Skip to main content

Extraction-free whole transcriptome gene expression analysis of FFPE sections and histology-directed subareas of tissue.

Trejo CL, Babić M, Imler E, Gonzalez M, Bibikov SI, Shepard PJ, VanSteenhouse HC, Yeakley JM, Seligmann BE

Publication: PLoS One (2019) • Vol 14 • Page e0212031PMID: 30794557View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper investigated the potential effects of formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) block storage, slide deparaffinization, and hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining on gene expression profiles generated with the ligation-based targeted whole transcription expression profiling assay, TempO-Seq.  Potential effects of the tissue area used for the assay and formalin fixation time on TempO-Seq results as well as a cross-platform comparison of TempO-Seq and RNAseq were also investigated using animal models and cell lines.

Conclusion

When a 10 mm2 area of tissue was scraped from 5 µm-thick unstained FFPE tissue sections, 10% of the lysate from the TempO-Seq assay was successfully used for whole transcriptome sequencing. Gene expression profiles of case-matched specimens scraped from serial FFPE slides (biological replicates), were strongly correlated for pancreas (R2=0.916), colorectal (R2= 0.872), and prostate (R2=0.885) tumors. Coefficients of variation (%CV) for genes with ≥10, 50, or 200 counts were lowest among prostate tumor specimens (27.57, 19.96, and 15.33, respectively) and highest for pancreas tumor specimens (33.44, 29.80, and 28.88, respectively).  Deparaffinization did not alter TempO-Seq results; unstained paraffinized slides that were used directly and those that were deparaffinized prior to TempO-Seq analysis generated very strongly correlated gene expression profiles (R2=0.902).  Gene expression profiles of unstained paraffinized FFPE sections and deparaffinized H&E-stained FFPE sections were also strongly correlated (R2=0.855). Archival FFPE specimens stored as blocks for up to 30 y at room temperature and for an additional 2 y as slide-mounted FFPE sections generated 2.1 M mapped reads, which the authors note is sufficient for meaningful analysis.  Gene expression profiles of biological replicates were strongly correlated for all FFPE archived specimens (R2≥0.8). The authors concluded that robust data can be collected from FFPE specimens archived for up to 30 y and stored as FFPE slide-mounted sections for 2 y prior to TempO-Seq analysis.

Using a mouse model, the authors found that gene expression was very strongly correlated among replicates when 10 mm2 or 2 mm2 was used. Liver specimens procured from rat models produced similar TempO-Seq results with comparable correlations among gene expression profiles from biological replicates when samples were fixed in neutral buffered formalin at 4°C for 24, 96, 192, or 384 h

When fresh and FFPE samples of MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 cell lines were compared, 4,461 genes were differentially expressed (raw counts >20, p<0.05) in FFPE samples and 3,015 genes were differentially expressed in fresh samples, and log2fold change was strongly correlated between the two sample types (R2= 0.970).  A cross-platform comparison of TempO-Seq and RNAseq using FFPE MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 cells revealed strong agreement between the two platforms with strongly correlated log2FoldChanges (R2=0.84).

Studies (2)

Purpose

This paper compared sequencing performance of differently sized formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue types with a ligation-based targeted whole transcriptome expression profiling assay (TempO-Seq) that does not required RNA extraction. The potential influences of specimen size, FFPE block storage, and hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining on transcriptome sequencing results were also investigated.  Colorectal adenocarcinoma, prostate adenocarcinoma, pancreatic tumor specimens were stored as FFPE blocks for up to 30 y at room temperature prior to sectioning; slide-mounted FFPE sections (5 µm; unstained) were then stored for 2 years prior to analysis.  Potential differences in TempO-Seq generated results between an unstained FFPE section that was directly used, adeparaffinized unstained FFPE section, and deparaffinized and hematoxylin and eosin-stained FFPE section were investigated using serial sections (5 µm-thickness, 5 mm2area) of human prostate tumor specimens and RNAse-free reagents for deparaffinization and staining. Slides that were deparaffinized were soaked in Leica Bond Dewax solution for 3 minutes. Details on the number of specimens analyzed, conditions of fixation and FFPE section storage are included below when specified. The TempO-Seq assay targets 19,283 protein-coding genes via probe hybridization and does not require nucleic acid extraction. Purified libraries were then run on an Illumina NextSeq 550 platform and data was analyzed using the TempO-Seq data analysis platform.  The authors also used cell lines, rat, and mouse tissue for additional comparisons and to explore potential effects of the tissue area (10 mm2, 2 mm2 of 5 µm-thick) as input, time in formalin, and cross-platform sequencing analysis.

