This paper investigated the effects on contamination of urine collected using a novel mid-stream urine collection device rather than traditional methods. The effects of patient posture, reason for testing, and locale of testing on the significance of the effects was also investigated.
A novel midstream urine-collection device reduces contamination rates in urine cultures amongst women.
Jackson SR, Dryden M, Gillett P, Kearney P, Weatherall R
Purpose
Conclusion
Although collection device did not affect the percentage of patients diagnosed with urinary tract infection (UTI), the novel collection device resulted in lower contamination rates (mixed growth or heavy growth) and reduced the need for retesting. Clinic, patient posture, and reason for test had no effect on the significance of the differences between sampling methods.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects on contamination of urine collected using a novel mid-stream urine collection device rather than traditional methods. The effects of patient posture, reason for testing, and locale of testing on the significance of the effects was also investigated. Women visiting antenatal clinics and general practice were randomly assigned for urine collection using the novel mid-stream urine collection device (1077 specimens) or collection of mid-stream urine using non-standardized conventional methods (1105 specimens) used in each clinic. Labial separation and cleansing were not advised for the novel device but not all clinics provided instruction. Analyses were conducted using dipsticks and culture.
Summary of Findings
Diagnosis of UTI occurred in a comparable number of specimens obtained with each method, but use of the novel device resulted in fewer specimens being classified as mixed growth (9% versus 14%, P=0.001) and heavy growth (1.2% versus 3.0%, P=0.004) and more specimens classified as clinically insignificant growth (88% versus 82%, P=0.005). Further, retesting was necessary in significantly fewer specimens collected using the novel device than the conventional methods (11% versus 16%, P=0.002). The novel collection system also resulted in less spillage than conventional collection (27% versus 46%, P<0.001). Clinic, patient posture, and reason for test had no effect on the significance of the differences between sampling methods.
Biospecimens
FluidUrinePreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPregnantPlatforms
Cell count/volumeLight microscopyCell count/volumeMicrobiological assayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Locale of biospecimen collection Different antenatal clinicsDifferent general practice clinicsBiospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Different urine collection procedures comparedVoided urine (spot collection)Biospecimen Acquisition Patient posture HoveringSittingStandingBiospecimen Acquisition Type of collection container/solution Novel midstream urine collection deviceTraditional urine collection cup