Skip to main content

Comparison of formalin-free tissue fixatives: a proteomic study testing their application for routine pathology and research.

Kothmaier H, Rohrer D, Stacher E, Quehenberger F, Becker KF, Popper HH

Publication: Arch Pathol Lab Med (2011) • Vol 135 • Page 744-52PMID: 21631267View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared histopathology and immunohistochemistry (IHC) in matched paraffin-embedded specimens fixed with three different formalin-free fixatives and standard formalin and compared protein yield and Western blot staining in fixed and snap-frozen specimens.

Conclusion

Movat staining was comparable between specimens preserved with all three formalin-free fixatives and those processed with standard formalin fixation but H&E-staining of HOPE-fixed sections was inferior compared to FFPE and the other formalin-free fixatives. While CK7 and PCNA IHC-staining were comparable among the specimens fixed with formalin-free fixatives and FFPE, the intensity of STAT-1 staining was higher in FFPE sections than those preserved with formalin-free fixatives. Conversely, EGFR and E-cadherin IHC staining was more intense in specimens preserved with formalin-free fixatives than in FFPE specimens. Overall comparison of Western blot results demonstrated higher protein integrity from specimens preserved with formalin-free fixatives and frozen tissues compared to FFPE tissue although protein yields were lower from frozen specimens than from fixed specimens, regardless of fixative.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared histopathology and IHC in matched paraffin embedded lung cancer specimens fixed with three different formalin-free fixatives and standard formalin and compared protein recovery from fixed specimens with that from frozen specimens. Five tissue specimens from each lung cancer patient (n=10) were taken and fixed with 10% neutral-buffered formalin (21-69 h), paraffin-embedded, and dehydrated according to the standard protocols; embedded in optimal cutting temperature (OCT) medium, snap-frozen, and stored in liquid nitrogen; or fixed for 21-69 h in a formalin-free fixative (FineFIX, RCL2, or HOPE), dehydrated, and paraffin-embedded. The FFPE, paraffin-embedded FineFIX, and paraffin-embedded RCL2 tissue blocks were stored at room temperature, whereas the paraffin-embedded HOPE tissue blocks were maintained at 4°C per manufacturers’ recommendations. FFPE, FineFIX, RCL2, and HOPE tissue sections (4 mm) were dewaxed with xylene and dehydrated with ethanol before hematoxylin-eosin (H&E) staining, Movat pentachrome staining, and immunohistochemical staining for cytokeratin 7 (CK7), E-cadherin, epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), and signal transducer and activator of transcription 1 (STAT1). For protein analysis, five 10-mm thick tissue sections from each FFPE block were cut, placed onto glass slides, deparaffinized, and then tumor areas were microdissected. For frozen tissue specimens, multiple 10-mm-thick sections were cut onto glass slides and stored at -80°C until protein extraction was performed. Proteins from all specimens were extracted using the Qproteome kit buffer and stored frozen at -20°C. Protein concentrations were determined using a BCA Protein Assay Kit and Western blot analysis was performed for Beta-actin, E-cadherin, EGFR, PCNA, and STAT1.

Summary of Findings

Movat staining and tumor cell analysis was comparable between specimens preserved with all three formalin-free fixatives and those fixed with formalin. While all fixatives resulted in good H&E-staining for tissue analysis, HOPE-fixed sections were inferior in visualization of nuclear features and mucin and surfactant inclusions than FFPE, FineFIX, and RCL2 sections. CK7, STAT1, and PCNA staining were comparable in FineFIX-, RCL2-, and HOPE-fixed sections (P≥0.05 for all) but specimens fixed with RCL2 and FineFIX had superior staining of the membrane proteins E-cadherin (P=0.01) and EGFR (P=0.03). In comparison to FFPE specimens, no statistical differences were observed for PCNA and CK7 staining between specimens fixed with the different formalin-free fixatives or STAT1 staining between FFPE and HOPE-fixed specimens but FFPE-preserved sections stained with higher intensity compared to those fixed with FineFIX and RCL2 (P=0.005, both); however, neither STAT1 nor PCNA could be detected in specimens preserved with the formalin-free fixatives when the staining intensity was low in the matched FFPE specimen. In contrast, EGFR staining was significantly higher in sections of FineFIX and RCL2 preserved specimens compared to FFPE specimens (P=0.005, both) and E-cadherin staining was higher in RCL2- and HOPE-fixed specimens (P=0.007 and P=0.02, respectively) than in FFPE specimens.

Overall comparison of Western blot results demonstrated higher protein integrity from FineFIX, RCL2, HOPE, and frozen tissues compared to FFPE tissue (P<0.001, all). Western blot analysis demonstrated higher band intensities for Beta-actin and STAT1 in frozen tissue than fixed tissue, but PCNA band intensity was higher in fixed specimens. While no significant difference was observed between FFPE specimens and specimens processed with the formalin-free fixatives for Beta-actin and PCNA, STAT1 band intensity was higher in HOPE-preserved specimens (P=0.01). EGFR results were significantly higher in the formalin-free specimen (P=0.007) compared to FFPE tissue section but the intensity and band location for E-cadherin showed no difference among any of the fixation methods. Protein yields were higher from RCL2-preserved specimens than FFPE tissues (P=0.01) and from RCL2- and HOPE-preserved specimens compared to frozen specimens (P=0.02 and P=0.03, respectively). Interestingly, protein yield from frozen specimens was lower than that from fixed specimens, regardless of fixative.

  • Biospecimens

    TissueLung
  • Preservation Types

    FormalinFrozenOther Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
  • Platforms

    MorphologyLight microscopy
    ProteinImmunohistochemistry
    ProteinWestern blot
    ProteinColorimetric assay
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    FineFIX
    Formalin (buffered)
    HOPE
    RCL2
    Snap frozen
    Western blot SpecificTargeted peptide/protein
    Beta-actin
    E-cadherin
    EGFR
    PCNA
    STAT1
    Immunohistochemistry SpecificTargeted peptide/protein
    CK7
    E-cadherin
    EGFR
    PCNA
    STAT1