This paper investigated the effects of nurse versus patient collection, cleanser type, and private rather than group instruction on contamination of voided urine specimens collected from women in an outpatient clinic.
A comparison of methods for collecting clean-catch urine specimens in a clinic population of obstetric patients.
Chavigny KH, Nunnally DS
Purpose
Conclusion
The percentage of contaminated specimens was higher and the percentage of specimens with no growth was lower after cleaning with benzalconium chloride than after cleaning with hexachlorophene or prepodyne, but the percentage of positive specimens was comparable among the three methods. There was no effect of group rather than individual instruction or nurse rather than patient collection on the incidence of contamination in urine specimens.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of nurse versus patient collection, cleanser type, and private rather than group instruction on contamination of voided urine specimens collected from women in an outpatient clinic. A total of 1469 urine specimens were obtained from 1350 women aged 13 to 45 years. Prior to collection, women either attended private or group instruction on vulva-perineal cleansing. The patient (all cleaning methods) or nurse (hexachlorophene only) cleansed the vulva-perineal area using four wipes containing either benzalconium chloride (139 specimens collected between May 15 and June 30), hexachlorophene (835 specimens collected between July 1- November 9), or prepodyne (375 specimens collected after November 11) and then with a Tuck pad. Mid-stream urine was collected and transported to the laboratory for cell culture. Contamination was defined as <105 colonies and a positive culture was defined as >105 colonies.
Summary of Findings
Contamination rates were higher in specimens collected after cleaning with benzalconium chloride (51.80%) than after cleaning with hexachlorophene (29.78%) or prepodyne (26.67%), and the percentage of specimens with no growth was also lower in specimens collected after cleaning with benzalconium chloride (35.25%) than after cleaning with hexachlorophene (59.03%) or prepodyne (64.27%). The percentage of positive specimens was comparable in specimens obtained after cleaning with hexachlorophene (11.2%), prepodyne (9.07%), and benzalconium chloride (11.48%). There was no effect of group rather than individual instruction or nurse rather than patient collection on the incidence of contamination in urine specimens.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Collection site preparation methods comparedDifferent urine collection procedures comparedVoided urine (spot collection)