Skip to main content

Targeted or whole genome sequencing of formalin fixed tissue samples: potential applications in cancer genomics.

Munchel S, Hoang Y, Zhao Y, Cottrell J, Klotzle B, Godwin AK, Koestler D, Beyerlein P, Fan JB, Bibikova M, Chien J

Publication: Oncotarget (2015) • Vol 6 • Page 25943-61PMID: 26305677View on PubMed

Purpose

This paper investigated the effects of using formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) rather than snap-frozen specimens on whole genome sequencing (WGS), whole exome sequencing (WXS) and targeted exon sequencing (TES) results. 

Conclusion

 Sequencing results were highly concordant between the 13 case-matched mixed tumor type FFPE and frozen specimen cohort by WXS (98.9-99.9%) and by TES (99.77-99.89%) and in the single case-matched frozen and FFPE normal breast specimen analyzed by WGS (99.87%). Concordance between sequencing platforms was comparable for frozen and FFPE specimens when BeadChips and WGS were compared, but concordance between platforms was lower for FFPE specimens than frozen specimens when BeadChip sequencing data was compared with TES or WXS. While a higher rate of C>T substitutions among FFPE specimens was expected by the authors, the rate of these substitutions in discordant locations was only significantly higher in FFPE specimens by WXS, but not TES; further C>T substitutions were limited to CpG islands. Concordance for the detection of insertions or deletions between the 13 mixed tumor case-matched FFPE and frozen cohort was >93.33% by all three methods. Copy number variant analysis based on the low-pass WGS technique generated similar patterns for the 7 pars of case-matched FFPE and frozen specimens analyzed; and while slight differences in individual variants were noted, CNV data clustered by patient. 

Interestingly, only 10-25% of identified tumor specific mutations identified by TES and WXS were at the same position in FFPE and frozen specimens, but of those at the same location the majority were concordant(>80%).

Studies (1)

Purpose

This study investigated the effects of using formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) rather than snap-frozen specimens on results obtained by WGS, WXS and TES. Specimens of ovarian carcinomas (9 patients), infiltrating ductal carcinoma with a case-matched normal adjacent tissue specimen (1 patient), and colonic adenocarcinoma with a case-matched normal adjacent tissue specimen (1 patient) were divided and either snap frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80˚C or fixed in formalin for less than 2 days, paraffin-embedded and stored at 25˚C. DNA was isolated from snap-frozen specimens using the Qiagen DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit and from 5µm-thick FFPE sections following deparaffinization with Qiagen deparaffinization solution and overnight proteinase K digestion using the FFPE protocol for Qiagen's All Prep DNA/RNA FFPE Kit. DNA was quantified by PicoGreen and amplificability was verified by PCR. Whole genome sequencing (WGS) was conducted for one pair of frozen/FFPE specimens from normal adjacent breast. Targeted exon sequencing (TES) and whole exome sequencing (WXS) were performed on all 26 specimens. Low-pass WGS was performed to identify copy number variants on paired frozen/FFPE specimens in 5 of the ovarian carcinoma specimens as well as the breast and colon cancer specimens. Sequencing results from the frozen specimen were used as a reference and FFPE results for each base were classified as concordant (same result) or discordant (mismatch). Sequencing was also performed using OMiniExpress BeadChips.

Summary of Findings

Compared to results obtained with frozen specimens, the mismatch error rate for FFPE specimens was slightly higher for WXS, but not TES. Sequencing results were highly concordant between the 13 case-matched FFPE and frozen mixed tumor type specimens (ranging from 98.9% to 99.9% by WXS, and from to 99.77% to 99.89% by TES). Concordance between the single pair of normal FFPE and frozen breast tissue specimens was 99.87% by WGS. Sequencing data generated with frozen specimens displayed a similar degree of concordance between BeadChips and WGS as FFPE counterparts (98.6% versus 98.8%). However, sequencing data generated with frozen specimens displayed a higher degree of concordance than FFPE specimens when BeadChips and TES were compared (>95.15% versus >91.14%) or when BeadChips and WXS were compared (>96.47% versus >86.46%). Concordance for the detection of insertions or deletions between the 13 mixed tumor case-matched FFPE and frozen cohort was >93.33% by all three methods. The average size of an insertion and deletion was slightly longer for frozen specimens (6 bp and 9 bp, respectively) than FFPE specimens (5 bp and 8 bp, respectively), and frozen specimens displayed slightly increased coverage compared to FFPE specimens (79X versus 61X). While a higher rate of C>T substitutions among FFPE specimens was expected by the authors, the rate of these substitutions in discordant locations was only significantly higher in FFPE specimens by WXS, but not TES; further C>T substitutions were limited to CpG islands. It is important to note that the majority of discordance between FFPE and frozen specimen was attributable to the variant allele fraction filter, with many variants observed at a low level in the corresponding frozen specimen.

Copy number variant analysis based on the low-pass WGS technique generated similar patterns for the 7 pairs of case-matched FFPE and frozen specimens analyzed; and while slight differences in individual variants were noted, CNV data clustered by patient.

Comparison of case-matched normal adjacent and tumor specimens from the same two patients permitted the identification of 387-491 and 30-49 tumor-specific mutations by WXS and TES, respectively. When the identified tumor-specific mutations were evaluated in differentially preserved specimens, only 55 and 90 of the mutations identified by WXS were at the same location in both matched FFPE and frozen specimens, and of these 54 and 88 had concordant sequence, respectively. Similarly, 6 and 5 of the tumor-specific mutations were identified at the same location in the two matched FFPE and frozen specimens by TES, respectively and in both cases 5 of these had concordant sequence.

  • Biospecimens

    TissueBreast
    TissueOvary
    TissueColorectal
  • Preservation Types

    FormalinFrozen
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
    NeoplasticNormal Adjacent
  • Platforms

    DNADNA microarray
    DNANext generation sequencing
    DNASNP assay
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionBiospecimen location
    Normal adjacent
    Tumor
    Biospecimen PreservationType of fixation/preservation
    Formalin (buffered)
    Snap frozen
    Next generation sequencing SpecificTechnology platform
    BeadArray
    TES
    WGS
    WXS