This paper investigated the effects of storing urine at room temperature in BD tubes rather than refrigerating in the original collection container and of analysis method on urine culture results.
Comparison of the B-D urine culture kit with a standard culture method and with the MS-2.
Hubbard WA, Shalis PJ, McClatchey KD
Purpose
Conclusion
Storage of urine at room temperature in BD tubes resulted in a larger decrease in the number of positive cultures and positive MS-2 results than when refrigerated in the collection container. The decline in positivity was greater when analyzed by MS-2 rather than by culture. Importantly, storage in BD tubes resulted in a lag in logarithmic growth compared to refrigerated storage.
Studies (2)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of storing urine at room temperature in BD tubes rather than refrigerating in the original collection container on urine culture results and MS-2 analysis in 100 urine specimens. Clean-voided midstream or catheterized urine specimens were collected from 100 randomly selected patients who were submitting urine for analysis. Half of each urine specimen was transferred into a BD urine transport tube, mixed, and stored at room temperature. The remainder of the urine specimen was stored at 8 ˚C ± 2. Urine specimens were mixed well and cultured after 0 and 24 h and examined after 24 and 48 h. Specimens were analyzed with the Abbott Laboratories MS-2 system at 0, 5, and 24 h.
Summary of Findings
When cultured immediately, 33 cultures were negative, 20 cultures were contaminated, 16 cultures had <104 cfu/mL, 5 cultures had 104-105 cfu/mL, and 26 cultures had >105 cfu/mL, regardless of tube type. Importantly, negative specimens were negative using either the standard culture method or the MS-2 system and while there was variability in counts among specimens with <105 cfu/mL, all remained <105 cfu/mL by both MS-2 and culture. There was no effect of refrigerated storage for up to 24 h in specimens with >105 cfu/mL, but the counts declined below 105 cfu/mL in 15% of specimens when stored in BD tubes. The detection rates were comparable for refrigerated and BD urine when analyzed by MS-2, but 6 of 26 organisms identified by culture were not found by MS-2.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
Other PreservativeNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedOther diagnosesPlatforms
Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assayCell count/volumeLight scatteringPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Boric acidGlycerolNone (fresh)RefrigerationSodium formateStorage Storage duration 0 h24 h5 hStorage Storage temperature 8˚CRoom temperature
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of storing urine at room temperature in BD tubes rather than refrigerating in the original collection container on urine culture results in 158 specimens found to contain bacteria using the MS-2 system. Urine specimens were analyzed with MS-2, cultured for 18-24 h, and the remainder refrigerated. Aliquots of the 158 specimens that were positive for bacteria using both the MS-2 system and by culture were transferred into BD tubes for room temperature storage while the remainder was left refrigerated in the original container. After 24 h, urine in BD tubes and the refrigerated specimen were cultured and analyzed using the MS-2 system.
Summary of Findings
Colony counts declined in 17.2% of specimens stored in BD tubes at room temperature for 24 h, but only declined in 7.0% of specimens refrigerated for 24 h in the original container. Although all 14 specimens culturing Group D enterococci and 13 specimens culturing other gram negative rods remained positive, at least one specimen that cultured other bacterial species types was no longer positive when cultured after 24 h at room temperature in BD tubes. Importantly, nine organisms were found to decline both in refrigerated and BD stored urine. When analyzed by MS-2, only 63.3% of specimens stored for 24 h in BD tubes were still positive compared to 91.1% of refrigerated urine specimens. Importantly, loss of positivity was found for Group D enterococci and gram negative rods in BD tubes only and Logarithmic growth was observed earlier in refrigerated urine than BD urine when analyzed by MS-2.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
Other PreservativeNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
Other diagnosesPlatforms
Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assayCell count/volumeLight scatteringPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Boric acidGlycerolNone (fresh)RefrigerationSodium formateStorage Storage duration 0 h24 hStorage Storage temperature 8˚CRoom temperatureMicrobiological assay Specific Technology platform MS-2Standard culture