This paper investigated the effects of core number, lesion characteristics, and operator experience on the diagnostic accuracy of benign and malignant breast lesions.
Percutaneous core biopsy of the breast: effect of operator experience and number of samples on diagnostic accuracy.
Brenner RJ, Fajardo L, Fisher PR, Dershaw DD, Evans WP, Bassett L, Feig S, Mendelson E, Jackson V, Margolin FR
Purpose
Conclusion
Overall, malignant and benign diagnostic accuracy increased with increasing number of biopsies. The sensitivity was higher for invasive cancer than for DCIS in malignant lesions, regardless of the number of cores examined. The diagnostic accuracy of the first core was highest for masses with or without calcifications but after 5 cores, was highest for biopsies with calcifications or focal asymmetries. As the operators gained experience, the accuracy of diagnosis increased such that fewer cores were necessary to obtain comparable diagnostic accuracy.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study investigated the effects of core number, lesion characteristics, and operator experience on the diagnostic accuracy of benign and malignant breast lesions. Five CNB specimens collected with a 14-gauge needle and matched excisional specimens were obtained from 230 asymptomatic women following mammography at 9 different hospitals. Diagnosis of the CNB was compared with the diagnosis based on the surgical specimen.
Summary of Findings
An accurate diagnosis was achieved using the first CNB in 83% (193 of 230) of cases and the rate of diagnostic accuracy increased with each additional biopsy. The overall diagnostic sensitivity of five biopsies for malignant and benign lesions was 96% (135 of 140) and 96% (70 of 73 cases), respectively; but the sensitivity of a single biopsy for was only 84% (123 of 141 cases) for malignant lesions and 79% (58 of 73 cases) for benign lesions. When all 5 biopsies were examined, the sensitivity for invasive cancer was 99% (128 of 129 cases) but the diagnostic sensitivity of the five biopsies for DCIS was only 67% (8 of 12 cases) with three of the missed cases being DCIS of the noncomedo subtype. Similarly, the diagnostic sensitivity of the first biopsy was 92% for invasive carcinoma but only 42% for DCIS. Diagnostic accuracy of the first core was highest for masses without calcification (96%) followed by those with calcifications (87%), but increased with increasing cores and after five cores was highest for biopsies with calcifications and focal asymmetries (both 100% after five biopsies). Although small lesions tended to need more cores to obtain an accurate diagnosis, the effect of lesion size was not significant. As the operator gained experience during the study, the accuracy of diagnosis increased such that fewer cores were necessary to obtain comparable diagnostic accuracy.
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FormalinNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaNeoplasticBenignPlatforms
MorphologyX-rayMorphologyLight microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition BenignDCISInvasive carcinomaPreaquisition Prognostic factor 2-100 mm lesionArchitectural distortionCalcificationFocal asymmetriesMass with calcificationNon-calcified massBiospecimen Acquisition Method of tissue acquisition Staff performing tissue acquisition comparedBiospecimen Aliquots and Components Biospecimen heterogeneity Intratumoral sampling (exact positions not specified)