This paper compared microRNA (miRNA, miR) levels in untreated, heat/freeze-cycled, freeze/thaw-cycled, and freeze/thaw and heat/freeze-cycled plasma and serum and compared levels with those in RNA extracted from serum.
Improved Detection of Circulating miRNAs in Serum and Plasma Following Rapid Heat/Freeze Cycling.
Mariner PD, Korst A, Karimpour-Fard A, Stauffer BL, Miyamoto SD, Sucharov CC
Purpose
Conclusion
Only a small number of miRNAs were detected directly in serum or plasma (no extraction or treatments) and levels of the detected miRNAs were not significantly correlated between replicates. Extraction or heat/freeze-cycling of serum and plasma resulted in the detection of more miRNAs and strong to very strong correlations between replicates and modest to strong correlation between extracted and heat/freeze-cycled specimens and between heat/freeze-cycled plasma and heat/freeze-cycled serum. Freeze/thaw-cycling of serum negatively impacted miRNA detection when not further processed but levels were strongly correlated with those in serum that was just heat/freeze-cycled. The reliability as determined by Cohen Kappa Statistics showed substantial agreement in miRNA levels between replicates when RNA was extracted from serum or when serum or plasma was heat/freeze-cycled and there was significant agreement between heat/freeze-cycled serum and extracted RNA from serum and between serum and plasma specimens that were heat/freeze-cycled but not between replicates of unprocessed serum or between unprocessed serum and unprocessed plasma, extracted serum, or heat/freeze-cycled serum. The authors conclude that heat/freeze-cycling is a viable alternative to extraction when only a small volume of plasma or serum is available.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared miRNA levels in untreated, heat/freeze-cycled, freeze/thaw-cycled, and freeze/thaw and heat/freeze-cycled plasma and serum and compared levels with those in RNA extracted from serum. Blood was collected from a single healthy individual into Vacutainers containing anticoagulant (acid citrate-dextrose tubes) and from two individuals into clot-activating Vacutainers (serum tubes). Blood was centrifuged at 850 x g for 20 min at 10°C and the resultant plasma/serum was aliquoted and stored at -80°C. miRNA was isolated from aliquots of both serum specimens using the miRNeasy Plasma/Serum Mini Kit and stored at -80°C. The effects of freeze/thaw-cycling were investigated by thawing aliquots of one serum on ice, aliquoting, returning the specimen to -80°C, and repeating such that there were specimens freeze/thaw-cycled 1-5 times. To test the effects of heat/freeze-cycling, 10 µL aliquots of both serum specimens, the plasma specimen, and the freeze/thaw-cycled serum were thawed on ice and aliquots were heat/freeze-cycled three times by heating in a 65°C heat block for 5 min followed by freezing in a dry ice ethanol bath and then immediately analyzed by real-time PCR. RNA in plasma and serum and RNA purified from serum was reverse-transcribed using the MegaPlex Pools protocol, preamplified using TaqMan PreAmp Master Mix, and amplified using TaqMan Gene Expression Assay.
Summary of Findings
Only 53 of the 373 miRNAs quantified were detected directly (no extraction) in serum, only 18 of which were found in both aliquots of serum from the same patient and levels were not significantly correlated between replicates. A total of 24 miRNAs were detected in unprocessed plasma and at least one of the two unprocessed serum specimens but levels of these were not significantly correlated between specimen types. In contrast, a total of 145 miRNAs were detected in both specimens when RNA was extracted from serum and levels were strongly correlated between the specimens (R=0.9256, P<0.0001) and 48 additional miRNAs found in only one extraction. While 15 of the 18 miRNAs found in both unprocessed serum specimens were found in both specimens after extraction, there was no correlation in levels of these miRNA. Like extraction, small aliquots of serum that were heat/freeze-cycled had 91 miRNAs detected in both specimens and levels of these miRNA were strongly correlated between the specimens (R=0.9192, P<0.0001) and included microvesicle miRNA. Importantly, 81 of these 91 miRNAs were also found in both extracted serum specimens and levels were modestly to strongly correlated (R=0.51-0.74, P< 0.0001, all) but were not correlated to the respective unprocessed serum. Similarly, heat/freeze-cycling of plasma resulted in detection of 82 miRNAs in both plasma replicates, levels of which were very strongly correlated between replicates (R2=0.95, P<0.0001) but not correlated with levels in the respective unprocessed plasma. Further, levels in heat/freeze-cycled plasma were strongly correlated with those in heat/freeze-cycled serum (R2=0.84-0.92, P<0.0001, all). Freeze/thaw-cycling of serum negatively impacted miRNA detection when not further processed but 87 miRNAs were detected in common in specimens that were and were not previously freeze/thaw-cycled when the specimen was subsequently heat/freeze-cycled and levels were strongly correlated (R=0.81-0.89, P<0.0001). The reliability as determined by Cohen Kappa Statistics showed substantial agreement in miRNA levels between replicates when RNA was extracted from serum (κ=0.75) or when serum or plasma was heat/freeze-cycled (κ=0.66 and κ=0.62, respectively) and there was substantial agreement between heat/freeze-cycled serum and extracted serum (κ=0.62) and between serum and plasma specimens that were heat/freeze-cycled (κ=0.67) but not between replicates of unprocessed serum (κ=0.34) or between unprocessed serum and unprocessed plasma (κ=0.39), extracted serum (κ=0.19), or heat/freeze-cycled serum (κ=0.18). The authors conclude that heat/freeze-cycling is a viable alternative to extraction when only a small volume of plasma or serum is available.
Biospecimens
FluidBloodFluidPlasmaFluidSerumPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NormalPlatforms
RNAReal-time qRT-PCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Aliquots and Components Blood and blood products PlasmaSerumStorage Freeze/thaw cycling 0 cycles5 cyclesAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method Extracted using miRNeasy Plasma/Serum Mini KitHeat/Freeze cycledNot extracted