This paper compared the diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and negative predictive values for malignancy of 14-gauge (G) core needle biopsies (CNB) and 22-G fine needle biopsies (FNB).
Diagnostic Accuracy and Safety of CT-Guided Percutaneous Transthoracic Needle Biopsies: 14-Gauge versus 22-Gauge Needles.
Ocak S, Duplaquet F, Jamart J, Pirard L, Weynand B, Delos M, Eucher P, Rondelet B, Dupont M, Delaunois L, Sibille Y, Dahlqvist C
Purpose
Conclusion
Use of a 14-G needle more frequently allowed for the collection of more than one specimen. However, 14-G CNB and 22-G FNB had comparable overall diagnostic accuracy, as well as cancer-specific diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and negative predictive value for malignancy. Importantly, it was possible to assign a defined cancer subtype in a significantly higher percentage of malignancies biopsied with a 14-G than a 22-G needle.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and negative predictive values for malignancy of computed tomography (CT)-guided transthoracic 14-G CNB and 22-G FNB. The 102 14-G CNB (99 patients) were performed using a 15 cm long Spirotome device by two physicians and the 102 22-G FNB (92 patients) were performed using a 15 cm Rotex device by three physicians. FNBs were fixed with lacquer or a 50% ethanol solution for cytological analysis and CNB were fixed in formalin. Final diagnosis was determined by follow-up or by surgical resection.
Summary of Findings
Although more than 1 specimen was obtained from 92% of patients who underwent 14-G CNB, more than one specimen was obtained from only 22% of patients who underwent 22-G FNB (P<0.001). However, 14-G CNB and 22-G FNB had comparable overall diagnostic accuracy (90% versus 82%), as well as cancer-specific diagnostic accuracy (94% versus 89%), sensitivity (91% versus 84%), specificity (100% versus 93%), and negative predictive value (78% versus 50%) for malignancy. Importantly, it was possible to assign a defined cancer subtype in 69 of 71 (97%) malignancies biopsied with a 14-G needle but only 47 of 73 (67%) of malignancies biopsied with a 22-G FNB (P<0.001). While major complications occurred at comparable rates with the two needle types, partial pneumothorax occurred more frequently following 14-G CNB than 22-G FNB (24% versus 7%, P=0.002).
Biospecimens
CellLungCellPleural FluidTissueLungPreservation Types
EthanolOther PreservativeFormalinDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaNeoplasticBenignEmphysemaPneumonia/Respiratory InfectionNot specifiedPlatforms
MorphologyLight microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Needle gauge 14-G CNB22-G FNB