Skip to main content

Use of FFPE-derived DNA in next generation sequencing: DNA extraction methods.

McDonough SJ, Bhagwate A, Sun Z, Wang C, Zschunke M, Gorman JA, Kopp KJ, Cunningham JM

Publication: PLoS One (2019) • Vol 14 • Page e0211400PMID: 30973937View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper investigated differences between DNA extraction methods on the yield of DNA, percent double stranded DNA (dsDNA), and fragment size and compared extraction and library preparation methods on next-generation sequencing (NGS) metrics and genotype concordance using archival formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) specimens. The differences among tissue types were also investigated.

Conclusion

DNA yields were highest from tonsil specimens and lowest from brain stem and breast specimens, but there was no consistent differences between extraction methods on yield. The percentage of DNA that was double stranded was highest using the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit, the GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (automated or manual), the QIAsymphony DSP DNA Mini Kit and the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit. The most consistently intact DNA (highest DQN and best multiplex PCR) was obtained using the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit, the QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit, and the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit.

As expected, the most degraded specimens (cerebellum) resulted in lower mean coverage and higher duplication rates than observed for other tissue types. Using Ultra II rather than ThruPLEX for library preparation resulted in higher mean coverage and lower duplication rate, but there was no clear difference based on extraction method. The concordance in genotype between extraction kits was >95% for all extraction kit combinations and both library preparation methods.

Using the targeted NGS panels, the highest average coverage was in specimens extracted using the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit. The average concordance between extraction methods in genotype calls using the targeted panels was 99.59%. The lowest percentage of C>T/G>A occurred when extraction was with the QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit or KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit but the differences were small.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study investigated differences between DNA extraction methods on the yield of DNA, percent dsDNA, and fragment size and compared extraction and library preparation methods on NGS metrics and genotype concordance. The effects of tissue type were also investigated.  Nine 10 µm sections were cut from each of 12 archival FFPE blocks including both normal and pathological breast, colon, lung, and pancreas specimens; two normal tonsil tissues; a brain stem specimen; and a cerebellum specimen. Specimens were fixed for more than 6 h before paraffin-embedding but other details of specimen procurement and FFPE processing were not specified. Sections were placed on slides and then scraped into microcentrifuge tubes. Sections were deparaffinized using the QIagen deparaffinization solution, xylene (for QIAamp extractions), or the KAPA Express Extract reagents (for KAPA express extractions). DNA was extracted using manual kits (KAPA Express Extract Kit, Promega Reliaprep FFPE gDNA Miniprep System, QIAamp FFPE tissue Kit with extention of lysis to overnight, or QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit) or automated kits (QIAGEN QIAsymphony DNA Mini Kit, QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit, Maxwell RSC DNA FFPE Kit, PerkinElmer Chemagic FFPE DNA kit, or Applied Biosystem’s Duo Mag-MAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit). DNA was quantified using the Qubit dsDNA BR Assay and spectrophotmetery. For specimens with measurements below 2.0 ng, the concentration was verified using the Qubit dsDNA HS Assay. Fragment lengths were determined using the Analytical Fragment Analyzer High-Sensitivity Large Fragment Analysis Kit and multiplex PCR. Libraries were constructed using NEBNext Ultra II DNA Library Prep and ThruPLEX DNA-seq Kit from DNA extracted with the QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (manual and automated), QIAamp DNA Mini Kit, or KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit and sequenced on an Illumina HiSeq 4000. The QIAGEN QIAseq Targeted Human Comprehensive Cancer Panel and the Human Breast Cancer panels were also sequenced on these specimens using a HiSeq 4000. Statistical analyses were performed but comparisons made were not always clear.

Summary of Findings

DNA yields were highest from tonsil specimens and lowest from brain stem and breast specimens, but there was no consistent effect of extraction method on yield. As expected, tumors yielded more DNA than the respective normal tissue. The percentage of DNA that was double stranded was highest using the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit, the GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (automated or manual), the QIAsymphony DSP DNA Mini Kit, and the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit. The ratio of the absorbance at 260 to 280 was above 1.8 for all specimens with the exception of those extracted with the KAPA Express Extract Kit and Reliaprep FFPE gDNA Miniprep System. Fragment length analysis showed the most degradation in cerebellum specimens and when the KAPA Express Extract Kit, Reliaprep FFPE gDNA Miniprep System, Maxwell RSC DNA FFPE Kit, or Chemagic MSM1 FFPE DNA Kit were used.  Highly variable results were observed when the QIAsymphony DSP DNA Mini Kit was used. The most consistently intact DNA (highest DQN) was obtained using QIAamp DNA Mini, QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE, and KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation kits. Multiplex PCR confirmed the lower integrity of specimens extracted using the KAPA Express Extract, Chemagic MSM1 FFPE DNA, and QIAsymphony DSP DNA Mini kits and better amplification of longer fragments when extraction was with QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit or the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit.

As expected, the most degraded specimens (cerebellum) resulted in lower mean coverage and higher duplication rates than observed for other tissue types. Using Ultra II rather than ThruPLEX for library preparation resulted in higher mean coverage (mean 25.88X versus 21.5X) and lower duplication rate (11.9% versus 26.21%). There were no clear differences between extraction method on the mean coverage or duplication rate and the concordance in genotype between extraction kits was >95% for all extraction kit combinations and both library preparation methods.

Using the QIAseq Human Comprehensive Cancer panel, higher average molecular tag coverage was found in specimens extracted using the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit (820.91X) than with the automated or manual QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (733.77X and 650.96X, respectively) or the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit (599.68X). Similarly, coverage was higher using the Breast Cancer panel for specimens extracted using the KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit (1609.23X) than with the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit (1089.31X) or the manual or automated QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (749.12X and 731.92X, respectively). Importantly, the average concordance in genotype calls between extraction methods was 99.59%. Finally, the lowest percentage of C>T/G>A occurred when extraction was with the QIAcube GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit (36.64%) or KingFisher Duo MagMAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit (36.59%) and the highest when extraction was with the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit (38.06%).

  • Biospecimens

    TissueBrain
    TissueBreast
    TissueColorectal
    TissueLung
    TissuePancreas
    TissueTonsil
  • Preservation Types

    Formalin
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
    Normal
  • Platforms

    DNAFluorometry
    DNASpectrophotometry
    DNANext generation sequencing
    DNAPCR
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionBiospecimen location
    Brain stem
    Breast
    Cerebellum
    Colon
    Lung
    Normal
    Pancreas
    Tonsil
    Tumor
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationAnalyte isolation method
    Applied Biosystem’s Duo Mag-MAX FFPE DNA Isolation Kit
    Automated QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE kit
    KAPA Express Extract kit
    Manual QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE kit
    Maxwell RSC DNA FFPE Kit
    PerkinElmer chemagic FFPE DNA kit
    Promega Reliaprep FFPE gDNA Miniprep system
    QIAGEN QIAsymphony DNA mini kit
    QIAamp FFPE tissue kit (extending lysis to overnight)
    Next generation sequencing SpecificTechnology platform
    Human Breast Cancer panels
    NEBNext Ultra II DNA Library Prep
    QIAseq Targeted Human Comprehensive Cancer Panel
    ThruPLEX DNA-seq Kit