Skip to main content

Reliability of self-sampling for accurate assessment of respiratory virus viral and immunologic kinetics.

Waghmare A, Krantz EM, Baral S, Vasquez E, Loeffelholz T, Chung EL, Pandey U, Kuypers J, Duke ER, Jerome KR, Greninger AL, Reeves DB, Hladik F, Cardozo-Ojeda EF, Boeckh M, Schiffer JT

Publication: J Infect Dis (2020)PMID: 32710762View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared respiratory viral detection between self-collected flocked swabs and foam swabs and between specimens obtained from the left versus right nostril. The effect of collection timing on virus detection and cytokine levels was also investigated.

Conclusion

Viral DNA was detected in specimens from 11 of 15 patients with concordance found between swab types for 22 of 30 specimens and between nostrils for 22 of 30 patients. Importantly, discordance between swab types only occurred in cases with viral loads <4 log10 viral copies per mL.

The pattern of viral load and cytokines showed consistency between days with viral load declining as the symptoms decreased. Cytokine levels in human rhinovirus (HRV)-positive specimens were strongly correlated among cytokines with the same cellular origin (T-cell, macrophage, or epithelial derived) with only weak correlations noted between HRV-positive specimens and cytotoxic T-cell response cytokines. For HRV-positive patients, there were three distinct cytokine responses with all patients displaying the least inflammatory signature at some time-points but only two patients showing the most inflammatory signature at any time-point.

Studies (2)

Purpose

This study compared respiratory viral detection between self-collected flocked swabs and foam swabs and between specimens obtained from the left versus right nostril. Fifteen patients with symptoms of a respiratory infection for less than 3 days self-collected specimens from each nostril using Copan flocked swabs or Puritan foam swabs. An hour after the first collection, patients self-collected specimens from each nostril using the other swab type. Swabs were vortexed in buffer and stored at -80°C until virus detection using a multiplex real-time PCR assay for 11 respiratory viruses including adenovirus A-F, human rhinovirus (HRV), influenza A and B, parainfluenza viruses (PIV) 1-4, human coronavirus, bocavirus (BoV), respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), and human metapneumovirus (MPV). 

Summary of Findings

Viral RNA was detected in specimens from 11 of 15 patients. Concordance between swab types from the same nostril was obtained for 22 or 30 specimens. Viruses were detected in the foam swab but not the flocked swab in five cases (one HRV, four coronavirus) and in the flocked but not foam swab in three cases (all coronavirus). Importantly, the discordant cases all had viral loads <4 log10 viral copies per mL. Interestingly, there was discordance between nostrils in 8 of 30 specimens (5 detected only in right, 3 only in left) and viral levels tended to differ between the nostrils. Most patients preferred foam to flocked swabs.

  • Biospecimens

    CellNasal cavity
  • Preservation Types

    Frozen
  • Diagnoses

    Pneumonia/Respiratory Infection
  • Platforms

    RNAReal-time qRT-PCR
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionBiospecimen location
    Left nostril
    Right nostril
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of cell acquisition
    Flocked swab
    Foam swab