Skip to main content

Comparison of 7 methods for extracting cell-free DNA from serum samples of colorectal cancer patients.

Fong SL, Zhang JT, Lim CK, Eu KW, Liu Y

Publication: Clin Chem (2009) • Vol 55 • Page 587-9PMID: 19246404View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the DNA yield from serum when extraction was with seven different methods and quantified using fluorometry, real-time PCR, and real-time PCR after bisulfite conversion. The size of isolated DNA was also compared by electrophoresis.

Conclusion

The DNA concentration as measured by fluorometry and amplification of CDH1 was highest when extraction was with the phenol/chloroform method with addition of glycogen or an in-house sodium iodide-based method followed by the QIAamp DNA Blood Midi Kit with carrier RNA. Importantly, these three methods were the only methods that yielded sufficient DNA to amplify ACTB after bisulfite conversion. While not significantly different from the phenol/chloroform method, the sodium iodide-based method yielded more amplifiable DNA overall and after bisulfite conversion. Electrophoresis revealed visible bands of 200, 400, and 500 bp when extracted using the phenol/chloroform method with addition of glycogen or an in-house sodium iodide-based method but only the 500 bp band was visible when extraction was with the other methods. The authors state the loss of 200 and 400 bp bands indicated poor recovery of nucleosomal DNA.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared the DNA yield from serum when extraction was with seven different methods and quantified using fluorometry, real-time PCR, and real-time PCR after bisulfite conversion. The size of isolated DNA was also compared by electrophoresis. Twelve pooled serum specimens were obtained from the serum of 67 patients with colorectal carcinoma (details of blood procurement and processing not provided). Serum is assumed to have been frozen prior to use. DNA was extracted from serum using a phenol/chloroform method with addition of glycogen, an in-house sodium iodide method, an in-house guanidine-resin based method, the QIAamp DNA Blood Midi Kit with carrier RNA, the ChargeSwitch 1-mL Serum Kit, the Zymo Research Serum DNA Kit, or the Puregene DNA Purification System Cell and Tissue Kit. DNA was quantified by Quant-iT dsDNA HS assay (Invitrogen) and by real-time PCR amplification of the epithelial cadherin 1(CDH1) gene. DNA was also bisulfite-converted and quantified by amplification of a region of ACTB without CpG sites. The size distribution of DNA was investigated by electrophoresis of DNA isolated from 1 mL of serum.

Summary of Findings

The DNA concentration as measured by fluorometry and amplification of CDH1 was highest when extraction was with the phenol/chloroform method with addition of glycogen or an in-house sodium iodide-based method followed by the QIAamp DNA Blood Midi Kit with carrier RNA. Importantly, these three methods were the only methods that yielded sufficient DNA to amplify ACTB after bisulfite conversion. Electrophoresis revealed visible bands of 200, 400, and 500 bp when extraction was with the phenol/chloroform based method with addition of glycogen or the in-house sodium iodide-based method but only the 500 bp band was visible when extraction was with the other methods. The authors state the loss of 200 and 400 bp bands indicated poor recovery of nucleosomal DNA. While not significantly different from the phenol-chloroform based method, the sodium iodide-based method yielded more amplifiable DNA overall and at a lower cost after bisulfite conversion, making it the authors method of choice.

 

  • Biospecimens

    FluidSerum
  • Preservation Types

    Frozen
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
  • Platforms

    DNAFluorometry
    DNABisulfite conversion assay
    DNAReal-time qPCR
    DNAElectrophoresis
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationAnalyte isolation method
    ChargeSwitch 1-mL Serum Kit
    In-house guanidine-resin based method
    In-house sodium iodide method
    Phenol/chloroform method with addition of glycogen
    Puregene DNA Purification System Cell and Tissue Kit
    QIAamp DNA Blood Midi Kit with carrier RNA
    Zymo Research Serum DNA Kit
    Bisulfite conversion assay SpecificTargeted nucleic acid
    ACTB
    Real-time qPCR SpecificTargeted nucleic acid
    CDH1
    Real-time qPCR SpecificTechnology platform
    Amplification of bisulfite converted DNA
    Fluorometry
    Standard real-time PCR