The purpose of this paper was to compare detection of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes the novel 2019 coronavirus disease (COVID, COVID-19, COVID19), using different targets and six different real-time PCR based assays. The potential to heat the specimen instead of extracting RNA was also evaluated using the most sensitive assay.
Sensitivity of different RT-qPCR solutions for SARS-CoV-2 detection.
Alcoba-Florez J, Gil-Campesino H, Artola DG, González-Montelongo R, Valenzuela-Fernández A, Ciuffreda L, Flores C
Purpose
Conclusion
Sensitivity of the assays was highly variable and dependent on the targeted genes with the highest sensitivity (97.9%) observed using the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID19) Assay with primers for the E-gene. The lowest sensitivity (60.2%) was observed using the SARS-COV-2 R-GENE Kit with primers for RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). Combining E and RdRp genes in the TaqMan Fast Virus 1-Step Master Mix Kit or the E gene with the N or RdRp genes in the SARS-COV-2 R-GENE Kit increased sensitivity slightly but use of multiple genes did not improve the sensitivity of any other kits. Importantly, the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV Assay with the E-gene primers had a sensitivity of 72.5% when specimens were heated for 10 min to 70°C instead of subjected to RNA extraction.
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare detection of SARS-CoV-2 using different targets and six different real-time PCR based assays. The potential to heat the specimen instead of extracting RNA was also evaluated using the most sensitive assay. Specimens from 98 patients with SARS-CoV-2 were collected in viral transport media (VTM). No other details of specimen collection were provided. RNA was extracted from VTM using the MagNA Pure Compact Nucleic Acid Isolation Kit I or the STARMag Viral DNA/RNA 200C Kit. SARS-CoV-2 virus was detected using the real-time PCR based TaqMan Fast Virus 1-Step Master Mix combined with validated primer-probe sets for the E, N, and RdRp genes; the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID19) Assay with primers for the E, N, and RdRp genes; the SARS-COV-2 R-GENE Kit with primers for the N and RdRp genes; the TaqPath COVID-19 CE-IVD RT-PCR Kit with primers for ORF1ab, S, and N genes; the Genesig Real-Time PCR COVID-19 Kit with primers for the RdRp gene; and the Real Accurate Quadruplex corona-plus PCR Kit with primers for the N gene. False negatives were defined as no detection after 45 cycles. To investigate the need for RNA extraction, specimens were heated for 10 min to 70°C and SARS-CoV-2 was detected directly using the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID19) Assay with primers for the E gene.
Summary of Findings
The fewest false negative results were obtained using the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID19) Assay with the E-gene primers (2 false negatives, sensitivity 97.9%), followed by the TaqMan Fast Virus 1-Step Master Mix also with primers for the E-gene (4 false negatives, 95.9% sensitivity). The highest number of false negative results were found using the SARS-COV-2 R-GENE Kit with primers for RdRp (39 false negatives, sensitivity 60.2%), E (34 false negatives, sensitivity 66.3%), and N (33 false negatives, sensitivity 65.3%) genes or the TaqPath COVID-19 CE-IVD RT-PCR Kit and primers for ORF1ab (34 false negatives, sensitivity 65.3%). Combining E and RdRp genes in the TaqMan Fast Virus 1-Step Master Mix Kit increased sensitivity to be equivalent to that using the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID-9) Assay with primers for the E-gene. Use of primers for the E gene in combination with the N or RdRp genes slightly improved the sensitivity of the SARS-COV-2 R-GENE Kit (71.4% and 69.4%, respectively), but use of multiple genes did not improve the sensitivity of any other kits. Importantly, the most sensitive method, the LightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV (COVID19) assay with the E-gene primers, had a sensitivity of 72.5% when specimens were heated for 10 min to 70°C instead of RNA extraction.
Biospecimens
CellNasal cavityPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Pneumonia/Respiratory InfectionPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Analyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Heat to 70°CMagNA Pure Compact Nucleic Acid Isolation Kit I or the STARMag Viral DNA/RNA 200C kitsReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid E-geneN-geneORF1ab geneRdRp-geneS-geneReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Technology platform Genesig Real-Time PCR COVID-19 kitLightMix1 Modular SARS-CoV assayReal Accurate Quadruplex corona-plus PCR KitSARS-COV-2 R-GENE assayTaqMan Fast Virus 1-Step Master MixTaqPath COVID-19 CE-IVD RT-PCR Kit