Skip to main content

Comparison of fecal and oral collection methods for studies of the human microbiota in two Iranian cohorts.

Wu Z, Hullings AG, Ghanbari R, Etemadi A, Wan Y, Zhu B, Poustchi H, Fahraji BB, Sakhvidi MJZ, Shi J, Knight R, Malekzadeh R, Sinha R, Vogtmann E

Publication: BMC Microbiol (2021) • Vol 21 • Page 324PMID: 34809575View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the potential impact of preservation system on the microbiome of oral (Scope mouthwash, OMIgene) and fecal (RNAlater, fecal occult blood test (FOBT) card) specimens, and assessed potential differences associated with volunteers living in a rural or urban area. Changes in the microbiome after storage for 4 days at room temperature in RNAlater, on a FOBT card, or in Scope mouthwash were also evaluated.

Conclusion

Most of the microbial variability occurred between subjects (85-92% for fecal and 71-80% for oral specimens), with less than 10% of the variability attributable to the geographical location of the subject, the collection device used, and specimen storage. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) for fecal specimens stored in RNAlater or on FOBT cards was >0.75 for both alpha and beta diversity metrics and for the most abundant microbial phyla, indicating a high level of stability for these preservation systems.  Intraclass correlation coefficients for oral specimens stored in Scope mouthwash were >0.75; differences in ICC were observed between geographic collection sites for some but not all distance calculation methods.  The relative abundance of many microbial taxa differed significantly between fecal specimens preserved on a FOBT card and those preserved in RNAlater, and between oral specimens preserved in OMNIgene and Scope solutions. However, the comparability ICC was higher for fecal specimens (preserved using RNAlater or FOBT cards) than oral specimens (preserved in Scope or the OMNIgene system).

Studies (1)

Purpose

This paper compared the potential impact of preservation system on the microbiome of oral (Scope mouthwash, OMIgene) and fecal (RNAlater, fecal occult blood test (FOBT) card) specimens, and assessed potential differences associated with volunteers living in a rural or urban area. Changes in the microbiome after storage for 4 days at room temperature in RNAlater, on a FOBT card, or in Scope mouthwash were also evaluated. Fecal and oral specimens were collected from Iranians living in rural (46 subjects) and urban (38 subjects) areas with few exclusion criteria. Fecal specimens were self-collected in a stool collecting container and transferred to two Starstedt tubes containing RNAlater (34 of 38 subjects) and two FOBT cards (36 of 38 subjects). One fecal specimen of each preservation type was frozen on the day of collection at -80°C while the other was stored at room temperature for 4 days before freezing at -80°C. Oral specimens were collected first by spitting into tubes from the OMNIgene oral collection kit and then by swishing and gargling Scope mouthwash. The Scope mouthwash-preserved specimen was aliquoted and one aliquot was frozen at -80°C immediately while the other was stored at room temperature for 4 days before freezing. After 6 months of storage at -80°C, DNA was extracted using the Qiagen MagAttract PowerSoil DNA kit, PCR amplified using primers for the V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene and pair-end sequenced on a MiSeq. ICCs were based on three alpha and four beta diversity metrics.

 

Summary of Findings

Most of the microbial variability occurred between subjects (85-92% for fecal and 71-80% for oral specimens), with less than 10% of the variability attributable to the geographical location of the subject, the collection device used, and specimen storage. Fecal and oral specimens collected from subjects located in a rural area had more Bacteroidetes, but fewer Firmicutes than specimens from subjects located in an urban area.  The stability of the intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) for fecal specimens stored in RNAlater or on FOBT cards was >0.75 for both alpha and beta diversity metrics and for the most abundant phyla.  Although storing RNAlater fecal specimens for 4 days resulted in higher levels of the phyla Actinobacteria and the genus Collinsella and lower levels of the genus Coprococcus, no differences were observed when fecal specimens were stored on FOBT cards. The comparability ICCs for fecal specimens preserved in RNAlater or on FOBT cards ranged from 0.60-0.93. The relative abundance of many microbial taxa differed between fecal specimens preserved on a FOBT card and those preserved in RNAlater, with 6 of the 12 microbial genera with abundance of >1% found to be more abundant in RNAlater specimens and the other 6 more abundant in FOBT specimens.

The intraclass correlation coefficients for oral specimens preserved in Scope mouthwash was >0.75, with ICC differences observed between geographic collection sites for some but not all distance calculation methods. After 4 days at room temperature, oral specimens preserved in Scope mouthwash had a greater abundance of the phyla Firmicutes but fewer bacteria from the phyla Proteobacteria.  Additionally, the abundance of 10 bacteria genera increased and 8 decreased when Scope mouthwash specimens were stored for 4 days at room temperature.  The comparability ICCs for oral specimens preserved in Scope mouthwash and using the OMNIgene kit ranged from 0.55-0.79 with two phyla more abundant and one less abundant in Scope mouthwash specimens than OMNigene specimens. Of the 6 microbial genera with abundance of >1%, 5 were more abundant in oral specimens preserved with the OMNIgene kit than those preserved with Scope mouthwash.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidFeces
    CellOral Cavity
  • Preservation Types

    FrozenRNAlaterOther Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
    Normal
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeNext generation sequencing
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    PreaquisitionDiagnosis/ patient condition
    Rural resident
    Urban resident
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    FOBT Card
    Frozen
    OMNIgene oral collection kit
    RNAlater
    Scope mouthwash
    StorageTime at room temperature
    0 day
    4 day