Skip to main content

Evaluation of Existing Methods for Human Blood mRNA Isolation and Analysis for Large Studies.

Meyer A, Paroni F, Günther K, Dharmadhikari G, Ahrens W, Kelm S, Maedler K

Publication: PLoS One (2016) • Vol 11 • Page e0161778PMID: 27575051View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this paper was to compare RNA purity and yield, and mRNA levels between RNA extracted from blood collected in Tempus and PAXgene tubes using both the Norgen Isolation Kit and the PAXgene RNA isolation Kit.  Potential effects of normalizing real-time PCR data to different housekeeping genes on sialic acid binding Ig-like lectin 7 (SIGLEC-7) variability and RNA quantification method were also investigated.

Conclusion

The average purity of RNA isolated from blood collected in PAXgene and Tempus blood collection tubes was high, regardless of extraction method.  While the Norgen Kit yielded more RNA from Tempus blood than PAXgene blood and the PAXgene Kit yielded more RNA from PAXgene blood than Tempus blood, the magnitude of the differences depended on quantification method.  Similarly, cycle threshold (CT) values depended on extraction method and blood tube type. Despite similar RNA input, Tempus blood had the lowest CT values when extraction was with the Norgen Kit while PAXgene blood had the lowest CT values when the PAXgene RNA Isolation Kit was used. Importantly, without the second DNAse step in the Norgen isolation, amplification of PPIA was observed in non-reverse transcribed negative controls. For RNA extracted using either kit, the lowest variability was observed after normalization to PPIA.

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to compare RNA purity and yield, and mRNA levels between RNA extracted from blood collected in Tempus and PAXgene blood tubes using both the Norgen Isolation Kit and the PAXgene RNA Isolation Kit.  Potential effects of normalizing real-time PCR data to different housekeeping genes on SIGLEC-7 variability and RNA quantification method were also investigated. Blood was collected from 17 healthy volunteers into PAXgene and Tempus blood collection tubes. Potential effects of storage were investigated using matched sets from five volunteers. All specimens were stored at room temperature for 2 h, followed by 4°C for 48 h, and then stored at -80°C. Specimens were thawed on ice and stored for 2 h at room temperature before RNA extraction using the Norgen Biotek RNA Purification Kit I (Tempus) or II (PAXgene) with an additional DNAse digestion step (12 patients) and f using the PAXgene RNA Isolation Kit (5 patients). RNA purity was evaluated by spectrophotometer. RNA yield was quantified by spectrophotometer and RiboGreen fluorometry. Levels of PPIA, tubulin, β-actin, and SIGLEC-7 were quantified by real-time RT-PCR.

Summary of Findings

The average purity of RNA isolated from blood collected in PAXgene and Tempus blood collection tubes was high (A260/A280 of 2.0 and 2.1, respectively).  When two different quantification methods were compared, RNA yield determined by spectrophotometer was 2.5-fold higher than the RiboGreen fluorometry method when blood collected in PAXgene tubes was used for extraction (Norgen Kit I or II), but comparable when blood from Tempus tubes were used.  RNA extracted with Norgen Kits (I and II) was 2.4 higher when blood was collected in Tempus tubes than PAXgene tubes when quantified by spectrophotometer but was 5.4-fold higher when quantified by the RiboGreen fluorometric assay.The CT values for PPIA, tubulin, β-actin, SIGLEC-7 were significantly lower when RNA was extracted (Norgen Kit I and II) from Tempus blood than PAXgene blood, regardless of inclusion of a second DNAse step despite starting with the same RNA input.  Importantly without the second DNAse step in the Norgen isolation protocol, amplification of PPIA was observed in non-reverse transcribed negative controls. For RNA extracted using the Norgen Kit, normalization to PPIA provided a high degree of reproducibility between tube types, but this was not observed when levels were normalized to tubulin, B-actin or a combination of the reference genes.

 Extraction with the PAXgene-specific Kit, resulted in higher RNA yields from PAXgene blood but yielded almost no detectable RNA from Tempus blood. Consequently, when extracted using the PAXgene Isolation Kit, RNA yield was higher in PAXgene blood than Tempus blood (2.9-fold higher by spectrophotometer and 1.6-fold higher by RiboGreen).  Similarly, CT vales for PPIA, tubulin, β-actin, SIGLEC-7 were significantly lower for PAXgene-extracted RNA from PAXgene blood than Tempus blood despite starting with the same RNA input.  Importantly, the CT values for RNA extracted with the PAXgene Isolation Kit from Tempus blood were high (>33) and thus no further analysis was conducted. For RNA extracted from PAXgene blood with the PAXgene Isolation Kit, normalization to PPIA provided the lowest variation in SIGLEC-7 levels for a given donor.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidBlood
  • Preservation Types

    PAXgeneOther Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    Normal
  • Platforms

    RNASpectrophotometry
    RNAReal-time qRT-PCR
    RNAFluorometry
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionType of collection container/solution
    PAXgene system
    Tempus system
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationAnalyte isolation method
    Norgen RNA extraction Kits
    PAXgene RNA extraction Kit
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationNucleic acid digestion
    One step
    Two steps
    Real-time qRT-PCR SpecificData handling
    Normalization to B-actin
    Normalization to PPIA
    Normalization to all three
    Normalization to tubulin
    Spectrophotometry SpecificTechnology platform
    RiboGreen
    Spectrophotometer