This paper compared estrogen receptor (ER, esr) status in matched biopsy and mastectomy specimens and investigated the effects of patient age and menopausal status. The paper also investigated if differences in ER levels were predictive of differences in progesterone receptor (PR) levels.
Discrepancy in ER levels of breast carcinoma in biopsy vs mastectomy specimens.
Young SC, Burkett RJ, Stewart C
Purpose
Conclusion
All 15 patients with ER negative biopsies had ER negative mastectomy specimens, but 12 of 43 patients who had ER positive tumors in the biopsy had false negative ER determination in the resection specimen. Further, 13 of the 31 ER positive mastectomy specimens had ER levels that were less than half of levels observed in the matched biopsy. There was no effect of patient age or menopausal status on the concordance and differences in ER levels between biopsy and resection were not predictive of changes in PR levels.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared ER status in matched biopsy and mastectomy specimens and investigated the effects of patient age and menopausal status. The study also investigated if differences in ER levels were predictive of differences in PR levels. Matched biopsy and mastectomy specimens from 58 patients with breast cancer were frozen by an unspecified method within 10-15 min. Estrogen levels were determined using the dextron-coated charcoal extraction method and considered positive if greater than 7 fmol/mg protein in premenopausal women and greater than 10 fmol/mg protein in post-menopausal women.
Summary of Findings
Of the 58 biopsies, 43 were considered ER positive and 15 were considered ER negative. After mastectomy, 31 tumors were considered to be ER positive and 27 ER negative. Although all 15 patients with ER negative biopsies had ER negative resection specimens, 12 patients who had ER positive tumors in the biopsy had false negative ER determination in the resection specimen. Further, 13 of the 31 ER positive mastectomy specimens had ER levels that were less than half of levels observed in the biopsy. There was no effect of patient age or menopausal status on the concordance and differences in ER levels between biopsy and resection were not predictive of changes in PR levels.
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
ProteinReceptor bindingPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Biomarker level PR comparable in mastectomy and biopsyPR higher in mastectomy than biopsyPR lower in mastectomy than biopsyPreaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition PostmenopausalPremenopausalPreaquisition Patient age 27-72 yearsBiospecimen Acquisition Method of tissue acquisition BiopsyMastectomy