Skip to main content

Circulating tumor cell isolation during resection of colorectal cancer lung and liver metastases: a prospective trial with different detection techniques.

Kaifi JT, Kunkel M, Das A, Harouaka RA, Dicker DT, Li G, Zhu J, Clawson GA, Yang Z, Reed MF, Gusani NJ, Kimchi ET, Staveley-O'Carroll KF, Zheng SY, El-Deiry WS

Publication: Cancer Biol Ther (2015) • Vol 16 • Page 699-708PMID: 25807199View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper compared the sensitivities of two methods of circulating tumor cell (CTC) isolation, CellSearch and size-based filter isolation (FMSA), in peripheral blood collected before, during, and after surgical metastasectomy. The paper also investigated if enriched and cultured CTCs from colorectal cancer patients express both epithelial cell and macrophage phenotypes.

Conclusion

CTC isolation using a FMSA filtration device resulted in significantly higher percentages of blood specimens with detectable CTCs and mean CTC counts per specimen than CellSearch (P=0.0001 to P<0.0078).  These differences were consistent across all blood collection timepoints examined: prior to, during, 30 min after, and 1 day after surgical resection.  Mean CTC count peaked during surgical resection in comparison to other timepoints using the FMSA filtration method (P=0.0281); however, while a similar trend was observed differences were nonsignificant when specimens were analyzed by CellSearch. Notably, a higher percentage of blood specimens were excluded from analysis due to clotting for FMSA filtration than CellSearch (35% compared to 8%). Upon examination of the resected tissue, the authors conclude that differences in CTC quantification between CellSearch (which enriches for EpCAM positive cells) and FMSA filtration assays are not a result of low EpCAM protein expression in the patients examined. When cultured, CTCs isolated with the OncoQuick method demonstrated both epithelial cell and macrophage phenotypes.

Studies (2)

Purpose

This study compared the sensitivities of two methods of circulating tumor cell (CTC) isolation. Blood was collected from 25 patients with stage IV colorectal cancer with liver or lung metastases undergoing metastasectomy. Fifteen ml of blood were collected from sites close to the liver metastases (central venous line/right atrium) and from the lung metastases (radial artery) before, during, and after metastasectomy and one day postoperative. Blood specimens were immediately split (7.5 ml each) into a CellSave tube for CellSearch analysis and an K2EDTA tube for filtration using a FMSA device. Specimens were analyzed within three days using the CellSearch protocol and the CTC Epithelial Cell Kit according to the manufacturer’s instructions. CTCs were isolated from blood collected in K2EDTA tubes within 24 hours with the FMSA device; fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde; stained for DAPI, CD45, and cytokeratin; and analyzed by fluorescent microscopy. All resected liver and lung metastases were immunohistochemically stained for EpCAM expression.

Summary of Findings

The percentage of blood specimens excluded from analysis due to clotting was higher for CTCs isolated by filtration with a FMSA device (35%) than CellSearch (8%). Of the specimens analyzed, CTC isolation using a FMSA filtration device resulted in significantly higher percentages of blood specimens with detectable CTCs and mean CTC counts per specimen than CellSearch (P=0.0001 to P<0.0078). The mean number of CTCs detected by CellSearch on postoperative day 1 (0.09) did not differ significantly from the mean number of CTCs detected at, during, and after resection (mean number of cells 0.42, 0.87, and 0.41, respectively; P= 0.3018). Conversely, the mean number of CTCs isolated by filtration using a FMSA device was significantly higher in blood collected during the resection (22.56 CTCs) than at incision (5.06 CTCs), 30 min after resection (7.00 CTCs), and on postoperative day 1 (10.65 CTCs) (P=0.0281). Higher numbers of CTCs were detected with FMSA than CellSearch for all four specimen collection timepoints (P<0.01 for each), although the largest difference between the CTC isolation methods occurred in blood specimens collected during resection (22.56 versus 0.87 CTCs, respectively). EpCAM was consistently expressed at high levels in colorectal liver and lung metastases and even in patients with no detectable CTCs (CellSearch). There was no significant association between the maximum number of CTCs detected and EpCAM intensity score (P= 0.2855). The authors state that the difference in the number of detectable CTCs between CellSearch and filtration with a FMSA device was not due to downregulated EpCAM expression within the tumor.

  • Biospecimens

    FluidBlood
    TissueLiver
    TissueLung
  • Preservation Types

    FormalinOther Preservative
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
  • Platforms

    ProteinFluorescent microscopy
    ProteinImmunohistochemistry
    Cell count/volumeFluorescent microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionTime of biospecimen collection
    30 min after resection
    Before incision
    During resection
    Postoperative day 1
    Biospecimen Aliquots and ComponentsCell capture method
    CellSearch
    FMSA
    Fluorescent microscopy SpecificTargeted peptide/protein
    CD45
    DAPI
    cytokeratin
    Immunohistochemistry SpecificTargeted peptide/protein
    EpCAM