Skip to main content

A Method to Evaluate the Quality of Clinical Gene-Panel Sequencing Data for Single-Nucleotide Variant Detection.

Lee C, Bae JS, Ryu GH, Kim NKD, Park D, Chung J, Kyung S, Joung JG, Shin HT, Shin SH, Kim Y, Kim BS, Lee H, Kim KM, Kim JS, Park WY, Son DS

Publication: J Mol Diagn (2017) • Vol 19 • Page 651-658PMID: 28743024View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared next generation sequencing (NGS) quality metrics in frozen and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimens and investigated which metrics were indicators of a pass rate (PR) greater than 80 at the required sequencing depth. The effect of extraction kit on NGS metrics in FFPE specimens was also examined.

Conclusion

The mean coverage was slightly higher for frozen than FFPE specimens and the pass rate (PR) scores at the required depth (200x for FFPE and 500x for frozen) were higher for frozen than FFPE specimens. The majority of variants detected in frozen specimens had high mean depth and high uniformity >50% (0.8) but there was more variation in mean depth and uniformity >50% in FFPE specimens. The best indicator of a PR500>80 for frozen specimens was the input amount used for hybridization, but the best indicators of PR200>80 for FFPE specimens was a DNA concentration after the pre-PCR step of >26.55 ng/µL and a molality of >3.92 mmol/L after post-PCR. However, in FFPE specimens with a concentration of <26.5 ng/µL after pre-PCR, 86.4% of specimens had a PR200>80 with an average library size of >274 bp.

Although the authors did not specify which extraction kit was which, one kit led to higher mean coverage but less uniformity and lower PR scores than the other kit.

Studies (2)

Purpose

This study compared NGS quality metrics in frozen and FFPE specimens and investigated what metrics were indicators of a PR>80 at the required sequencing depth. DNA was extracted from 1142 FFPE tumor specimens using the Promega Maxwell 16 CSC DNA FFPE kit and the QIAamp DNA FFPE Tissue kits and from 1283 frozen tumor specimens using QIAamp DNA Mini kits. No details of specimen procurement, processing, or storage were provided. Specimens included chronic myeloid leukemia, melanoma, non-small cell leukemia, colorectal carcinoma, neuroblastoma, small cell carcinoma of the lung, acute myeloid leukemia, breast cancer, thyroid cancer, thymic cancer, basal cell carcinoma, and ovarian cancer.  DNA yield was determined by using a Qubit 2.0 fluorometer and spectrophotometry. DNA integrity was determined using a 2200 TapeStation and by real-time PCR amplification. NGS libraries were constructed from 200 ng DNA from frozen specimens and 300 ng DNA from FFPE specimens using SureSelect XT Reagent Kit and sequenced using the HiSeq 2500 sequencing platform. The limit of detection for variants was set at 5% for frozen specimens (>500x) and 10% for FFPE specimen (>200x).

Summary of Findings

The mean coverage was slightly higher for frozen than FFPE specimens (954x versus 728x), and the PR scores at the required depth (200x for FFPE and 500x for frozen) were higher for frozen than FFPE specimens (97.3% versus 92.9%). Further, there were fewer sites with a uniformity of coverage >50% for frozen specimens than FFPE specimens (0.849 versus 0.876). The majority of variants detected in frozen specimens had high mean depth and high uniformity >50% (0.8), but there was more variation in mean depth and uniformity >50% in FFPE specimens. In specimens with low uniformity, the depth for an individual hotspot rather than the mean depth is critical to understand variant detection. For frozen specimens, DNA input used for hybridization was predictive of a PR500 >80 as this was achieved in 98.9% of specimens when >648 ng of DNA was used for hybridization but only 77.9% if <648 ng was used. For FFPE specimens, DNA concentration after the pre-PCR step was the best indicator of a PR200>80 as 97.6% of specimens has a PR200>80 if the concentration was >26.5 ng/µL versus only 70.9% when the concentration was <26.5 ng/µL. In FFPE specimens with a pre-PCR concentration >26.5 ng/µL, 98% of specimens with >3.92 mmol/L had a PR200>80 versus 70.0% in those with <3.92 mmol/L. For those FFPE specimens with a DNA concentration of <26.5 5 ng/µL after the pre-PCR step, 86.4% of the samples with a library size of >274 bp had a PR200>80 versus 31.0% of the samples with a library size of <274 bp.

  • Biospecimens

    TissueBreast
    TissueColorectal
    TissueOvary
    TissueSkin
    TissueThyroid Gland
    TissueThymus Gland
  • Preservation Types

    FormalinFrozen
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
    NeoplasticLeukemia
    NeoplasticMelanoma
    NeoplasticLymphoma
  • Platforms

    DNASpectrophotometry
    DNAFluorometry
    DNANext generation sequencing
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Formalin (buffered)
    Frozen