This paper compared detection SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes the novel 2019 coronavirus disease (COVID, COVID-19, COVID19) in viral transport media (VTM) and ethanol after short-term storage of nasopharyngeal swabs and among six different swab types. The effects of swab type on environmental detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by real-time RT-PCR and detected microbial analysis by next-generation sequencing (NGS) were also investigated.
Feasibility of using alternative swabs and storage solutions for paired SARS-CoV-2 detection and microbiome analysis in the hospital environment.
Minich J, Ali F, Marotz C, Belda-Ferre P, Chiang L, Shaffer JP, Carpenter CS, McDonald D, Gilbert J, Allard SM, Allen EE, Knight R, Sweeney DA, Swafford AD
Purpose
Conclusion
Significantly less RNAse P RNA was recovered from the ethanol than from the VTM or the swab head when RNA was extracted from the storage media, but viral RNA levels were comparable between the swab head stored in ethanol as the VTM. While recovery of RNA was comparable between 95% ethanol and 91% isopropanol, 95% ethanol provided better protection against RNAse A than 91% isopropanol. The yield of RNA was significantly affected by swab type (Kruskal-Wallis P=0.03), with the highest yields occurring with the CVS nonsterile, cotton-head, plastic-shaft, consumer-grade swabs (CGp) followed by the non-sterile, cotton-head, plastic-shaft swabs in use by TMI (TMI) and BD synthetic rayon-head, plastic-shaft swabs (SYN).
The false negative rate for SARS CoV-2 was 12.5% for SYN swabs stored in VTM and 44%, 33%, and 50% for SYN, CGP, and TMI swabs stored in ethanol, respectively. When only swabs collected within 72 h of initial positive test were considered, the false negative rates for Syn, CGp, and TMI swabs stored in ethanol decreased to 18.2%, 25%, and 30%, respectively. Importantly, there were no false positives in the swabs from the four patients who did not have SARS-CoV-2. In floor swabs, the highest rate of detection of SARS-CoV-2 was found using the CGp swabs, but swab type had no effect on detection in bed rail specimens. NGS read counts varied between patients and tended to be higher in patient than floor specimens, with less variability observed between swab types than patients. Principle component analysis grouped specimens by patient rather than by swab type with distinct clusters observed for each patient and between floor and patient samples. Not surprisingly, microbial diversity was higher in floor than patient specimens.
Studies (2)
Purpose
This study compared detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA in viral transport media (VTM) and ethanol after short-term storage of nasopharyngeal swabs and between the swab head and the ethanol in which it was stored. Using commercial RNA, the authors also investigated the effects of ethanol and isopropanol on the recovery of RNA and the susceptibility of the specimen to RNAse treatments. Nasopharyngeal swabs were obtained from 39 patients with SARS-CoV-2 by inserting the swab 2-3 cm into the nostril and rotating for 5-10 sec. After collection, swabs were placed in VTM and transported on dry ice. Additional specimens were collected from the nares of 11 SARS-Cov-2 patients and 11 healthcare workers using sterile synthetic-head, plastic-shaft swabs, placed in 95% ethanol and stored on dry ice. RNA was extracted from the swab eluents using the Omega Mag-Bind Viral DNA/RNA 96 Kit and from the swab heads using the MagMAX Microbiome Ultra Kit. Human RNAse P and SARS-CoV-2 RNA were quantified by real-time PCR. Extraction efficiency was evaluated by spiking SARS-CoV-2 RNA into 95% ethanol and 91% isopropanol with or without 0, 2.5, or 25 µg RNAse A.
Summary of Findings
Significantly less human RNAse P RNA was recovered from the ethanol than from the VTM (P<0.001) when RNA was extracted from the storage media, but comparable viral RNA levels were obtained from the swab head stored in ethanol as from the VTM. The SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA load was also significantly higher in the swab specimen than in the ethanol in which it was stored (P=0.032). Using commercial RNA, the authors found that 49.5% of the RNA was recoverable when no buffer was used and 32.1% and 35.3% of RNA were recoverable from 95% ethanol and 91% Isopropanol, respectively. Importantly, 95% ethanol provided better protection against RNAse A than 91% isopropanol.
