Skip to main content

Urine sampling in ambulatory women: midstream clean-catch versus catheterization.

Walter FG, Knopp RK

Publication: Ann Emerg Med (1989) • Vol 18 • Page 166-72PMID: 2916781View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared results and diagnostic accuracy of midstream clean-catch and catheterized urine from 105 women with symptoms of a urinary tract infection (UTI).

Conclusion

Concordant culture results were obtained using the catheter and clean-catch specimen in 80 of 105 cases (76%) with most discordance due to contamination of the clean-catch specimen, which the authors consider clinical concordance. Overall, the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of clean-catch specimens for diagnosis of UTI based on the catheter specimen was 98%, 97%, 95%, and 98%, respectively.  Further, the sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV for UTI diagnosis using leukocyte esterase, nitrites, pyuria, and microscopic bacteria were not significantly different in catheter and clean-catch urine. The authors conclude that use of catheterized urine decreases contamination but does not significantly affect diagnosis of UTI.

Studies (2)

Purpose

This study compared the diagnostic accuracy of midstream clean-catch urine for diagnosis of urinary tract infection (UTI) based on catheter urine. Pregnant women and those who had taken antibiotics in the previous 48 h were excluded. The periurethral area was cleaned by swabbing with three povidone-iodine-soaked gauze pads and a midstream urine specimen was collected. Immediately following collection of the mid-stream specimen, the patient was cleaned with povidone-iodine and catheterized by a nurse. Urine was cultured for 48 h before analysis. The catheterized specimen defined the presence of UTI.

Summary of Findings

Concordant results were obtained using the catheter and clean-catch specimen in 80 of 105 cases (76%). Of the 25 cases with discordant results, 21 had contamination of the clean-catch specimen. The authors state that contamination would not lead to a diagnosis of UTI and therefore these patients would be considered clinically concordant, resulting in a clinical concordance rate of 96%. Identical results were found between the clean-catch specimen and catheter specimen for 40 of the 42 cases considered positive for UTI. The discrepancies in the positive cases included a clean-catch specimen that cultured a second bacterium not found in the catheter specimen and a clean-catch specimen that grew mixed flora, indicating contamination. Of the 61 cases where no growth occurred in the catheter specimen, 40 had no growth, 18 had mixed growth, three had low level growth (<10,000 cfu/mL) and two were false positives (>10,000 cfu/mL of a single species) in the clean-catch specimen.

Overall, the sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV of clean-catch specimens for diagnosis of UTI in the catheter specimen was 98%, 97%, 95%, and 98%, respectively.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidUrine
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Other diagnoses
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assay
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    Different urine collection procedures compared
    Needle
    Voided urine (spot collection)