The purpose of this paper was to compare detection rate and copy number of human papillomavirus (HPV) and GAPDH in midstream and first void urine, and in case-matched urine stored without preservation, with an in-house urine conservation media (UCM1), and with ProTec. Additionally, the detection and copy numbers of GAPDH and HPV after extraction using five different extraction methods including extraction from the pellet and supernatant were compared.
Optimization of HPV DNA detection in urine by improving collection, storage, and extraction.
Vorsters A, Van den Bergh J, Micalessi I, Biesmans S, Bogers J, Hens A, De Coster I, Ieven M, Van Damme P
Purpose
Conclusion
The highest yield (corrected for urine volume) of both GAPDH and HPV DNA from untreated urine occurred when DNA was extracted from a pellet (formed by centrifugation at 23,000 g) using the QIAamp Kit. However, when UCM1 preserved urine was used the highest yield of GAPDH DNA occurred with the QIAamp Kit while the highest yield of HPV DNA occurred with the filter combined with the QIAamp Kit. When urine was stored for 3-7 days at room temperature, HPV was detected in a significantly higher percentage of UCM1-treated than untreated urine and copy number of HPV and GAPDH were significantly higher in UCM1-treated than untreated urine. However, in detection of HPV and GAPDH was comparable in urine treated with UCM1 and BD Protec prior to being stored at room temperature for seven days. First-void urine was more likely to have increased turbidity and menstrual blood contamination than midstream urine. While GAPDH was detected in all first-void and midstream urine, HPV was detected in nine of ten first void specimens and seven of ten mid-stream specimens. The number of copies of HPV and GAPDH DNA were significantly higher in first-void than midstream urine.
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare detection rate and copy number of HPV and GAPDH in midstream and first void urine, and in case-matched urine stored without preservation, with UCM1, and with ProTec. Additionally, the detection and copy numbers of GAPDH and HPV were compared after extraction with one of five different extraction methods, extraction from the pellet and supernatant were also compared. Urine was collected from 44 women who had a cervical specimen with normal cytology that tested positive for HPV 16 or HPV 18. Urine was aliquoted within 30 min and stored frozen at -20°C. Unless otherwise specified, DNA was obtained by filtration with Amicon Ultra-4 50 K centrifugal filter (4,000 g for 2 min) followed by extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG off-board lysis protocol. DNA was quantified by real-time PCR amplification of GAPDH, HPV 16, and HPV 18. To understand the effects of extraction method, first-void urine was collected from 25 women and stored for 72 h untreated or with UCM1 (a phosphate buffered saline solution containing a chelating agent, a microbicide, a fungicide, and bovine serum albumin) before storage of aliquots at -20°C for 7-90 days and DNA extraction using: (a) QIAamp DNA mini Kit protocol, (b) filtration with Amicon Ultra-4 50 K centrifugal filter (4,000 g for 2 min) followed by extraction with QIAamp DNA mini Kit, (c) centrifugation at 23,000 g for 1 h followed by extraction from the supernatant using the Qiagen DNA mini Kit, (d) centrifugation at 23,000 g for 1 h followed by extraction from the pellet using the Qiagen DNA mini Kit, and (e) extraction with Nuclisens easyMAG Automatic Kit with off board lysis. To further understand the effects of storing first-void urine, specimens were collected from 13 women and aliquots were stored for 7 days with no additive, with UCM1, or with BD Protec before aliquots were stored at -20°C. To test the effect of the timing of collection, first void and midstream urine were collected from 10 women and urine aliquots were treated with UCM1 and immediately frozen at -20°C.
Summary of Findings
When urine was stored at room temperature for 3 days without a preservative, HPV DNA was detectable in 7 (extraction from 23,000 g supernatant) to 19 (extraction from 23,000 g pellet) of the 24 specimens evaluated and GAPDH was detected in 5 (extraction from 23,000 g supernatant) to 23 (extraction from 23,000 g pellet) of the 24 specimens evaluated. Urine stored at room temperature for 3 days with the UCM1 preservative, had a higher fraction of specimens in which HPV was detected (16-21 of 24) and led to detection in all 24 specimens regardless of extraction method. Importantly, the difference in the number of copies HPV and GAPDH DNA between untreated and UCM1 treated urine was significant (P<0.001, both). The highest yield (corrected for urine volume) of both GAPDH and HPV DNA from untreated urine occurred when DNA was extracted from the centrifugation pellet (23,000 g) using the QIAamp kit; however, from UCM1 preserved urine, the highest yield of GAPDH corrected for volume was obtained with just the QIAamp Kit and the highest yield of HPV DNA was with the filter used in combination with the QIAamp Kit. When urine was stored for 7 days at room temperature, HPV was detected in a higher percentage of treated than untreated urine specimens (P≤0.003), with comparable detection in urine treated with UCM1 and BD Protec. While GAPDH was detected in all but one untreated urine specimen, the median number of copies per µL of urine was much lower in untreated urine than UCM1- and BD Protec-treated urine (30 versus 3730 for UCM1 and 1200 for Protec, P≤0.001). First-void urine was more likely to have increased turbidity and menstrual blood contamination than midstream urine. While GAPDH was detected in all first-void and midstream urine, HPV was detected in nine of ten first void specimens and seven of ten mid-stream specimens. The number of copies of HPV and GAPDH DNA were significantly higher in first-void than midstream urine (P=0.008 and P=0.007, respectively).
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
FrozenOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Other diagnosesPlatforms
DNAReal-time qPCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation BD ProtecNone (fresh)UCM1Storage Storage duration 3 days7 daysAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Centrifugation at 23,000 g for 1 h followed by extraction from the pellet using the Qiagen DNA mini kitCentrifugation at 23,000 g for 1 h followed by extraction from the supernatant using the Qiagen DNA mini kitExtraction with Nuclisens easyMAG automatic kit with off board lysisFiltration with Amicon Ultra-4 50 K centrifugal filter (4,000 g for 2 min) followed by extraction with QIAamp DNA mini kitQIAamp DNA mini kit protocolReal-time qPCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid GAPDHHPV (16 and 18)