This paper investigated the effects of perineal cleansing, separating the labia majora and minora during collection, and collecting only mid-stream urine on bacterial contamination of urine specimens. The authors also investigated if contraceptive use, history of urinary tract infection (UTI), and menstrual status impacted contamination rates.
Evaluation of urine sampling technique: bacterial contamination of samples from women students.
Baerheim A, Digranes A, Hunskaar S
Purpose
Conclusion
Compared to specimens collected without precautions, labial separation resulted in a 58.2% lower percentage of contaminated specimens, but when performed in combination with collection of only mid-stream urine and/or perineal cleansing the reduction in contamination rates was not significant. Separating the labia during collection significantly increased the percentage of uncontaminated specimens versus collection without precautions, but the effect was only significant when combined with collection of mid-stream urine. The authors state that the decreases of contamination observed were regardless of the order of collection, contraceptive use, menstrual status, or history of UTI.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of perineal cleansing, separating the labia majora and minora during collection, and collecting only mid-stream urine on bacterial contamination of urine specimens. The authors also investigated if contraceptive use, history of UTI, and menstrual status impacted contamination rates. Urine was collected from 110 healthy women at their homes on eight consecutive days following different instructions each day. The collection methods were: collection without any special techniques, collection while separating the labia, collection following perineal cleansing, collection of only mid-stream urine, collection while separating the labia following perineal cleansing, collection of mid-stream urine while separating the labia, collection of mid-stream urine following perineal cleansing, and collection of mid-stream urine while separating the labia following perineal cleansing. Half of the women collected urine specimens in the above order, while the remainder collected urine in the opposite order. Immediately after collection, the women inoculated dipslides and delivered them to the laboratory the same day. Specimens were considered uncontaminated if they contained <105 colony-forming units (cfu)/mL.
Summary of Findings
Of the 864 specimens, 210 (24.3%) were considered contaminated (>105 cfu/mL). Compared to specimens collected without precautions, labial separation resulted in a 58.2% lower percentage of contaminated specimens (13% versus 31.1%, P<0.01), but the reduction in contamination rates was not significant when performed in combination with collection of only mid-stream urine and/or perineal cleansing. Further, collection of only mid-stream urine and/or perineal cleansing did not significantly affect contamination rates. Interestingly, while separating the labia during collection increased the percentage of uncontaminated specimens versus collection without precautions (22% versus 14.2%, P<0.001), the effect was only significant when combined with collection of mid-stream urine (14.2% versus 26.6%, P<0.05). The authors state that the decreases in contamination observed were regardless of the order of collection, contraceptive use, menstrual status, or history of urinary tract infection.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
NormalPlatforms
Cell count/volumeLight microscopyCell count/volumeMicrobiological assayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition History of UTINo history of UTIVarious stages of menstrual cyclePreaquisition Other drugs Contraceptives not takenContraceptives takenBiospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Collection site preparation methods comparedDifferent urine collection procedures compared