 9 specimens from one patient and 11 from another that were collected over a 9-day period.  Levels of hemoglobin and blood cell counts were analyzed using multiple Sysmex analyzers and hemoglobin levels were verified using a Radiometer ABL800 Flex device.  

Summary of Findings

During April 2022, the number of potential errors reported to the Hematology Core Lab increased from an average of 2 to 18. All 18 reports indicated variability in hemoglobin levels among specimens collected from the same patient over a short period of time (multiple blood specimens collected over the course of 9 days with some <24 h apart). Importantly, red blood cell count, hematocrit, mean concentration hemoglobin (MCH), mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC), white blood cell count, platelet count, and plasma condition were not affected. Initial analysis eliminated bleeding, transfusion, increased hemolysis, and medications as potential sources of variability. Upon further investigation, it was found that all specimens were obtained by central venous catheters which were in place for chemotherapy.  Analytical errors were deemed unlikely but were investigated.  While four machines were in use, viewing maintenance records, sending a specimen to another laboratory for verification, and comparing results obtained using two different machines and a different analytical method (blood gas analyzer) eliminated analytical error as a potential source of variability.  Upon further investigation, it was revealed that the hospital had switched from collecting blood directly using Vacutainers Luer-Lok Access Devices to using Vacutainer Female Luer Adapter blood transfer devices to collect blood from the IV catheter and transfer it to the K2EDTA vacutainer due to shortages of the former. This switch necessitated collecting blood from the IV catheter into a syringe and then transferring a small portion into the K2EDTA tube. It was then determined that sedimentation during this additional step resulted in an unequal distribution of red blood cells unless a mixing step was employed. The variability in hemoglobin measurements was largely eliminated once collection into syringes were no longer used to transfer blood specimens from the IV catheter to a K2EDTA vacutainer tube.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidBlood
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticNot specified
    Not specified
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeHematology/ auto analyzer
    ProteinHematology/ auto analyzer
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    Central venous catheter
    Syringe draw
    Hematology/ auto analyzer SpecificTechnology platform
    Multiple Sysmex analyzers
    Radiometer ABL800 Flex