Skip to main content

Validation of a Gene Expression Test for Mesothelioma Prognosis in Formalin-Fixed Paraffin-Embedded Tissues.

De Rienzo A, Cook RW, Wilkinson J, Gustafson CE, Amin W, Johnson CE, Oelschlager KM, Maetzold DJ, Stone JF, Feldman MD, Becich MJ, Yeap BY, Richards WG, Bueno R

Publication: J Mol Diagn (2017) • Vol 19 • Page 65-71PMID: 27863259View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the risk classification based on real-time PCR gene expression scores (GES) of matched formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) and frozen mesothelioma specimens and investigated the effect of GES risk classification on survival in an independent mesothelioma cohort.

Conclusion

Overall, a concordant risk type was assigned for 64 of the 77 specimens (83%) with most discordant cases arising from specimens assigned as type B (poor prognosis) in the frozen specimen and being assigned as type A (good prognosis) in the matched FFPE specimen. Importantly, exclusion of specimens with a score close to the threshold (0.91-1.11) did not exclude eight of nine specimens classified as type B in the frozen specimen and type A in the matched FFPE specimen. In an independent cohort of FFPE specimens, those classified as type A had a significantly longer median survival time than those those classified as type B (18 versus 7 months, P=0.002). In these specimens, the predictive effect of GES score for survival was independent of histological and lymph node status and has a hazard ratio of 4.3.

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study compared the GES risk classification of matched FFPE and frozen specimens and investigated the effect of GES risk classification on survival in an independent cohort. Seventy-seven matched frozen and FFPE biopsy specimens of mesothelioma and an additional 73 FFPE specimens of mesothelioma were included in the study. Methods used to preserve and store specimens were not detailed. Tumor cells were macrodissected from 5 µm sections of FFPE specimens and RNA was extracted using the Ambion RecoverAll Total Nucleic Acid Isolation Kit or the PicoPure RNA isolation kit (text and figure give conflicting information). RNA was extracted in a different facility from 5 µm sections of frozen specimens using Trizol. Gene ratios for frozen specimens were based on SYBR real-time PCR and gene ratios for FFPE specimens were based on TaqMan microfluidic card real-time PCR assays. The geometric mean of the expression of transmembrane 4 L6 family member 1(TMSF1)/pyruvate kinase muscle isozyme M2 (PKM2), TM4SF1/ Rho GDP dissociation inhibitor alpha (ARHGDIA), and cordon-bleu protein-like 1 (COBLL1)/ARHGDIA was defined as the GES. A GES of ≥1 was considered to be type A, which was predicted to have good overall survival, but a GES of <1 was considered to be type B and was a predictor of poor survival. 

Summary of Findings

Of the 62 specimens classified as type A in the frozen specimen, 58 were also classified as type A in the FFPE specimen and four were classified as type B. Of the 15 specimens classified as type B in the frozen specimen, six were classified as type B in the FFPE specimen. Overall a concordant type was assigned for 64 of the 77 specimens (83%), with most discordant cases arising from specimens assigned as Type B in the frozen specimen being assigned as Type A in the FFPE specimen. Thus when prognosis is based on FFPE specimens, there are fewer cases assigned a poor prognosis. When specimens with a score close to the threshold (0.91-1.11) were excluded, all 64 concordant cases and eight of nine specimens classified as Type B in the frozen specimen and type A in the FFPE remained, but only one of the four cases misclassified as Type B in the FFPE specimen remained.

In the cohort of 73 FFPE specimens, 64 were classified as type A and nine as Type B. As expected, those classified as Type A had a median survival time of 18 months (range from 14-42) while those classified as type B had a significantly shorter median survival time of 7months (range from 1-14), (P=0.002). Importantly, the predictive effect of GES score for survival was independent of histological and lymph node status and had a hazard ratio of 4.3 (P=0.003). The hazard ratio of histological subtype and lymph node status were 2.4 (P=0.018) and 1.9 (P=0.088), respectively.

  • Biospecimens

    TissueLung
  • Preservation Types

    FormalinFrozen
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticOther
    NeoplasticMixed type
  • Platforms

    RNAReal-time qRT-PCR
    MorphologyH-and-E microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Formalin (buffered)
    Frozen
    Real-time qRT-PCR SpecificTargeted nucleic acid
    ARHGDIA
    COBLL1
    PKM2
    TM4SF1