This paper investigated the effects of increasing the number of biopsy levels on the diagnostic accuracy of calcified breast lesions.
Examination of breast needle core biopsy specimens performed for screen-detected microcalcification.
Kumaraswamy V, Carder PJ
Purpose
Conclusion
While an accurate diagnosis was possible based only on the first 3 levels in 89% of cases, the diagnosis changed in 9% of cases after evaluation of levels 4-6, and the diagnosis was upgraded after examination of levels 7-9 for 3% of cases. As proper procedure would have resulted in additional levels or excision in 10 of these cases, the authors state that in only one case the use of only 6 levels rather than 9 would have resulted in a missed diagnosis. Despite not affecting diagnosis, levels 7-9 were found to yield additional information in 18% of cases.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of increasing the number of biopsy levels on the diagnostic accuracy of calcified breast lesions. Needle core biopsies were obtained using a 14-gauge biopsy gun from 100 patients with screening-detected calcification. Methods of preservation were not discussed but are assumed to include formalin fixation.
Summary of Findings
An accurate diagnosis was obtained based on examination of only the first three levels in 89 (89%) of cases, but the remaining 11 cases required examination of additional levels. After investigation of levels 4-6, eight of these cases were upgraded from B1 (inadequate or normal) to B2 (benign) and one case was upgraded from B4 (suspicious of malignancy) to B5a (DCIS). After examination of levels 7-9, one of these cases was further upgraded from benign B2 to B4 (suspicious of DCIS). The remaining 2 cases were only upgraded from B1 (inadequate or normal) to B2 (benign) and from B3 (uncertain malignant potential) to B4 (suspicious of DCIS) after examination of levels 7-9. The authors note that proper procedure would require additional levels from one of these specimens and that an initial diagnosis of B3 would result in excision, so only in one case would examination of fewer levels have resulted in a missed diagnosis. While not critical for diagnosis, examination of levels 7-9 excluded calcification in six cases, excluded invasion or microinvasion of DCIS in five cases, allowed for a more thorough assessment of epithelial proliferation in five cases and more thoroughly showed the diagnostic changes in two cases.
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FormalinDiagnoses
NeoplasticBenignNeoplasticCarcinomaNormalPlatforms
ProteinImmunohistochemistryMorphologyH-and-E microscopyMorphologyLight microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Aliquots and Components Biospecimen heterogeneity Intratumoral sampling (exact positions not specified)Sampling at multiple levels