Skip to main content

A midstream urine collector is not a good alternative to a sterile collection method during the diagnosis of urinary tract infection.

Verliat-Guinaud J, Blanc P, Garnier F, Gajdos V, Guigonis V

Publication: Acta Paediatr (2015) • Vol 104 • Page e395-400PMID: 25857456View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared urine culture results between urine collected in the bag (early) or tube (late) of a midstream collection device with those in matched catheter specimens from children under the age of three with positive dipstick results.The effect of excluding specimens obtained from patients not recorded to be standing on the rate of inconsistent results was also investigated.

Conclusion

Culture results were consistent between catheter and matched bag or tube specimens in 78.7% and 76.7% of cases, respectively, with contamination occurring in a comparable number of catheter specimens (5) and tube or bag specimens (6 each). Patient position did not affect the number of inconsistent results which were comparable between catheter specimens and their corresponding bag and tube specimens, regardless of inclusion of all specimens in the analysis or just those obtained while upright. The majority of inconsistent results were found when the catheter specimen was positive and the bag or tube specimen had growth below the threshold to be considered positive.  

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared urine culture results between urine collected in the bag (early) or tube (late) of a midstream collection device with those in matched catheter specimens from children under the age of three with positive dipstick results. The effect of excluding specimens obtained from patients not recorded to be standing on the rate of inconsistent results was also investigated..  A catheter specimen was collected from 94 children under the age of three whose urine collected in the tube or bag of a midstream collection device had tested positive for leukocyte esterase or nitrites using dipsticks. The catheter specimen was sent along with the refrigerated midstream urine specimens for microscopy and culture. Urine cultures were considered positive if they contained ≥103 CFU/mL of a single pathogen in catheter specimen or ≥105 CFU/mL of a single pathogen in the midstream specimens. Polybacterial growth was defined as ≥103 CFU/mL of two or more pathogens.

Summary of Findings

Urine cultures were positive in 56.9% of catheter specimens, 46.8% of bag specimens, and 45.7% of tube specimens. Consistent results were found between catheter and bag specimens in 78.7% of cases (74 of 94). Discrepant cases included nine specimens that were positive in the catheter specimen and negative in the bag specimen, five cases with polybacterial growth in the catheter specimen, and six cases with polybacterial growth in the bag specimen. Similarly, consistent results were found in catheter and tube specimens in 76.7% of cases (72 of 94) and discrepancies included 11 specimens that were positive in the catheter specimen but negative in the tube specimen, five cases with polybacterial growth in the catheter specimen, and six cases with polybacterial growth in the tube specimen. Patient position did not affect the rate of inconsistent results which were comparable between catheter specimens and their corresponding bag and tube specimens, regardless of inclusion of all specimens in the analysis or just those obtained while upright. Importantly, all cases that were negative in the bag or tube specimen but positive in the catheter specimen had monobacterial growth that was below the threshold for midstream collection. 

  • Biospecimens

    FluidUrine
  • Preservation Types

    Other PreservativeNone (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Other diagnoses
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assay
    Cell count/volumeLight microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    Catheterized urine
    Different urine collection procedures compared
    Voided urine (spot collection)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionPatient posture
    Sitting
    Standing
    Supine