Skip to main content

Comparison of urine contamination rates using three different methods of collection: clean-catch, cotton wool pad and urine bag.

Alam MT, Coulter JB, Pacheco J, Correia JB, Ribeiro MG, Coelho MF, Bunn JE

Publication: Ann Trop Paediatr (2005) • Vol 25 • Page 29-34PMID: 15814046View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared contamination rates of clean-catch urine with urine collected in pads (wool or cotton sanitary) or in bags from hospitalized children without urinary tract infections (UTI).

Conclusion

Collection by the clean-catch method resulted in significantly less contamination than collection on pads (14.7% versus 29%) or bags (14.7% versus 26.6%). Non-significant increases in contamination rates were observed when collection was on sanitary pads rather than the Newcastle pads and when urine was collected by the clean-catch method from girls rather than boys. The number of specimens that were culture positive increased with an increase in bacteria observed by microscopy.  

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared contamination rates of clean-catch urine with urine collected in pads (wool or sanitary) or bags from hospitalized children less than three years old without UTI. When possible, urine specimens were collected by each of the three methods from the 191 patients on the same day but if necessary, collection was continued the next day.  Collection in wool pads involved placing Newcastle pads (first 110 patients) or cotton sanitary pads (59 patients) inside the diaper and checking every 10 minutes to determine when wet. When the pad was wet, urine was aspirated into a syringe. To collect clean-catch urine specimens, the child sat on the parent’s lap not wearing a diaper until the specimen was collected. Urine was refrigerated until analyzed by contrast phase microscopy within 1 h and culture, which occurred within 2 h. The patient was considered to have a urinary tract infection when more than 105 cfu/ml bacteria were found by all three methods and the specimens were excluded. Similarly, specimens were excluded if the patient was considered indeterminate (at least one specimen considered positive for UTI). Any growth on culture was considered positive for contaminants.

Summary of Findings

Twelve of the 191 patients (6.3%) were found to have UTI and three patients were indeterminate for UTI, thus urine from 15 patients was excluded from further analysis.  At least one contaminated specimen was collected from 76 of the 160 included patients who provided urine by all three methods (47.5%).

Collection by the clean-catch method resulted in significantly less contamination than collection on pads (14.7% versus 29%, P<0.01) or bags (14.7% versus 26.6%, P<0.01). Collection on sanitary pads rather than the Newcastle pads resulted in non-significant increases in contamination rates (36% versus 26%). Only slight agreement was observed between clean-catch and bag (22%) or pad specimens (20%), but there was moderate agreement between bag and pads (40%). Contamination by the clean-catch method was non-significantly lower in boys than girls (12% versus 19%) and the authors report comparable contamination in specimens from boys and girls when collected in bags or pads. The number of specimens that were culture positive increased with an increase in bacteria observed by microscopy.  Using a cut-off or ≤10 bacteria/five small squares; microscopy properly classified 76.3% of negative specimens and 48.4% of contaminated specimens.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidUrine
  • Preservation Types

    Other Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeMicrobiological assay
    Cell count/volumeLight microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    PreaquisitionPatient gender
    Female
    Male
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    Different urine collection procedures compared
    Voided urine (spot collection)
    Microbiological assay SpecificTechnology platform
    Phase-contrast microscopy