This paper compared DNA methylation profiles between matched buccal cell specimens and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). The association between DNA methylation and patient age, gender, ethnicity, and body mass index (BMI) was also investigated.
Discordance of DNA methylation variance between two accessible human tissues.
Jiang R, Jones MJ, Chen E, Neumann SM, Fraser HB, Miller GE, Kobor MS
Purpose
Conclusion
PBMCs had significantly higher mean DNA methylation levels than buccal cells, but buccal cell specimens had larger overall inter-individual ranges than PBMCs and inter-tissue variation was higher than inter-individual variation. Of the 998 CpG sites analyzed, 537 CpGs were significantly different between PBMCs and buccal cells and this variation was mostly due to differences in methylation levels of low CpG density islands sites. While DNA methylation was not associated with patient age, ethnicity, or alcohol consumption in either specimen type; both tissues had methylated CpG sites that were associated with patient gender but only PBMCs demonstrated a substantial number (>50) that were statistically significant. Similarly, more CpGs were associated with BMI in PBMCs than in buccal cells.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared DNA methylation profiles between matched buccal cell specimens and PBMCs. The association between DNA methylation and patient age, gender, ethnicity, and BMI was also investigated. Buccal cell and blood specimens were collected using unspecified methods from 25 healthy volunteers (26 to 45 years old, 15 males and 10 females, 18 Caucasians and 7 non-Caucasians, BMI of 18.18–47.95). PBMCs were isolated from blood using density gradient centrifugation. Genomic DNA was extracted from PBMCs and buccal cells by an undescribed method, treated with the EZ DNAm kit, and DNA methylation at 1,536 CpG loci and 371 genes was evaluated by microarray.
Summary of Findings
For each participant, PBMCs had significantly higher mean DNA methylation rates than buccal cells (P=3.16 x 10-14), but buccal cell specimens had larger overall inter-individual ranges than PBMCs (P=2.05 x 10-8). Variation between specimen types was higher than individual variation with a correlation coefficient of 0.773 between buccal and PBMC specimens and correlation coefficients among individuals of 0.980 for buccal cells and 0.987 for PBMC. Of the 998 CpG sites analyzed, 537 CpGs (53.8%) were significantly different between PBMCs and buccal cells (P<0.001). This variation between specimen types was mostly due to a higher level of methylation of low CpG density islands sites in PBMC specimens (mean correlation of 0.514) as opposed to high CpG density islands, intermediate CpG density islands, or uncategorized sites (mean correlations of 0.748, 0.757, and 0.795; respectively). Exclusion of sites representative of cellular processes specific to buccal cells or PBMCs resulted in 449 differentially methylated sites. Low CpG density islands which constituted only 21% (212/998) of total CpG sites analyzed, represented 31% of those differentially methylated (P=1.02 x 10-12). While DNA methylation was not associated with age or ethnicity in either specimen type, both PBMC and buccal cell specimens had methylated CpG sites that were associated with gender but only PBMCs demonstrated a substantial number (>50) that were statistically significant. Similarly, more CpGs were associated with BMI in PBMCs than in buccal cells.
Biospecimens
CellBuccalCellWhite CellsFluidBloodPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
NormalPlatforms
DNADNA microarrayDNABisulfite conversion assayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Patient age 26 to 45 yPreaquisition Patient body mass index 18.18–47.95Preaquisition Patient gender FemaleMalePreaquisition Patient race Caucasiannon-CaucasianBiospecimen Acquisition Biospecimen location BloodBuccal cellsBiospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Cheek rubbing during collectionVenipuncture