This paper investigated the effects of storage duration, cellularity, and diagnostic grade on DNA and RNA yield and integrity. The effect of rapid onsite evaluation (ROSE) on determination of specimen cellularity and the use of fine needle aspiration (FNA) versus formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) surgical specimens on the mutational profile by next-generation sequencing were also investigated.
Preanalytic variables in quality and quantity of nucleic acids extracted from FNA specimens of thyroid gland nodules collected in CytoLyt: Cellularity and storage time.
Heymann JJ, Yoxtheimer LM, Park HJ, Fernandez EM, Facey KE, Alperstein SA, Tran HV, Baek I, Scognamiglio T, Rennert H, Siddiqui MT, Song W
Purpose
Conclusion
The study design resulted in specimens classified as category II or III being stored significantly longer than those classified as IV, V, or VI. There was a very weak negative correlation between storage duration and DNA but not RNA yield. Specimen cellularity and diagnostic category may be confounding factors. In a selection of seven cases (range of cellularity and storage durations), the cell-free DNA proportion as evidenced by a ladder increased and the percentage of RNA fragments >200 nt (DV200) decreased with increasing storage duration. Specimens with a higher risk of malignancy (IV-VI) were more likely than those with a score of II or III to score high for cellularity, pass quality control for DNA and RNA, and yielded higher mean DNA and RNA quantities. Specimen cellularity and number of follicular epithelial cell clusters were comparable in specimens collected with and without ROSE. Using the leftover CytoLyt specimen, mutations were detected in 10 of 11 malignant specimens and 7 of 33 indeterminate specimens, but some mutations found in the corresponding FFPE block were not found.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of storage duration, cellularity, and diagnostic grade on DNA and RNA yield and integrity. The effect of ROSE on determination of specimen cellularity and the use of FNA versus FFPE surgical specimens on the mutational profile by next-generation sequencing were also investigated. FNA specimens from 53 patients (56 specimens) with thyroid nodules classified as Bethesda diagnostic category IV (suspicious for neoplasm), V (suspicious for malignancy), or VI (malignant) were prospectively collected (40 specimens) over 6 months and atypical (III) and benign (II) FNA specimens were retrospectively collected 2 months earlier (16 specimens). FFPE surgical blocks were available for 11 of the prospectively collected specimens. All biopsies were collected under ultrasound guidance with rapid onsite evaluation (ROSE) for 38 specimens. During ROSE, direct smears were stained using the Diff-Quik or Papanicolaou method and a ThinPrep slide was prepared from residual material in CytoLyt. For the specimens without ROSE, smears were prepared at the discretion of the operator and the needle was rinsed in CytoLyt. For specimens with visible tissue fragments in the CytoLyt vial, an FFPE block was prepared. ThinPrep slides were evaluated for the number of clusters with ≥10 follicular epithelial cells (1 to 10 clusters, 11 to 20 clusters, or >20 clusters) and the cell clusters and follicular epithelial cells were scored for cellularity as low, moderate, or high by both a cytopathologist and a cytotechnologist working independently. When there was a discrepancy in scoring, a senior cytopathologist evaluated the case. DNA and RNA were extracted from the remainder of the CytoLyt specimen using the AllPrep DNA/RNA Mini Kit and quantified using the Qubit dsDNA Kit and the RNA HS Assay Kits, respectively. DNA and RNA integrity were assessed using a 4200 TapeStation system and the RNA 6000 Pico Kit on a bioanalyzer, respectively. DNA and RNA were extracted from 5 µm thick sections after macrodissection using the Maxwell 16 FFPE DNA Kit and the RNeasy FFPE Kit, respectively. Sequencing libraries were prepared using the Oncomine Comprehensive Panel v2 assay and quantified with the Ion TaqMan Quantitation Kit.
Summary of Findings
The study design resulted in specimens classified as category II or III being stored significantly longer than those classified as IV, V, or VI (46.5 days versus 29 days, P=0.01). There was a very weak negative correlation between storage duration and DNA yield (R2=0.08, P=0.02), but diagnostic category may be a confounding factor and no similar correlation was found for RNA. In a selection of seven cases (range of cellularity and storage durations), the cell-free DNA proportion as evidenced by a ladder increased and the percentage of RNA fragments >200 nt (DV200) decreased with increasing storage duration, but the sample size was insufficient for statistical analysis. Specimens with a higher risk of malignancy (IV-VI) were more likely than those with a score of II or III to score high for cellularity (P=0.01) and pass quality control for DNA (P=0.04) and RNA (P=0.03). Further, those with a score of IV, V, or VI had higher mean DNA and RNA quantities than those with a score of II or III (6.0 versus 3.4 ng/µL, P<0.01 and 6.0 versus 3.8 ng/µL, P<0.03). Specimen cellularity and number of follicular epithelial cell clusters were comparable in specimens collected with and without ROSE. Using the leftover CytoLyt specimen, mutations were detected in 10 of 11 malignant specimens and 7 of 33 indeterminate specimens but only one had a MAF >50%. Sequencing from FFPE resection blocks identified alterations in 6 of 13 specimens and some of these were not identified in the corresponding CytoLyt specimen.
Biospecimens
TissueThyroid GlandPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaNeoplasticBenignNot specifiedPlatforms
DNAFluorometryDNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNAFluorometryRNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerDNANext generation sequencingMorphologyLight microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition Bethesda Category IIBethesda Category IIIBethesda Category IVBethesda Category VBethesda Category VIBiospecimen Acquisition Method of tissue acquisition Fine needle aspirationSurgical resectionStorage Storage duration Median of 29 days; range, 7-70 daysMedian of 46.5 days; range, 21-77 days