Biospecimens
CellNasal cavityPreservation Types
EthanolFrozenDiagnoses
Pneumonia/Respiratory InfectionPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Storage Short-term storage solution 91% Isopropanol95% EthanolVTMReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid RNAsePSARS-CoV-2
Purpose
TThis study compared detection of SARS-CoV-2 virus in the eluate and swab after collection from the nares using six different swab types. The microbial diversity of patient as well as environmental swabs were compared using three different swab types. Specimens were collected from the nares of an unspecified number of SARS-CoV-2 patients by inserting each of the swab types 2-3 cm into one nostril and rotating for 5-10 seconds. Swabs were immediately placed in 95% ethanol and stored on dry ice until RNA extraction. In the initial study, specimens were collected using BD sterile synthetic rayon head, plastic-shaft swabs (SYN), BD sterile foam-head, plastic-shaft swabs (BDF), non-sterile cotton-head plastic-shaft swabs used by The Microsetta Initiative (TMI), CVS nonsterile cotton-head plastic-shaft consumer-grade swabs (CGp), CVS non-sterile cotton-head wooden-shaft consumer-grade (CGw) and Puritan non-sterile cotton-head wooden-shaft swabs (Pu). In a replicate study, specimens were collected from 16 SARS-CoV-2 patients and 4 controls using SYN, TMI, and CpG swabs an average of 4.2 days from initial diagnosis when SYN swabs stored in VTM were used. The swabs were placed in ethanol and stored on dry ice until extraction from the swab head. SYN, TMI, and/or CpG swabs were collected in triplicate from the nares of three patients and from the floor of two patient rooms and then stored in ethanol to investigate the effects of swab type on microbiome analysis. RNA was extracted from swab heads using the MagMAX Microbiome Ultra Kit and RNAse P and SARS-CoV-2 RNA were quantified by real-time RT-PCR. For microbiome analysis, libraries were constructed using 515f/806r EMP primers and sequenced on a MiSeq.
Summary of Findings
The yield of RNA was significantly affected by swab type (Kruskal-Wallis P=0.03), with the highest yields occurring with the CVS nonsterile, cotton-head, plastic-shaft, consumer-grade swabs (CGp) followed by the non-sterile, cotton-head, plastic-shaft swabs in use by TMI (TMI) and BD synthetic rayon head plastic-shaft swabs (SYN). For all swabs, the number of human RNAse P RNA copies was higher when extraction was from the swab head than from the ethanol in which they were stored. For most swab types, the difference between swab head and ethanol was large, but the yields were almost comparable for the BDF swabs. When data from all swab types were grouped, significantly more RNA was recovered from the swab heads than the 95% ethanol or 91% isopropanol (P<0.001, both). When SYN, CGp, and TMI swabs were spiked with SARS-CoV-2 RNA directly, the yield was very strongly correlated with the input (R2=0.9660, R2=0.711 and R2=0.9821, respectively) and variation in recovery among the types was only noted at 116,000 genome equivalents.
SARS-CoV-2 was detected in 14 of 16 patients using the standard SYN swab stored in VTM (12.5% false negative rate), but only 9 of 16, 8 of 12, and 5 of 10 patients when collected using SYN, CGp, and TMI swabs that were placed in ethanol, respectively. The resultant false negative rates were 44%, 33%, and 50% for SYN, CGP, and TMI swabs stored in ethanol, respectively. When only swabs collected within 72 h of initial positive test were considered, the false negative rates for Syn, CGp, and TMI swabs decreased to 18.2%, 25%, and 30%, respectively. Importantly, there were no false positives in the swabs from the four patients who did not have SARS-CoV-2. Among floor swabs, the highest rate of detection of SARS-CoV-2 was found using the CGp swabs (75% compared to 63% and 44% for SYN and TMI swabs, respectively). However, SARS-CoV-2 was detected in 5 of 16 bed rail swabs using each of the three swab types. Read counts varied among patients and tended to be higher in patient than floor specimens, with less variability observed between swab types than between patients or sample location. Principle component analysis grouped specimens by patient rather than by swab type, with distinct clusters observed for each patient and between floor and patient samples. Not surprisingly, microbial diversity was higher in floor than patient specimens.
Biospecimens
CellNasal cavityPreservation Types
EthanolFrozenDiagnoses
Pneumonia/Respiratory InfectionPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRRNANext generation sequencingPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Method of cell acquisition BD sterile foam-head, plastic-shaft swabs (BDF)BD sterile synthetic rayon head, plastic-shaft swabs (SYN)CVS non-sterile cotton-head wooden-shaft consumer-grade (CGw)CVS nonsterile cotton-head plastic-shaft consumer-grade swabs (CGp)Non-sterile cotton-head plastic-shaft swabs used by The Microsetta Initiative (TMI)Puritan non-sterile cotton-head wooden-shaft swabs (Pu)Storage Short-term storage solution EthanolIsopropanolVTMReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid RNAse PSARS-CoV-2