This paper compared microbial profiles in matched fecal specimens in tubes or swabs that were transported frozen or at ambient to those fresh-frozen and transported in sterile collection tubes and those placed in OMNIgene GUT stool stabilization fluid and transported at ambient temperature.
Gut microbiome analysis by post: Evaluation of the optimal method to collect stool samples from infants within a national cohort study.
Williams GM, Leary SD, Ajami NJ, Chipper Keating S, Petrosin JF, Hamilton-Shield JP, Gillespie KM
Purpose
Conclusion
Variation in the relative abundance of the different phyla and genera was much greater among individuals than transportation conditions, but the microbial profiles of specimens placed in OMNIgene GUT Kit most closely resembled the fresh-frozen tube specimen while the tube and swab specimens shipped at ambient showed the greatest changes in microbial abundance.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared microbial profiles in matched fecal specimens in tubes or swabs that were transported frozen or at ambient temperatures and those placed in OMNIgene GUT stool stabilization fluid and transported at ambient temperature. Fecal specimens were collected from the diapers of eight healthy children (6 males, 2 females; 6-38 weeks old) at home and portions were placed in two sterile collection tubes, on two swabs, and in a tube containing OMNIgene GUT stool stabilization fluid. One tube and one swab were immediately frozen on dry ice and shipped frozen via courier to the laboratory. The remaining swab and tubes were mailed at ambient temperature and frozen at -80°C upon arrival at the laboratory (within 3 days of collection). Bacterial DNA was extracted from fecal samples with the MO BIO PowerSoil DNA Isolation Kit. Bacterial 16S rRNA gene V4 region was amplified by PCR, sequenced on a MiSeq platform, and clustered into operational taxonomic units (OTUs) with similarity cut-off value of 97%. The Shannon diversity index was used to compare whether changes were related to the richness and evenness of the microbes. Results were compared to those from fresh-frozen specimens transported and stored in collection tubes on a Bland-Altman plot and 95% limits of agreement were calculated (mean difference +/- 2 standard deviations of the difference).
Summary of Findings
There were 516,160 total reads across all specimens tested with a median of 10,781 reads. Specimens collected and transported in OMNIgene GUT Kits were closest to the fresh-frozen tube specimen in mean number of OTUs (average difference 0.50 units) with the narrowest limits of agreement (-9.55, +10.55). The specimens sent at ambient (tube and swab) were comparable for both mean number of OTUs (5.13 and 6.50, respectively) and limits of agreement (-16.13, +26.38 and -16.95, +29.95; respectively). The fresh-frozen swabs had a lower mean number of OTUs (-3.63) and showed less agreement to the fresh-frozen tube specimen (-35.49, +28.24), but the authors state this was due to a single outlier. Using the Shannon diversity index, OMNIgene GUT specimens were closest to the frozen standard method but specimens collected using a swab and frozen immediately had the narrowest limits of agreement (-0.96, +1.0 versus -0.85, +0.93, respectively) while the tube and swab specimens sent at ambient showed the least agreement (-1.1, +1.59 and -0.99, +1.42). Variation in the relative abundance of the different phyla and genera was much greater between individuals than between sampling methods, but the microbial profiles of specimens collected using the OMNIgene GUT Kit most closely resembled the fresh-frozen specimen while the tube and swab specimens shipped at ambient showed the greatest changes.
Biospecimens
FluidFecesPreservation Types
FrozenNone (Fresh)Other PreservativeDiagnoses
NormalPlatforms
DNAPCRDNANext generation sequencingPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation FrozenNone (fresh)OMNIgene GUTStorage Specimen transport duration/condition Frozen sterile tubeFrozen swabOMNIgene GUT Kit at ambientSterile tube shipped at ambientSwab shipped at ambientNext generation sequencing Specific Targeted nucleic acid Bacterial 16S rRNA gene V4 region