The purpose of this paper was to compare microRNA (miRNA, miR) extraction efficiencyfrom plasma, plasma exosomes and urinary exosomes using the miRNeasy, miRCURY and miRCURY biofluids kits. Levels of individual miRNAs quantified by real-time PCR were compared as well as the number of miRNAs detected using low density real-time PCR arrays. The authors also compared the yield, purity and integrity of RNA isolated from different numbers of cultured cells using the miRCURY, miRCURY biofluids, miRNeasy and Trizol Kits.
Assessing cellular and circulating miRNA recovery: the impact of the RNA isolation method and the quantity of input material.
El-Khoury V, Pierson S, Kaoma T, Bernardin F, Berchem G
Purpose
Conclusion
Based on initial experiments with cell lines, the authors determined that while RNA purity was higher when extraction was with the miRCURY Kit, the miRNeasy kit had the highest recovery of miRNA; however, the difference between extraction methods depended on the number of cells used. When extraction was from plasma, levels of the four miRNAs of interested and recovery of the spike-in control were higher and more miRNAs were detected when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit compared to the miRCURY Kit. Mean quantification cycle (Cq) for the four miRNAs of interest did not differ when miRNA was extracted from ≥100µL plasma using either the miRCURY biofluids or miRNeasy kits. Isolation of miRNA from plasma exosomes with the miRNeasy Kit resulted in a trend toward slightly lower Cq values and allowed for detection of more miRNAs than other methods. Similarly, Cq values for the five miRNAs assayed in urine exosomes were lower in two of three specimens and comparable in the third when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit than the miRCURY Kit. Similar to plasma, more miRNAs were detected in urinary exosomes when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit compared to the miRCURY Kit, and the majority of the miRNAs detected were found at higher levels when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit.
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare microRNA (miRNA, miR) extraction efficiency from plasma, plasma exosomes and urinary exosomes using the miRNeasy, miRCURY and miRCURY biofluids kits. Levels of individual miRNAs quantified by real-time PCR were compared as well as the number of miRNAs detected using low density real-time PCR arrays. The authors also compared the yield, purity and integrity of RNA isolated from different numbers of cultured cells using the miRCURY, miRCURY biofluids, miRNeasy and Trizol Kits. Initial experiments were conducted by isolating RNA from cultured A549 cells using the miRNeasy, miRCURY and Trizol Kits. RNA yield and purity were assessed by spectrophotometer and RNA integrity was evaluated by bioanalyzer. Blood was collected from six healthy volunteers into EDTA tubes and plasma was separated by centrifugation at 1000 g for 10 min followed by 2000 g for 10 min and stored at -80°C. Plasma exosomes were isolated by centrifugation at 10,000 g for 50 min, followed by sequential filtration through 1.6 and 0.2 µm pore filters and ultracentrifugation at 100,000 g for 1.5 h, washing in PBS and recentrifugation at 100,000 g for 1.5 h. Midstream urine was collected from three healthy volunteers into containers with a protease Inhibitor and were then aliquoted and stored at -80°C. Urinary exosomes were obtained by centrifugation at 1,000 g for 10 min, 17,000 g for 30 min, resuspended in 20 mmol Tris pH 8.6, centrifugation at 17000 g for 30 min, and ultracentrifugation at 200,000 g for 70 min. RNA was extracted from plasma using the miRNeasy, miRCURY and miRCURY biofluids Kits and from plasma and urinary exosomes using the miRNeasy and miRCURY Kits. Levels of miR106a, miR-222, miR-16 and miR-223 in plasma and plasma exosomes and levels of miR-30c-2-3p, miR-106a, miR-204, miR-222, and miR-141 in urine were assayed by real-time PCR. Levels of 756 miRNA in plasma, plasma exosomes and urinary exosomes were quantified using TaqMan Low Density Arrays.
Summary of Findings
RNA yields from A549 cells were comparable using the miRNeasy and miRCURY Kits, but the Trizol Kit yielded less miRNA when of cells was excessively high (800 x 103); while the yield appeared higher when a lower number of cells was used for input, the authors state this was likely attributable to overestimation as a result of phenol contamination. Supporting this hypothesis, purity (A260/A230 ratio) was low when RNA was isolated using Trizol or miRNeasy Kits, but not the miRCURY Kit. Nevertheless, RNA obtained by all three methods was largely intact (mean RNA integrity numbers, RIN >9.1). Real-time PCR detection of individual miRNAs from a fixed amount of RNA was dependent upon extraction method, the individual miRNA amplified, and number of cells used for input. Extraction efficiency of the miRCURY kit decreased when more cells were used, indicating column saturation. Yields of the smallest RNAs, including miRNAs, were highest when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit. Recovery of the smallest RNAs using miRCURY Kit was dependent on input amount as when a large number of cells were used the miRCURY Kit favored the recovery of large RNAs.
Recovery of miR-106a, miR-222, miR-16, and miR-223 from plasma was higher when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit compared to the miRCURY Kit (P<0.01, P<0.001, P<0.01, and P<0.01, respectively), but quantification cycle (Cq) did not differ based on extraction kit (miRCURY biofluids Kit versus miRNeasy Kit) for any of the four miRNAs quantified. Isolation of miRNA from plasma exosomes with the miRNeasy Kit resulted in slightly lower Cq values than the miRCURY Kit but the differences were not significant. Recovery of the spike-in control (cel-miR-39) from plasma was highest when the miRNeasy Kit was used, followed by the miRCURY biofluids Kit and then the miRCURY Kit (P<0.001 for all comparisons). When extraction was from 50 µL plasma (as opposed to 100 or 200 µL), miRNA recovery was significantly higher with the miRNeasy Kit than either of the miRCURY Kits (P<0.001, both); however, when 100 or 200µL plasma was used as input, the miRCURY biofluids Kit was comparable to the miRNeasy Kit. The kit used for miRNA extraction affected the number of miRNAs identified with a Cq value <35. For example, 313 and 274 miRNAs were identified after miRNA extraction from plasma and exosomes with the miRNeasy Kit, respectively, which decreased to 111 and 178 miRNAs when extraction was with the miRCURY Kit. For the 102 and 150 miRNAs detected in plasma and exosomes, respectively, across all extraction methods, the vast majority had higher Cq when extraction was with miRCURY Kit and in plasma the difference exceeded 5 cycles for >50% of the miRNAs evaluated.
In the exosomes from two of the three urine specimens analyzed, Cq values for all five miRNAs of interest were lower when extraction was with the miRNeasy kit than the miRCURY kit and Cq values were comparable between extractions in exosomes from the third specimen. Similar to plasma, more miRNAs were detected in urinary exosomes at a Cq<35 when extraction was with miRNeasy Kit than the miRCURY Kit (309 versus 241), and the majority of the 229 miRNAs detected across all extraction methods were found at higher levels when extraction was with the miRNeasy Kit.
Biospecimens
FluidPlasmaFluidUrinePreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NormalPlatforms
RNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNASpectrophotometryRNAReal-time qRT-PCRRNALow density arrayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Aliquots and Components Aliquot size/volume 100 µL200 µL50 µLAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Trizol (cell experiments only)miRCURY biofluids kitmiRCURY kitmiRNeasy kit