Skip to main content

Quantity and quality of nucleic acids extracted from archival formalin fixed paraffin embedded prostate biopsies.

Carlsson J, Davidsson S, Fridfeldt J, Giunchi F, Fiano V, Grasso C, Zelic R, Richiardi L, Andrén O, Pettersson A, Fiorentino M, Akre O

Publication: BMC Med Res Methodol (2018) • Vol 18 • Page 161PMID: 30518332View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper investigated the effect of extraction kit choice by comparing the yield, purity, and integrity of RNA and DNA isolated from matched serial sections of archival histologically normal prostate biopsies following extraction with different kits designed for formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimens. The authors also investigated how tumor length, percentage tumor cells, Gleason scores, and block storage duration affected the yield, purity, integrity, and CT values of the RNA and DNA extracted from FFPE sections of prostate cancer biopsies.

Conclusion

The RNeasy FFPE Kit yielded RNA with a higher median RNA integrity number (RIN) than the HighPure Kit, FFPE RNA Micro Kit, or the AllPrep DNA/RNA FFPE Kit. The RNeasy Kit also yielded more RNA and the RNA obtained had a higher A260/280 than that obtained using the HighPure Kit. Use of the QIAamp Kit resulted in DNA of much higher mean purity than either the HighPure or AllPrep kits but the mean cycle threshold (CT) values for 18s rRNA were slightly higher for DNA extracted using the QIAamp Kit than the other kits.

In specimens from prostate cancer patients, significant correlations were identified between tumor length and RNA/DNA yield and RIN values and significant differences in RNA yield, DNA yields, and RNA CT values for 18s rRNA were found when specimens were classified by tumor length. The authors state the percentage of tumor cells and Gleason scores were not correlated with DNA or RNA yield, A260/A280 ratios, RIN, or the DNA or RNA CT-values for 18s rRNA. However, there was a weak correlation between age of the FFPE tissue and DNA yield but not RNA yield. DNA and RNA yield from matched sections were not correlated. For RNA, there were significant negative weak to modest correlations identified between yield and A260/A280 and between the CT values for 18s rRNA and between RIN and A260/A280. For DNA, a weak negative correlation was observed between the yield and the CT value for 18s rRNA.

Studies (3)

Purpose

This study compared three RNA extraction kits designed for FFPE specimens by comparing the yield, purity, and integrity of RNA isolated from matched serial sections of archival histologically normal prostate biopsies. Twenty FFPE prostate needle biopsies with normal histology collected between 1992 and 2002 were obtained from the archive (no further details of processing were provided). RNA was extracted from freshly-cut serial 10 µm sections of ten biopsies using the High Pure FFPE RNA Micro Kit and the RNeasy FFPE Kit. RNA was extracted from 10 µm sections of the remaining ten biopsies using the AllPrep DNA/RNA FFPE Kit and the RNeasy FFPE Kit and purity and yield were measured using a spectrophotometer. RNA integrity was assessed using a bioanalyzer and by TaqMan real-time RT-PCR of the 18S rRNA transcript.

Summary of Findings

In the comparison between the HighPure FFPE RNA Micro Kit and the RNeasy FFPE Kit, the RNeasy Kit yielded RNA with significantly higher mean yield (16.3 ng/µL versus 5.6 ng/µL, P<0.001), purity (A260/280 of 1.55 versus 1.38, P=0.003), and median RIN (2.15 versus 1.0, P=0.011) but a comparable number of amplifiable copies of 18S rRNA transcript (mean cycle threshold of 25.4 versus 26.4, P=0.268) to the HighPure Kit. Importantly, Bland-Altman plots indicated that the higher yield, purity, and RIN with RNeasy were fixed bias and there was also a proportional bias in RIN (slope: 1.98, P<0.0001). In the comparison between the RNeasy FFPE Kit and the AllPrep DNA/RNA FFPE Kit, the RNeasy Kit produced RNA with a higher median RIN value (2.5 versus 1.0, P=0.044) but there was no difference in mean yield (11.4 ng/µL versus 12.6 ng/µL, P=0.307), purity (A260/280 of 1.47 versus 1.50, P=0.419), or amplifiable copies of 18S rRNA transcript (mean cycle threshold of 27.4 versus 28.0, P=0.088). Bland-Altman plots confirmed a fixed bias toward higher RIN with RNeasy, but in this comparison, the bias was not found to also be proportional.  

  • Biospecimens

    TissueProstate
  • Preservation Types

    Formalin
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
  • Platforms

    RNAAutomated electrophoresis/Bioanalyzer
    RNASpectrophotometry
    RNAReal-time qRT-PCR
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationAnalyte isolation method
    AllPrep DNA/RNA FFPE kit
    High Pure FFPE RNA Micro kit
    RNeasy FFPE kit