Skip to main content

Gene expression profiling of whole blood: A comparative assessment of RNA-stabilizing collection methods.

Donohue DE, Gautam A, Miller SA, Srinivasan S, Abu-Amara D, Campbell R, Marmar CR, Hammamieh R, Jett M

Publication: PLoS One (2019) • Vol 14 • Page e0223065PMID: 31600258View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared RNA quality and gene expression patterns in RNA extracted from peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) preserved in Trizol and from blood stored in PAXgene RNA and RNAgard tubes. Different methods were used for RNA extraction from PBMC and blood specimens.

Conclusion

Mean RNA integrity numbers (RIN) values were higher for RNA extracted from PBMCs in Trizol than from blood in PAXgene or RNAgard tubes. While the overall fold-changes in expression appeared similar across the specimen types both before and after normalization, PCA clustered by specimen type rather than subject. Only very small weak correlations were noted between probe properties (distance from 3’, distance from 5’, target size, %GC content) and probe variability for each method, indicating differences between methods are not due to RNA degradation. In PAXgene and RNAgard specimens, the technical variance was highest for genes associated with immune response and homeostasis functions. Comparison of gene profiles revealed higher expression of nuclear lumen and apoptotic genes and lower expression of metal ion binding genes in RNAgard specimens than PAXgene specimens.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared RNA quality and gene expression patterns in RNA extracted from PBMCs preserved in Trizol and from blood stored in PAXgene RNA and RNAgard tubes. Blood was collected from eight healthy army personnel 2 weeks prior to deployment using a 21-gauge butterfly needle and catheter. Blood from each subject was dispensed into a PAXgene RNA tube, a RNAgard Blood tube, and two CPT tubes. PAXgene and RNAgard specimens were inverted 10 times and stored at room temperature for 2 h before freezing at-20°C for 24 h and storage at -80°C until transport. PBMCs were isolated from blood in CPT tubes within 2 h of collection by centrifugation at 1700 x g for 20 min. PBMCs were washed in PBS and resuspended in Trizol. All specimens were then transported on dry ice. Cell pellets were obtained from blood in PAXgene tubes by centrifugation at 3500 x g for 10 min, resuspension in water, and a second centrifugation. Cell pellets were obtained from blood in RNAgard tubes by mixing 4 mL of blood with BioMaxi Precipitation Buffer in a new tube, incubation for 15 min, and then centrifugation at 4500 x g for 30 min. RNA was extracted from the PAXgene and RNAgard pellets using the PAXgene RNA blood miRNA kit following instructions for the QIAcube. RNA was extracted from frozen PBMCs in Trizol following the Trizol protocol. RNA was quantified by spectrophotometry. RNA integrity was evaluated using an Agilent RNA ScreenTape assay. Gene expression was evaluated using the Agilent SurePrint G3 Human gene expression v2 8 × 60K Microarray following the manufacturer’s workflow. Data was normalized and converted to log 2-fold differences and quantile normalized across arrays and other methods using R scripts.

Summary of Findings

Mean RIN values were higher for RNA extracted from PBMCs in Trizol than from blood in PAXgene or RNAgard tubes (8.875 versus 7.306 and 7.433, respectively; P<0.0001), but there was no difference in RIN values between PAXgene and RNAgard samples. While the overall fold-changes in expression appeared similar across the specimen types both before and after normalization, PCA clustered by specimen type rather than subject. The authors point out that the separate clustering of the PBMCs in Trizol versus the two blood specimen types is explained by the different cell type compositions. The variation between technical replicates was lowest in the PBMCs preserved in Trizol, but the separation between subjects was also lower than for the two types of blood specimens. The signal-to-noise ratio (ratio of correlation of within-donor probes to between-donor probes for a given method) was close to 1 for all methods (1.058 for PAXgene, 1.064 for RNAgard, and 1.044 for PBMCs in Trizol) indicating a similar ability of each to differentiate mRNA levels across individuals. Only very small weak correlations were noted between probe properties (distance from 3’, distance from 5’, target size, %GC content) and probe variability for each method, indicating differences between methods are not due to RNA degradation. In PAXgene and RNAgard specimens, the technical variance was highest for genes associated with immune response and homeostasis functions. Expression of nuclear lumen and apoptotic genes was higher and metal ion binding gene lower in RNAgard specimens than PAXgene specimens.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidBlood
    CellWhite Cells
  • Preservation Types

    FrozenOther PreservativePAXgene
  • Diagnoses

    Normal
  • Platforms

    RNADNA microarray
    RNAAutomated electrophoresis/Bioanalyzer
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionType of collection container/solution
    CPT tube
    PAXgene RNA tube
    RNAgard blood tube
    Biospecimen Aliquots and ComponentsBlood and blood products
    Peripheral blood
    Peripheral blood mononuclear cells
    Biospecimen PreservationRNA stabilization method
    PAXgene tube
    RNAgard blood tube
    Trizol reagent