Skip to main content

Evaluation of liquid and lyophilized preservatives for urine culture.

Weinstein MP

Publication: J Clin Microbiol (1983) • Vol 18 • Page 912-6PMID: 6630469View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper investigated the effects of urine preservation and delayed culture on urine culture results.

Conclusion

When cultured immediately after arrival at the laboratory, culture results for unpreserved specimens were in agreement with results for 99.4% of specimens preserved in liquid boric acid, glycerol, and sodium formate solution (LQ) and 99.5% of those preserved with lyophilized boric acid, sorbitol, and sodium formate (LY). When culture was delayed by 24 h, there was 99.0% agreement between unpreserved specimens and specimens preserved in LQ or LY. When results were compared between specimens immediately cultured and those held overnight before culture in the same media, there was agreement in 82.7% of unpreserved specimens, 84.5% of LQ preserved specimens, and 83.9% of LY preserved specimens.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study investigated the effects of urine preservation and delayed culture on urine culture results. Mid-stream clean voided or catheterized urine was collected from in-patients (no diagnosis) in sterile cups. Aliquots were transferred into a tube containing liquid boric acid, glycerol, and sodium formate solution (LQ, 869 specimens) or lyophilized boric acid, sorbitol, and sodium formate (LY, 556 specimens) and transported to the laboratory by courier with the remaining specimen in the sterile cup . Each specimen was cultured immediately and again after overnight storage of the unpreserved specimen in the refrigerator and the matched specimen at room temperature. The time between collection and first culture was known for 556 of the 869 specimens and was <2 h for 325 of these specimens (58.4%) and more than 2 h for 231 of these specimens (41.6%). 

Summary of Findings

When cultured immediately after arrival at the laboratory, culture results for unpreserved for unpreserved specimens were in agreement with results for 99.4% of specimens preserved in LQ and 99.5% of those preserved in LY. The discrepancies in culture results between LQ and unpreserved specimens were positive (≥105 CFU/mL) in the unpreserved specimen but negative (<105 CFU/mL, 3 cases) or contaminated (2 cases) in the LQ preserved specimen. The discrepancies between unpreserved and LY preserved specimens consisted of one specimen that was positive in the unpreserved specimen but had 104-5 CFU/mL in the LY preserved specimen and another specimen where the opposite result was found. When culture was delayed by 24 h, there was 99.0% agreement between unpreserved specimens and specimens preserved in LQ or LY. Importantly, discrepancies observed after 24 h included some in which the unpreserved specimen was judged more accurate and some in which the preserved specimen was more accurate. Of specimens growing 104-5 CFU/mL in the unpreserved specimen, 16 of 22 matched LQ specimens (73%) and 14 of 17 LY specimens had 104-5 CFU/mL of the same strain when cultured immediately and 12 of 16 matched LQ specimens (75%) and 8 of 11 matched LY specimens (73%) had 104-5 CFU/mL of the same strain when cultured after 24 h. Finally, when results were compared between specimens immediately cultured and those held overnight before culture in the same media, there was agreement in 82.7% of unpreserved specimens, 84.5% of LQ preserved specimens, and 83.9% of LY preserved specimens.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidUrine
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)Other Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assay
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Boric acid
    Glycerol
    None (fresh)
    Refrigeration
    Sodium formate
    StorageStorage duration
    0 h
    24 h
    StorageStorage temperature
    Refrigerated
    Room temperature