This paper compared calprotectin levels in matched fecal aliquots and fecal extracts stored at room temperature or 4°C for 0, 4 or 8 days before freezing and subsequent analysis using five different immunoassays.
Impact of Preanalytical Factors on Calprotectin Concentration in Stool: A Multiassay Comparison.
Hamer HM, Mulder AHL, de Boer NK, Crouwel F, van Rheenen PF, Spekle M, Vermeer M, Wagenmakers-Huizinga L, Muller Kobold AC
Purpose
Conclusion
There was considerable variation in quantified levels of calprotectin between the five immunoassays evaluated and between storage temperatures but the significance of differences was dependent on timepoint. Calprotectin levels that were normalized to the baseline specimen (promptly extracted and stored frozen) were stable for 8 days when extracts were stored at 4°C, but were significantly lower in extracts stored for ≥1 day at room temperature and when feces were stored at 4°C for ≥4 days or at room temperature for ≥1 day before extraction. Importantly when broken down by method, calprotectin levels were always most stable when stored as an extract at 4°C and least stable when stored as feces at room temperature.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared calprotectin levels in matched fecal aliquots and fecal extracts that were stored at room temperature or 4°C for 0, 4 or 8 days before freezing and subsequent analysis using five different immunoassays. Nine leftover fecal specimens with different calprotectin levels (100-2000 µg/g) were homogenized with a stick and aliquoted within 24 h of collection at all three analysis centers. Aliquots were frozen at -20°C and distributed among the analysis centers. Centers thawed all aliquots and performed multiple extractions per specimen and immediately froze an extract of each specimen (baseline). Aliquots of the extracts and remaining feces were stored at room temperature and 2-8°C for 2, 3, 4 or 8 days before extraction (fecal specimens only) and freezing at -20°C. All extracts were analyzed in one batch using each immunoassay. Calprotectin levels were quantified using the Sentinel CALiaGold test, ThermoFisher EliA Calprotectin test, Bühlmann fCal turbo, Bühlmann fCAL ELISA, and Inova Quanta Flash. Levels were expressed as percentage recovery relative to the specimen that was immediately extracted and frozen at -20°C and analyzed using the same immunoassay.
Summary of Findings
The levels calprotectin quantified by the five immunoassays varied considerably among baseline specimens, with >2-fold differences between assays for some specimens. Levels of calprotectin also differed significantly when extracts stored at 4°C were analyzed by different immunoassays (P<0.05), but differences between assays were not significant in other specimens after storage. Calprotectin levels (normalized to the baseline specimen, analyzed using the same immunoassay) were stable for 8 days when extracts were stored at 4°C but were significantly lower when extracts were stored for ≥1 day at room temperature and when feces were stored at 4°C for ≥4 days or at room temperature for ≥1 day. Importantly when broken down by immunoassay, calprotectin levels were always the most stable when stored as an extract at 4°C and least stable when stored as feces at room temperature; and, the difference was significant on day 8 of storage for all assays (P<0.05) with the exception of CALiaGold.
Biospecimens
FluidFecesPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
ProteinELISAPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Storage Storage conditions As extractAs fecesStorage Storage duration 0 days1 day2 days4 days8 daysStorage Storage temperature 4°CRoom temperatureELISA Specific Technology platform Bühlmann fCAL ELISABühlmann fCal turboInova Quanta FlashSentinel CALiaGold testThermoFisher EliA Calprotectin test