Skip to main content

Comparison of proteases in DNA extraction via quantitative polymerase chain reaction.

Eychner AM, Lebo RJ, Elkins KM

Publication: Anal Biochem (2015) • Vol 478 • Page 128-30PMID: 25197027View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared DNA yields obtained using four different proteases during DNA extraction in nine different specimen types.

Conclusion

Amplifiable DNA was obtained from all specimens, regardless of the type of protease used during extraction. Use of papain and bromelain resulted in higher average DNA yields from blood but the highest average yields for semen, buccal cells, and breastmilk were obtained using the kit proteinase K. DNA yields from earwax were similar among specimens extracted using the different proteases, but yields were slightly higher when papain was used. The highest DNA yields from diluted blood, saliva, and semen specimens were obtained using the unmodified proteinase K but the highest yields from fingerprints and environmental chewing gum were obtained when bromelain was used and from cigarette butts using the kit proteinase K.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared DNA yields obtained using four different proteases from nine specimen types (blood, semen, buccal cells, breastmilk, earwax, computer keyboard swabs, chewing gum, and cigarette butts), as well as from diluted blood, semen, and saliva samples. Blood, semen, and breastmilk specimens (50 µl) were pipetted on DNA-free cotton-tipped swabs. Buccal cells and earwax were collected individually on swabs (details not provided). Computer keyboard samples were taken using moistened swabs. Control chewing gum obtained from adult volunteers (chewed for 30 min at least a half-hour after food or drink was consumed) and environmental chewing gum and cigarette butts (collected from the ground at Towson University) were processed whole. DNA extraction was performed using the QIAamp DNA Investigator Kit per manufacturer instructions with the exception of modified kit proteinase K being substituted with unmodified proteinase K, bromelain, or papain. DNA was quantified by real-time qPCR using the Quantifiler TaqMan assay.

Summary of Findings

Amplifiable DNA was obtained from all specimens, regardless of the protease used during extraction. Use of papain and bromelain during extraction resulted in higher average DNA yields (59.1 and 40.2, respectively) from blood than either unmodified proteinase K (32.4 ng) or the QIAamp kit proteinase K (27.8 ng). For semen and buccal cells, use of the kit proteinase K resulted in the highest average DNA yields (74.7 ng and 60.8 ng, respectively) followed by bromelain (50.6 ng and 29.3 ng, respectively), unmodified proteinase K (44.6 ng and 56.6 ng, respectively), and papain (42.9 ng and 43.9 ng, respectively). Similarly, average DNA yields from breastmilk were highest using the kit proteinase K (1.67 ng), but only slightly lower yields were observed when unmodified proteinase K (0.869 ng), bromelain (1.09 ng), or papain (1.20 ng) were used. For earwax, DNA yields were similar among specimens extracted using the different proteases with slightly higher DNA yields obtained when papain was used than with unmodified proteinase K, kit proteinase K, or bromelain (0.848 ng versus 0.690 ng, 0.413 ng, and 0.388 ng; respectively). The average DNA yields were higher when unmodified proteinase K was used for 1:10 and 1:100 diluted blood samples (7.787 and 0.830 ng/µl, respectively), 1:10 and 1:100 diluted semen samples (9.607 and 0.571 ng/µl, respectively), and 1:10 diluted saliva (0.793 ng/µl) than when kit proteinase K, bromelain, or papain were used. The highest DNA yields from control chewing gum were observed when bromelain was used (1.430 ng/µl), from fingerprints on computer keyboards and environmental chewing gum using papain (0.220 ng/µl and 15.697 ng/µl, respectively), and from cigarette butts using the kit proteinase K (4.286 ng/µl).

  • Biospecimens

    CellSkin
    FluidBlood
    FluidSaliva
    FluidSerum
    FluidBreast Milk
    CellBuccal
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Normal
  • Platforms

    DNAReal-time qPCR
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen Aliquots and ComponentsBiospecimen components
    1:10 diluted blood
    1:10 diluted saliva
    1:10 diluted semen
    1:100 diluted blood
    1:100 diluted saliva
    1:100 diluted semen
    Undiluted blood
    Undiluted semen
    Analyte Extraction and PurificationProtein digestion
    Bromelain
    Modified kit proteinase K
    Papain
    Unmodified proteinase K