This paper compared miRNA expression profiles and RNA electropherograms between case-matched formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) and optimal cutting temperature (OCT)-embedded frozen lymph node hyperplasia specimens. Potential correlations between technical replicates of the same RNA extraction, different RNA extractions, and different sections of the same specimen were also investigated.
An array-based analysis of microRNA expression comparing matched frozen and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded human tissue samples.
Zhang X, Chen J, Radcliffe T, Lebrun DP, Tron VA, Feilotter H
Purpose
Conclusion
Sufficient RNA was obtained from all specimens, regardless of preservation. While a clear miRNA peak (18-24 nt) was observed in electropherograms from frozen OCT-embedded specimens, a distinct miRNA peak was not observed in RNA from FFPE specimens. Strong to very strong correlations in miRNA levels were observed between technical replicates, replicate RNA extractions, and between sections of the same frozen OCT-embedded or FFPE specimen. miRNA levels were modestly to strongly correlated between matched frozen and FFPE specimens (Τ = 0.669-0.815, ρ = 0.847-0.948) and generally clustered by patient rather than preservation method in unsupervised clustering. When levels of 30 randomly chosen miRNAs were further investigated, the expression pattern was generally similar in frozen and FFPE specimens and no consistent deviations were observed.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared miRNA expression profiles and RNA electropherograms between case-matched FFPE and OCT-embedded frozen lymph node hyperplasia specimens. Potential correlations between technical replicates of the same RNA extraction, different RNA extractions, and different sections of the same specimen were also investigated. Matched lymph node hyperplasia specimens from seven patients were formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded (FFPE) or embedded in Optimal Cutting Temperature (OCT) freezing medium and stored at -80°C. Specimens were stored for 1-2 years prior to the study but no further details of specimen procurement or preservation were provided. RNA was extracted from OCT-embedded frozen specimens using the miRNAeasy Kit. RNA was extracted from three 20 µm thick xylene-deparaffinized sections of FFPE specimens using the RecoverAll total RNA Isolation Kit. RNA quality was analyzed using a Bioanalyzer. miRNA were labelled using the Agilent miRNA labeling reagent and 470 miRNA were quantified using Agilent human miRNA arrays. Correlations were evaluated using Kendall rank correlation (Τ) and Spearmans Rank correlation (ρ).
Summary of Findings
Sufficient RNA was obtained from all specimens, regardless of preservation method. While a clear miRNA peak (18-24 nt) was observed in electropherograms from frozen OCT-embedded specimens, a distinct miRNA peak was not observed in RNA from FFPE specimens. Strong to very strong correlations in miRNA levels were observed between technical replicates using the same RNA extract from frozen OCT-embedded (Τ = 0.853, ρ = 0.953) or FFPE (Τ = 0.804, ρ = 0.924) specimen, between replicate extractions from the same frozen (Τ = 0.829, ρ = 0.945) or FFPE (Τ = 0.807, ρ = 0.930) section, and between sections of the same frozen (Τ = 0.737, ρ = 0.901) or FFPE (Τ = 0.737, ρ = 0.900) specimen. miRNA levels were modestly to strongly correlated between matched frozen and FFPE specimens (Τ = 0.669-0.815, ρ = 0.847-0.948). Importantly, unsupervised clustering based on miRNA expression generally clustered specimens by patient. When levels of 30 randomly chosen miRNAs were further investigated, expression patterns of frozen and FFPE specimens were generally similar and no consistent deviations were observed.
Biospecimens
TissueLymph NodePreservation Types
OCTFormalinDiagnoses
Other diagnosesNeoplasticNot specifiedPlatforms
RNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNADNA microarrayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Aliquots and Components Biospecimen heterogeneity Representative sections examinedBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)OCTAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Multiple extractions compared