Skip to main content

Contamination rates of three urine-sampling methods to assess bacteriuria in pregnant women.

Schneeberger C, van den Heuvel ER, Erwich JJ, Stolk RP, Visser CE, Geerlings SE

Publication: Obstet Gynecol (2013) • Vol 121 • Page 299-305PMID: 23344279View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the results of gram staining and urine culture results in mid-stream urine collected during the first void and second void and clean-catch urine and investigated if dipstick results were predictive of gram-stain or positive culture.

Conclusion

Collection of mid-stream urine during the second void resulted in slightly more gram-positive rods and gram staining and culture found mixed growth in a larger percentage of mid-stream first void than mid-stream second void or clean-catch specimens, but no other significant effects were identified.  Further, dipstick results for leukocyte esterase were not predictive of the presence of leukocytes in the gram stain and a positive dipstick for nitrites was not a predictor of positive urine culture.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared the results of gram staining and urine culture in mid-stream urine collected during the first void and second void and clean-catch urine and investigated if dipstick results were predictive of gram stain or positive culture. Three consecutive urine specimens were collected from 113 women during uncomplicated singleton pregnancy of more than 22-weeks gestation. Mid-stream urine was collected without any cleaning during the first void and the subsequent void. The final specimen was collected mid-stream while holding the labia apart and after cleaning the meatus and mucosa with wet cotton balls. Specimens were refrigerated until transported to the laboratory. Leukocyte esterase and nitrites were tested by dipstick and urine was gram stained and cultured. Microscopy of individual cell types was classified based on a 12.5 x 100 magnification as none (0 cells/gram stain), sporadic (1-10 cells/gram stain), few (1-2 cells/view), moderate (2-10 organisms or 2-5 cells/view), many (10-50 organisms or 5-10 cells/view), or much (more than 50 organisms or more than 10 cells/view). The culture was examined daily for growth and classified as negative (no growth or just skin flora), mixed growth (at least two organisms), low growth (<104 CFU/mL), or positive (≥104 CFU/mL).

Summary of Findings

Gram positive rods were slightly more likely to be present in mid-stream urine collected at the second void (77.7%) than the first void (71.7%) or in clean-catch specimens (66.7%).

The presence of epithelial cells was not significantly affected by the collection method. Epithelial cells were present in 50.4% of first and 58.9% of second mid-stream urine specimens and 56.8% of clean-catch specimens, but they were relevant contaminants in only 1.8% of first or second mid-stream specimens and 2.7% of clean-catch specimens. Gram staining showed mixed growth was present in 34.5% of first void and 25.9% of second void mid-stream urine specimens and 27.9% of clean-catch specimens.

Culture showed a single microorganism at ≥104 CFU/mL was found in 4.4% of first and 4.5% second void mid-stream urine specimens and 3.6% of clean-catch specimens. Mixed growth was significantly affected by urine collection method (P=0.05) and was present in 6.2% of first and 0.9% second void mid-stream urine specimens and 2.7% of clean-catch specimens. Negative culture results were obtained in 88.5% of first and 92.9% second void mid-stream urine specimens and 90.1% of clean-catch specimens.

Interestingly, only 23 of 143 specimens (16.1%) with a positive leukocyte dipstick test also had a positive gram stain for leukocytes and only three of 14 positive nitrite tests were positive in culture.

Compared to mid-stream collection during the second void, collection of mid-stream urine at first void or clean-catch urine was more likely to yield mixed growth during culture (odds ratio at 95% confidence of 7.4 and 3.08, respectively), but all other odds ratios were less than 2.0.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidUrine
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Pregnant
    Normal
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeColorimetric assay
    Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assay
    Cell count/volumeLight microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    Collection site preparation methods compared
    Different urine collection procedures compared
    Voided urine (spot collection)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionTime of biospecimen collection
    First void
    Second void
    Microbiological assay SpecificTechnology platform
    Dipstick
    Gram-stain
    Colorimetric assay SpecificTechnology platform
    Light microscopy
    Urine culture