This paper compared (miRNA, miR) extraction with the miRNeasy kit and a bead-based method based on levels of five miRNAs in archival serum and plasma specimens. Levels of miRNA in serum from patients with testicular germ cell tumors (TGCT) were compared to those in healthy patients.
Comparative Analyses of Liquid-Biopsy MicroRNA371a-3p Isolation Protocols for Serum and Plasma.
Timmerman DM, Gillis AJM, Mego M, Looijenga LHJ
Purpose
Conclusion
The recovery of cel-miR-39 was lower when RNA was extracted using the miRNeasy kit rather than the bead-based method, but levels of miR-30b-8p and miR-30 b-8p normalized to miR-371a-3p were higher when the miRNeasy kit was used for extraction. When extraction was with the miRNeasy kit, plasma Cq values for cel-miR-39 were approximately 2 cycles higher than serum, but no difference in cel-miR-39, miR-371a-3p, or miR-375 Cq values was found when extraction was with the bead based methodand. Significant differences in miR-30b-5p (normalized to miR-371a-3p) l were found between serum from healthy individuals and those with TGCT. Using dilutions of a cell line, the authors found that bead-based extraction was more accurate for miRNA detection at a plasma/serum low volume.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared miRNA extraction with the miRNeasy kit and a bead-based method based on levels of five miRNAs in archival serum and plasma specimens. The following specimens were compared, serum specimens were collected from patients with TGCT and healthy patients; archived case-matched frozen plasma and serum specimens collected from healthy men; and serum from seventeen TGCT patients (details of specimen procurement and processing were not provided). miRNA was isolated from plasma and serum specimens using the bead-based TaqMan miRNA ABC Purification Kit Human Panel A and a KingFisher Flex robot and miRNeasy Serum/Plasma Advanced Kit with MS2 carrier. cel-miR-39 was added to both extractions during lysis. miRNA and RNA were reverse transcribed using the TaqMan miRNA RT Kit. Levels of cel-miR-39-3p, miR30b-5p, miR-371a-3p, miR-373-3p, and miR-375 were assayed by real-time PCR and normalized to miR-30b-5p.
Summary of Findings
Recovery of cel-miR-39 was lower when RNA was extracted using the miRNeasy kit compared to the bead-based method (P<0.005), but the recovery of miR-30b-8p was higher (P<0.0001). When miRNA was extracted with the miRNeasy kit, plasma Cq values for cel-miR-39 were approximately 2 cycles higher than serum, but no difference was found in Cq values when miRNA was extracted using the bead-based method. Variability in Cq values for cel-miR-39 was higher when extraction was with the miRNeasy kit than the bead-based method (5.25 cycles versus 1.3 cycles), but variability in the endogenous gene, miR-30b-8p, was similar between extraction methods. While recovery of miR-30b-5p was superior with the miRNeasy kit (P<0.0001), recovery of cel-mIR-39-3p was more efficient with the beads (P=0.0002). Levels of miR-371a-3p and miR-375 (normalized to miR-30b-5p) were comparable in plasma and serum, but detectable levels of miR-371a-3p were higher when the miRNeasy extraction kit was used as opposed to the bead-based method (P<0.0001 for serum and plasma). Significant differences in miR-30b-5p (normalized miR-371a-3p)) were found between serum from healthy individuals and those with TGCT regardless of whether extraction was with miRNeasy (P<0.0001) or the bead-based method (P=0.0003). Using dilutions of a cell line, the authors found that the bead-based extraction kit was more accurate for detection at low specimen volume.
Biospecimens
FluidBloodFluidPlasmaFluidSerumPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticGerm CellNormalPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition HealthyTGCTBiospecimen Aliquots and Components Blood and blood products PlasmaSerumAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method TaqMan BeadsmiRNeasyReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid cel-miR-39-3pmiR-30b-5pmiR-371a-3pmiR-373-3pmiR-375