This meta-analysis of the literature investigated potential effects of pneumatic tube system (PTS) transport of blood on the hemolysis rate, hemolysis index, and levels of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), potassium, aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT).
Effects of a pneumatic tube system on the hemolysis of blood samples: a PRISMA-compliant meta-analysis.
Ding X, Wen X, Wang L, Chen T, Zhou G, He H, Xin X
Purpose
Conclusion
A total of 29 studies met the criteria for inclusion in the meta-analysis. Higher LDH levels were reported among blood specimens transported by PTS compared to specimens that were manually transported. When broken down by transport speed or duration, significant differences in LDH levels relative to manually transported blood specimens were only observed when blood was transported at a speed ≥6 m/s or for ≥250 m. While AST levels differed significantly between PTS blood specimens that were protected and transported >=250 m relative to manually transported specimens, levels were comparable among manually transported blood and blood transported by PTS when data was analyzed as a whole or when transported shorter distances. There were no significant differences in hemolysis rate, hemolysis index, serum potassium and ALT levels between PTS and manually transported specimens. With the exception of AST levels, meta-analysis findings were not altered by the exclusion of any one study and no significant bias was identified by Egger’s test.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This meta-analysis of the literature investigated potential effects of PTS transport of blood on the hemolysis rate, hemolysis index, and levels of LDH, potassium, AST and ALT. The authors further investigated if effects of PTS were limited to specimens transported at a speed of <6 m/s or ≥6 m/s, a duration of <250 m or ≥250 m, or with or without protection. The authors searched the literature for papers investigating the effects of pneumatic tube transport on the degree of hemolysis, and levels of potassium, LDH, ALT or AST. Studies were included in meta-analysis if they had all of the following: employed a cross-sectional or cohort design, collected venous blood from adult subjects, included both PTS and manual transportation groups during similar periods, reported outcomes related to hemolysis induced by a PTS and manual transportation and provided data on the outcomes. When multiple PTS speeds or distances were evaluated in the study, data obtained at the closest speed to 6 m/s followed by the closest distance to 250 m were chosen. When both protected and unprotected specimens were used, data from the protected specimen was selected. Specimens obtained using lithium heparin, or serum tubes were preferred. A sample was considered hemolyzed when cell-free hemoglobin levels exceeded 31µmol/L. Hemolysis rate was defined as the percentage of specimens that were hemolyzed. Studies were scored for risk of bias as low (0-3), medium (4-7) or high (8-11) based on the scoring system of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ).
Summary of Findings
A total of 29 studies met the criteria for inclusion. Based on AHRQ scores, only one study was classified as having a low risk of bias and four were classified as high risk of bias with the remaining 24 studies classified as a moderate risk of bias. In the 6 studies that evaluated both hemolysis rate and index, no differences were observed between manually and PTS transported specimens regardless of transport speed, trasport duration, or use of protection during transport. Analysis of the extracted data from 24 studies (1329 specimens) showed potassium levels in serum did not differ between manually and PTS transported specimens (P=0.24) and there was no effect of PTS distance (<250 m versus ≥250 m) or speed (<6 m/s versus ≥6 m/s). Analysis of LDH levels in 21 studies (1219 specimens), resulted in considerable heterogeneity between studies (I2=61.8%, P<0.001). Higher LDH levels were observed in PTS transported specimens than those transported manually (P=0.01) regardless of whether specimens were protected (P<0.05, both), but when specimens were broken down by transport speed or duration the difference from manually transported specimens was only observed when specimens were transported at ≥6 m/s (P=0.02) or for ≥250 m (P=0.03). In 10 studies (699 specimens), ALT levels were comparable in PTS transported and manually transported specimens, both when analyzed all together or as groups based on transport speed or duration. AST levels in 15 studies (919 specimens) were comparable among PTS transported and manually transported specimens regardless of transport speed; Although specimens that were protected and transported by PTS for ≥250 m differed significantly from manually transported specimens (P=0.02), specimens transported with no protection and/or for shorter durations did not differ from manually transported controls nor was an effect found when analyzed all together. With the exception of AST levels, meta-analysis findings were not altered by the exclusion of any one study and no significant bias was identified by Egger’s test.
Biospecimens
FluidBloodFluidSerumFluidPlasmaPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
ProteinClinical chemistry/auto analyzerProteinHematology/ auto analyzerElectrolyte/MetalClinical chemistry/auto analyzerPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Storage Specimen transport duration/condition <250 m<6 m/sNot protectedProtected≥250 m≥6 m/sStorage Within hospital transportation method Hand-deliveredPneumatic tube system