This paper investigated the effects of collecting urine after perineal cleansing (clean-catch urine) rather than non-clean-catch urine on the contamination rates in matched specimens from 100 pregnant adolescents. The authors also investigated if positive urinalysis or pyuria were more common in specimens that cultured a pathogen.
Perineal cleansing does not reduce contamination of urine samples from pregnant adolescents.
Schlager TA, Smith DE, Donowitz LG
Purpose
Conclusion
For 87 of the 100 patients, the results were identical in the clean-catch (after perineal cleansing) and non-clean catch specimen and for 7 of the 13 discrepant cases there was no growth in the non-clean-catch specimen and non-pathogenic growth in the clean-catch specimen. The percentage of specimens considered contaminated or non-contaminated was comparable between clean-catch and non-clean-catch specimens. Importantly, positive urinalysis was not a predictor of pathogen growth but pyuria was more common in specimens that cultured a pathogen than those that had no growth.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of collecting clean-catch urine rather than non-clean-catch urine on the contamination rates in matched specimens from 100 pregnant adolescents. The authors also investigated if positive urinalysis or pyuria were more common in specimens that cultured a pathogen.
Summary of Findings
Two consecutive urine specimens were collected during a single prenatal visit from patients aged 10-19. Women who had taken antibiotics in the prior 7 days or displayed symptoms of urinary tract infection were excluded. The first specimen was collected mid-stream without any prior cleaning into a sterile specimen container. Prior to collection of the second specimen, the patient cleaned the urethral meatus and then the peritoneum with a Castille soap towelette and then collected midstream urine into the clean-catch urine kit container. Specimens were refrigerated for up to 5 h before urinalysis using dipsticks and microscopy and bacterial culture. The authors defined a urinalysis as positive when the specimen contained bacteria and/or were positive for nitrite on the dipstick and had either more than five leukocytes/field or was positive for leukoesterase on the dipstick. Significant bacteruria was defined at ≥105 cfu/mL of a single pathogen (species of Enterobacteriaceae, Enterococcus, Staphylococcus aureus, Staphylococcus saprophyticus, or group B streptococci). Sterile urine contained <103 cfu pathogens/mL while contaminated urine contained <105 cfu/mL of pathogenic bacteria or non-pathogenic bacteria.
For 87 of the 100 patients, the results were identical in the clean-catch (collected after perineal cleansing) and non-clean-catch specimen including 33 with no growth, 44 which cultured non-pathogens, and 10 that grew the same pathogen in both specimens. The discrepant specimens included seven which had no growth in the non-clean-catch specimen but non-pathogenic growth in the clean-catch specimen, three which cultured group B streptococci in the non-clean-catch specimen but non-pathogenic growth in the clean-catch specimen, one which cultured Escherichia coli in the non-clean-catch specimen but non-pathogenic growth in the clean-catch specimen, one that cultured non-pathogenic growth in the non-clean-catch specimen but cultured group B streptococci in the clean-catch specimen, and one that cultured non-pathogenic growth in the non-clean-catch specimen but had no growth in the clean-catch specimen. Overall, 55 of the non-clean-catch specimens and 62 of the clean-catch specimens were considered contaminated (P=0.38). Similarly, 40 non-clean-catch and 34 clean-catch specimens had no growth (P=0.46). Importantly, positive urinalysis was found in 11 of 25 specimens that cultured a pathogen and 24 of 33 that were sterile (P=0.33) but pyuria was more common in specimens that cultured a pathogen than those that had no growth (32% versus 8% P=0.006) and also occurred in 17% of specimens that had non-pathogenic growth.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
PregnantOther diagnosesPlatforms
Cell count/volumeLight microscopyCell count/volumeColorimetric assayCell count/volumeMicrobiological assayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Collection site preparation methods comparedDifferent urine collection procedures comparedVoided urine (spot collection)