Summary of Findings

When a 10 mm2 area of tissue was scraped from 5 µm-thick unstained FFPE tissue sections, 10% of the lysate from the TempO-Seq assay was successfully used for whole transcriptome sequencing. Gene correlations among age-matched specimens scraped from serial FFPE slides (biological replicates), were strong for pancreas (R2=0.916), colorectal (R2= 0.872), and prostate (R2=0.885) tumors. As expected, principal component analysis (PCA) of FFPE unstained sections analyzed by the TempO-Seq assay revealed that pancreas, colorectal, and prostate tumor specimen clustered by tissue type, and that normal adjacent areas of unstained FFPE sections from different patients clustered together. Coefficients of variation (%CV) for genes with ≥10, 50, or 200 counts were lowest among prostate tumor specimens (27.57, 19.96, and 15.33, respectively) and highest for pancreas tumor specimens (33.44, 29.80, and 28.88, respectively).  Deparaffinization did not alter TempO-Seq results as unstained paraffinized slides that were directly used and deparaffinized unstained FFPE sections generated very strongly correlated gene expression profiles (R2=0.902).  Similarly, gene expression profiles of unstained paraffinized FFPE sections and deparaffinized H&E-stained FFPE sections were strongly correlated (R2=0.855).

Using a mouse model, the authors determined that a tissue area of 2 mm2 from a 5 µm-thick unstained FFPE tissue section was sufficient for TempO-Seq, generating consistent input amounts, and that gene expression correlation among replicates were comparable when a tissue area of 10 mm2 or 2 mm2 was used (R2=0.969 and R2=0.95, respectively).

Liver specimens procured from rat models produced similar TempO-Seq results with comparable correlations among biological replicates when samples were fixed in neutral buffered formalin at 4°C for 24, 96, 192, or 384 h (R2= 0.93-0.98).                                          

When fresh and FFPE samples of MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 cell lines were compared, 4,461 genes were differentially expressed (raw counts >20, p<0.05) in FFPE samples and 3,015 genes were differentially expressed in fresh samples, and log2fold change was strongly correlated between the two sample types (R2= 0.970).  A cross-platform comparison of FFPE MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 cells that was conducted by comparing results generated with TempO-Seq and RNAseq (which required RNA extraction, purification, and reverse transcription) revealed strong agreement between the two platforms with strongly correlated log2FoldChanges (R2=0.84).

  • Biospecimens

    TissueColorectal
    TissueProstate
    TissuePancreas
  • Preservation Types

    Formalin
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
    NeoplasticNormal Adjacent
  • Platforms

    RNANext generation sequencing
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    PreaquisitionDiagnosis/ patient condition
    Colorectal adenocarcinoma
    Pancreatic cancer
    Prostate adenocarcinoma
    Biospecimen AcquisitionBiospecimen location
    Colon
    Pancreas
    Prostate
    Biospecimen Aliquots and ComponentsAliquot size/volume
    10 mm2
    2 mm2
    Biospecimen Aliquots and ComponentsType of slide
    FFPE unstained and deparaffinized FFPE section
    FFPE unstained section
    H&E-stained FFPE section
    Biospecimen PreservationTime in fixative
    192 h
    24 h
    384 h
    96 h
    Next generation sequencing SpecificTechnology platform
    RNAseq
    TempO-Seq
    Next generation sequencing SpecificType of tissue stain
    H&E stained
    Unstained